I certainly feel the BF has done one of the best jobs at the administration side and I don't have any complaints or much advise for changes/improvements at the moment to function or design. The last trick with forums staying alive and relevant is content and we the users are the source for this content and it is our job to contribute to the content of the forum to further aid in user retention and growth which again I believe BF has managed to capture a great user base for the continuation of its place and purpose..
Well, I agree with your assessment of the user content. THIS is the most valuable commodity in forums.
Best job
admin? Moderators are GREAT! Admin? Ummmmm.
As a business owner I am sadly unimpressed with the response to the 'problems'. Visit the Service and Support forums for a 25 page dialog on server
slowness.
My pet peeve is that showing photos continues to be WAYYY overcomplicated. (Host them on IMGUR! it's FREE!) Yeah, and it's the whole upload/host/link/copy size, paste, etc... Why?
At a
paying membership I would MOST certainly expect my fees to cover the cost of photo storage (Photos take up SO little space compared to videos.) The Forum software has the ability to downsize ALL images to postable size,
right from your phone. Not now, though. The owner has stalled upgrading. to the latest version for I-don't-know-what reason. Since the amount of queries in that forum is about 50% image hosting related, I say get ON it. It's part of running a GOOD business.
(I would continue showing new work in my sticky Gallery, but I refuse to have to host this on my own, or go through hoops to 'fit' the filesize upload requirements which are too stringent. Let the Xenforo software take care of that. Like
other forums do running this software.
As to forums I love the comradery and knowledge shared here, along with the show and tell aspect and sales. I’ve seen several gun forums with great information see a sudden influx of new members who seem to take over and drive out the old guard then eventually the whole devolves into a classified add and there is little to no knowledge or discussion. I can only hope that does not happen here.
As I type there are 15 makers on two pages showing their work. 90% of them are somewhat new (to me), and rarely (never?) enter dialog in this forum, save for their own threads. It's right here and now, just as you described.
Social media has been mostly positive. Facebook gets the occasional "like" but Instagram has been great.
The whole ADD, short attention span, instant gratification thing is just a part of our disposable society now. We still see that mindset today in all areas of our lives; marriages, politics, jobs, you name it. So I think people just don't have the will or patience to engage in a dialog. That takes time, thought, manners, consideration of another's perspective and sometimes it takes a thick skin. And people are so easily offended these days. When I began visiting BF I was a new maker (still am). I wanted to hear what the older guys had to say. The guys who had been doing this for decades were exchanging perspectives and ideas, telling stories, and I was the fly on the wall trying to learn. Now most of those folks have lost patience with the disrespect, the inexperienced opining, personal attacks etc. and gone away. So we are left with a lot of newer makers and mid level guys that just want to show their work.
I have heard it said that print is dead. I hope not. I still enjoy books and magazines. There is something special about books. And being published in print format means something. It means some person or committee has considered and judged your work as worthy of inclusion in their publication. These days almost anyone with the slightest computer savvy can post pictures on a variety of social media platforms or websites, or to even build your own website. There is little culling or process of elimination, debate, considering the relevance to an accompanying topic or article, discerning small differences in the sharpness or composition or lighting of the photographs. Snap a pic, send it to the web. Done. Next.
Thank you Coop for not just taking great photos but for your support of the work you photograph. Your contacts and submissions made on behalf of the makers help to get us published and help to legitimize us in the community. Thank you. I hope print will never die.
Great commentary on FiF. LOL! Game Show! with a side helping of education, and a LOT of drama as gravy.
"So we are left with a lot of newer makers.... that just want to show their work."
Sadly correct.
Instagram is great, I am able to post works in progress, showcase work and answer questions and my knives typically sell there first even if I put them up for sale here.
Last year the $75 knifemaker fee did not even pay for itself here on Bladeforums.
It is a nice place to chat about knives but it is not a really an asset for sales anymore for me.
Interesting. IG has become SO powerful, so one needs to offer something different and BETTER to retain satisfied members.
This forum was KING for years. Now it's changed. Hence my original opinions in the post.