I thought NJ was kinda like the populated areas of CA. "May Issue" - but good luck with that.
I haven't even bothered to try. Compared to a lot of people, I'd have a tough time proving any kind of "need."
A friend - who applied, and got denied, told me of a friend of his (in the SF Bay area.) Former military - honorary discharge. Former CIA agent. Private Investigator. Clean record. Sheriff denied.
I hear in NY it depends on where you live, and in and around the city - how rich and/or famous you are. Tanker, you should've told 'em about your celebrity status.