Pick one.

[mbkr]

The 3 Dwarves: Queen, Schatt-M, GEC. Bone, Stag, Blackwood

Queen

 

[Ironbut]

In no particular order:

 

[mbkr]

Hobson's Choice ?

I think a Hobson's Choice is a choice between one or nothing.
I'd take the Bird Dog

 

[mbkr]

In no particular order:
View attachment 1941583View attachment 1941584View attachment 1941589

Tough one.
The Eureka Jack.

 

[Old Engineer]

Choose one for your next camping trip:

Top one

Harry

 

[Old Engineer]

View attachment 1941384

Dan.

Middle one .

Harry

 

[Old Engineer]

In no particular order:
View attachment 1941583View attachment 1941584View attachment 1941589

Middle one

Harry

 

[Old Engineer]

View attachment 1941479

Which one for whittling ?

Dan.

I know NOTHING about whittling but I like the top one

Harry

 

[Old Engineer]

Hobson's Choice ?

I pick the top one because of the Blade

Harry

 

[Old Engineer]

The 3 Dwarves: Queen, Schatt-M, GEC. Bone, Stag, Blackwood

Pick small S&M Small Barlow

Harry

 

[dantzk8]

Great stuff you've been showing

Would take the F&F lockback from an earlier post, sturdy!

Bottom one please... even if it does have an end-cap... 78 or 79? can't remember the difference.

Thanks Will,
The bottom one is a 78, very well made.

Dan.

 

[Old Engineer]

One days carry from a while back
Northfield Dark Brewed 83 , or Henckles Barlow , or Case Barlow .

Three Northfield 72's that I had in 2016 and I gifted 2 of them at Christmas that year and i still have one of them . Which one ????

Three that I got at one of the Rendezvous . # 1 and #3 are GEC'S

Northfields 73 , 74 , and 74

Harry

 

[dantzk8]

62

I know NOTHING about whittling but I like the top one

Harry

Harry,

It's a Queen. If you ever decide to experiment with wood whittling , then believe Jiki, the 62 is the one for you.

Dan.

 

[Th.H.]

View attachment 1941479

Which one for whittling ?

Dan.

#62 for me

 

[Hickory n steel]

I'm going to cheat a little bit here and post 4 instead of just 3.
You've got different covers, blade grinds, shields if at all, and bolster materials to choose from.
If I remember correctly the 1st is also in 425m as apposed to the standard 420hc of the other 3, so theres that choice to make as well.

 

[Sventhelumberjack]

In no particular order:
View attachment 1941583View attachment 1941584View attachment 1941589

Wow! Cattle knife in Antique jig bone for me please!

 

[Marlingspike12]

Mercator. I prefer spearpoints.

 

[Will Power]

I think a Hobson's Choice is a choice between one or nothing.
I'd take the Bird Dog

Kind of... in this case you're correct- the Barehead 2 blade has been sold and the 56 Pruner is NEVER going away

Bird Dog is cool though, not a poor option

Thanks, Will

 

[Will Power]

MAM Muito obrigado. Por que? I have a mess of Opinels, like them a lot, if the top one is a Chinese copy that attracts me less and the MAM locks

 

[Will Power]

What about these 3, though?

(Sorry to say, but I believe Barrett’s is a Chinese knock-off)

Bottom one. Looks like a fish...and I think would probably be easier to get out of the pocket than the other too. Really would like to get hold of one of these workers.