I certainly know that issues can happen, and there's pattern or two that I don't think they can get right from what I've seen.
I've been very lucky mostly just having gotten nice and slightly less nice knives, but people can have different expectations and standards for what constitutes a nice knife.
With my Cheetah Cub I'll be checking the W&T, overall tight fitment , and I'm hoping for an edge that's fairly even & consistent on both sides.
I'll except a hint of blade play to a point, and don't consider any issues that I have to go out of my way to notice.
Politely, what this says is "I am ok with flaws" even though you spent time calling out
S
ShaiHulud
for
not being accepting of flaws.
I have something like 50 or 60 Case knives, spanning decades of production, and plenty of them have some issue or other. Bad grinds, blade play (I do not accept blade play in a slipjoint, sorry, I just don't), gaps in scales, backsprings, etc. I actually posted on the board how about a month ago, I was at my local ACE and perusing the fresh batch of Case knives they'd gotten in and every single one of them had blunt tips on all blades. It was actually bizarre. Like, the grinds all ended half a millimeter from the tips. Trappers, Stockmans, several other models. It was crazy to me that that many knives passed QC with such poor grinds. BUT. They were pretty, and the scales on the fifteen or so knives I personally inspected were nice looking, and the blades were polished. That's probably why, when I went in last week, most of that batch had sold. So clearly, blunt tips (a major QC defect) weren't a big deal to some folks, though they were to me.
In any case, I have had to send multiple Case knives back in the last year for QC issues. Others, I've gotten and they've been perfect. It's just such a wild swing, you never know what you're going to get. These days, I try to only buy Case knives I've manually inspected, or I buy from a dealer who has no issue with returns. So, ShaiHulud's experience is neither surprising nor all that uncommon.