Cory Hess
Basic Member
- Joined
- Jul 1, 2014
- Messages
- 2,117
The PM2 is the epitome of a middle of the road folder in my opinion. It's got a lot going for it, but nothing crazy good that really stands out.
The pros:
Ergonomics - The handle is comfortable for me in just about every position. There are no significant hot spots in any grip that I would normally use.
Compression Lock - It's my favorite Spyderco lock. I love the ingenuity, though in use it's no better or worse than other common locks. I do like that it allows the scales to be more uniform than something like a frame lock.
Light Weight - For the size and sturdiness the PM2 is amazingly light weight.
Blade Shape - I know that a lot of people complain about the handle to blade ratio, but I find this to be overblown. I've found the PM2's blade profile to be extremely versatile and the length of both the handle and blade is similar to other 3.5" folders. Compared to my XM-18 (4.75" handle vs. 3.5" blade) the PM2's (4.812" handle vs. 3.438" blade) measurements might be a little worse, but in hand they feel about the same lengthwise. Maybe I'm just not refined enough to detect a couple hundredths of an inch difference.
Lack of Jimping - One thing that I dislike in a lot of knives is excessive jimping. It's the biggest negative that the Manix 2 has in my opinion. There's aggressive jimping all over that thing. The PM2 has jimping in the choil and around the thumb ramp and that's it. The jimping that's there isn't too aggressive.
Lefty Version - The biggest plus in my book is that Spyderco made a version especially for us lefties.
The cons:
Flatness - Spyderco's treatment of G10 is pretty uninspired. There is no contouring at all. They cut the appropriate shape out of a flat slab of G10 and that's it. It would be nice if there was some rounding of the edges or chamfering or texturing or anything other than a flat, blocky slab.
Action - There is nothing especially bad about the action of the PM2, but compared to similar knives it's not fantastic. The Manix 2 for example gives the feel of a much higher quality. I think it's due to the consistency of resistance that the Manix has. It's similar to a Hinderer or CRK, not as good mind you but similar. The PM2 on the other hand has detent, then looseness, then a click as the liner pops back into the detent, and then the lock. It's not terrible, but not nearly as good as other alternatives.
Not Enough Standoffs - There should be another standoff just behind the lock. I don't know i this would mechanically affect the function of the lock, but there's a big gap between the front standoff and the stop pin. This makes the knife flex if I grip it tightly. It doesn't affect function at all, but it does affect the feeling of quality.
Overall, I'd rate the PM2 a 6 out of 10. There's a lot to like about it, but there are some things that could have been done better in my opinion. These things are all my preferences, so I'm not suggesting that anything should have been done differently. I'm saying that for me other knives check more boxes. For example, I prefer the Manix 2 to the PM2. The only negatives that knife has are the weight and jimping. For 25% less money, it's a much better buy in my opinion. I don't think that either is a bad buy though.
The pros:
Ergonomics - The handle is comfortable for me in just about every position. There are no significant hot spots in any grip that I would normally use.
Compression Lock - It's my favorite Spyderco lock. I love the ingenuity, though in use it's no better or worse than other common locks. I do like that it allows the scales to be more uniform than something like a frame lock.
Light Weight - For the size and sturdiness the PM2 is amazingly light weight.
Blade Shape - I know that a lot of people complain about the handle to blade ratio, but I find this to be overblown. I've found the PM2's blade profile to be extremely versatile and the length of both the handle and blade is similar to other 3.5" folders. Compared to my XM-18 (4.75" handle vs. 3.5" blade) the PM2's (4.812" handle vs. 3.438" blade) measurements might be a little worse, but in hand they feel about the same lengthwise. Maybe I'm just not refined enough to detect a couple hundredths of an inch difference.
Lack of Jimping - One thing that I dislike in a lot of knives is excessive jimping. It's the biggest negative that the Manix 2 has in my opinion. There's aggressive jimping all over that thing. The PM2 has jimping in the choil and around the thumb ramp and that's it. The jimping that's there isn't too aggressive.
Lefty Version - The biggest plus in my book is that Spyderco made a version especially for us lefties.
The cons:
Flatness - Spyderco's treatment of G10 is pretty uninspired. There is no contouring at all. They cut the appropriate shape out of a flat slab of G10 and that's it. It would be nice if there was some rounding of the edges or chamfering or texturing or anything other than a flat, blocky slab.
Action - There is nothing especially bad about the action of the PM2, but compared to similar knives it's not fantastic. The Manix 2 for example gives the feel of a much higher quality. I think it's due to the consistency of resistance that the Manix has. It's similar to a Hinderer or CRK, not as good mind you but similar. The PM2 on the other hand has detent, then looseness, then a click as the liner pops back into the detent, and then the lock. It's not terrible, but not nearly as good as other alternatives.
Not Enough Standoffs - There should be another standoff just behind the lock. I don't know i this would mechanically affect the function of the lock, but there's a big gap between the front standoff and the stop pin. This makes the knife flex if I grip it tightly. It doesn't affect function at all, but it does affect the feeling of quality.
Overall, I'd rate the PM2 a 6 out of 10. There's a lot to like about it, but there are some things that could have been done better in my opinion. These things are all my preferences, so I'm not suggesting that anything should have been done differently. I'm saying that for me other knives check more boxes. For example, I prefer the Manix 2 to the PM2. The only negatives that knife has are the weight and jimping. For 25% less money, it's a much better buy in my opinion. I don't think that either is a bad buy though.