I've never paddled a Merrimack but have lusted after them, as with most higher end canoes. If I am remembering correctly, the Crossville factory is where Blue Hole sent some of their canoes to be dressed out in ash. Yeah, I would love to have a fine canoe, but it would not fit into my uses. I have two Old Town "tupperware boats" now and am looking to get a third, hopefully the Two Brothers Arkota, this spring. I always wanted a nice wood and canvas Chestnut, but I would beat the bottom out of it in no time in the shallow, rocky streams I frequent. And a Merrimack would be no different. Beautiful craftsmanship, but requiring more care in use, more maintenance and better storage facilities than I have.
Why three canoes? One is a light, short solo, the 119K which is a cheaper version of the Pack. Great for quick trips to the river to wet a line or just enjoy a short paddle. It cartops with no problem. I liken it to an economy car. I would have the Pack if I could find one at a bargain.
The much longer 169 will hold a lot of weight, is wide and stable. I can take my grown daughter, her young daughter and Jake without worrying about us all becoming swimmers. It is a bit big for just me and Jake, even when we do overnighters, but I do solo it frequently. And it's width, keel and weight make it less maneuverable. So it is like the station wagon.
The Arkota, if it is what I wind up with, is a crossover canoe between the flatwater touring and whitewater canoes. More like the old Blue Hole OCA and Perception canoes of the same era. While narrower and with more rocker than my OT169, it still has length enough for decent tracking and speed, but can be maneuvered in currents better.
All three have forgiving plastic hulls and vinyl gunnels and wood furniture. And when I finish modifying my canoe trailer, I can carry all three easily when I have guests. And I can offload all but one onto my racks, whichever I choose, when I go on a quick trip to the river. Which I do as often as I can. I intend to do so until the day I can't which is not that far in the future.