Interesting thread...
Photon vs. ASP...from real world use not in the military.
The ASP suffers from the fact it is not available in colors (at least where I shop). If you want BLUE, great. Too bad it's not my favorite color. That clip is very handy, much easier to use routinely (ASP fits as a zipper pull on a coat easily, will you put an o-ring photon there?). The case size is a little large for my tastes, I like its rubber pad to turn it on but, the constant on feature is missing. The ASP is cheaper, all things considered so, you can have multiple units around to suffice for ones that need batteries without breaking the bank.
The Photon has advantages and disadvantes as well, most of which have already been covered above. These things don't resist water very well. A light rain in my pocket is not a problem, dropping them in the sink is. I really don't like unscrewing the case to turn it off when the bulb is glowing dimly. The fact that it is offered in many colors and brightness patterns and levels, is very nice, wish ASP would do the same. Some have a very good spread for area light, some a tight beam for pin point light, some are dim enough to use in the cockpit with out blinding the pilots and, others will adequately light a small back yard to find dogs and kids (not to mention avoiding things like toys and snakes that may lay in your path). Since it is so small and light weight, I find I have it everywhere I need it, whereas the ASP is clipped to briefcase or backpack which may not be within reach all the time.
Bigger lights...UnderWater Kinetics..
For the money, UnderWater Kinetics is the way to go. The 3 models I recommend are the little AAA light (a tad larger then older car alarm remotes and is "key chain-able"), the 4AA light (the flat case with 2 side by side pairs stacked) which fits in the palm your hand nicely, and the UKE2L for those who want the reliability of Lithium batteries but don't want to spend $40 on a light. These lights all have great beam quality, high light output, stand up to real life (rain, falls, etc.) well. When you consider they are only marginally more expensive then what you buy at Wal-mart and they always work (unless you run the batteries completely out), why throw your money away on a cheap flashlight that won't work a week later? UKE also offers many different color cases so, Yellow, Black, Safety Orange, etc are options for those that care. The twist off head means they won't come on accidently and are highly water resistent.
Mag-lites....
Beam quality in these are generally pretty bad, especially if you've been using some of the UKE's mentioned above. The beam has hot spots and shadows and, the variable focus is part of the reason why. If you shim the bulb properly to center it in the head and put it far enough forward to work properly, you can improve things some
. These are generally heavy enough and large enough that you won't have them on you
when you need them, if you're lucky you can find one the trunk of your car at a road side somewhere when needed. They won't be there after you leave the mall to check the interior of the car for bag guys and such.
Carley
lamps and RadioShack High Capacity Ni-Cad's go along way to improving this light. In fact, given the option of buying a Sure-Fire or a Carley'ized Mag-lite, I'll take the improved Mag-lite. Beam quality is improved (they can only do so much with a bad reflector design) but, OUTPUT! Lots of light
OUTPUT
. And since they are Ni-Cad powered, you can actually afford to use them routinely
, unlike Lithium powered lights
. With a standard bulb, you can milk the setup for really long run times
.
The larger Streamlights also should be mentioned here. Their recharge solution is the most convenient I have found and, they have plenty of good quality light with acceptable run times. They do cost more then most but, give you a better solution for the money.
For Tactical lights....
The two choices are Streamlight or SureFire. For a small non-rechargeable lights, the SureFires offer the package that fits me the best in their "Z" solution. In the rechargeables, the small Streamlights get the nod. With lithium batteries providing such short run times and high replacement expense, I tend to think most people would be happier spending a little extra and getting the smaller Streamlight rechargeable Tactical Lights.
I've rambled enough here...
Sid
[This message has been edited by Sid Post (edited 02 July 1999).]