Cliff Stamp
BANNED
- Joined
- Oct 5, 1998
- Messages
- 17,562
collecter said:I don't understand how you guys can recommend this knife without qualifying the handle.
I have no use for partial grip knives either from an ergonomics/security issue. I have had a few customs with small two/three finger grips and they are fine for light precision cutting, but in extended work they get bad fast. Even on very small blades I like a full grip.
Knives that are so grip limited are generally reserved as backup pieces which allow you to carry a knife whereas a full sized grip would make it too difficult to conceal. It is more of a case of better this than nothing rather than an actual optimal designed tool.
USAFSP said:Then how can Cliff not recommend the knife without even touching it?
I didn't actually do that in this case, in the original post I just talked about several other knives of that same type. However there are lots of knives I would not recommend even though I have not handled them because of basic design or steel issues.
If it was impossible to infer anything performance wise from pictures and spec's it would be impossible for makers to design knives, and likewise impossible for users to actually shop for knives. The whole process would consist of random actions which would hopefully lead somewhere. This is obviously false.
Yes you can tell more from use and the more use the better, and yes when knives get really similar in design it is near impossible to judge them from spec's especially when they have several which give them an advantage but others which are drawbacks, so it can be difficult to say exactly which will come out on top.
-Cliff