I've researched this question, and there are several threads on it, but they all seem to turn into all fixed vs folders in general, not just the 3" range, or the threads start to sway toward only outdoor carry.
Here's what I already understand from previous threads and see what each has going for it.
Fixed blades:
are easier to clean/sanitize
usually cost less for the same amount/type of steel
have no pivot, so dirt/debris cannot muck up opening/closing
Ties:
Safety - Fixed blades are safer in hand, but less safe when not in hand (folders' blades are encased within handle using steel pivot pins/liners).
Ease of Access - Thinking this is a tie because it can usually go both ways: a belt/pocket sheath knife is easier to get out, but harder to put back into the sheath than a folder into your pocket, and I just personally don't consider neck knives, but they are somewhat tied because EDCing one means it will be under a shirt but carrying one in the woods will be easier to access.
Folders:
Length/Weight is more convenient
Generally considered more public friendly than sheath knife
I already have one, why pay for something I already have covered? (besides just wanting one)
I can see why people carry them: because they like them more, they don't trust folders' locks, they don't like opening/closing the blade with their fingers -- these are more personal advantages.
I'm really interested to hear what you all think are any remaining practical advantages of a 3"-3.5" fixed blade over a 3"-3.5" folder. The quick answer always seems to be that the fixed blade is stronger, but stronger for what? What does anyone use a 3"-3.5" fixed blade for that would break a folder of similar size?? The only thing I can think of is prying, but won't that break any knife tip that's thin enough?? Does anyone who EDCs a fixed blade do anything with it that would break a Buck 110 or a thick ZT??
Basically, I'm trying to get someone to talk me into thinking that I need a BK14 Eskabar. I just want to know if it will accomplish anything that my Buck Vantage Pro or USA Schrade folders shouldn't be used for.
I did see quite a few posts about how a folder's blade is already broken, so why would you want to use a blade that's already broken?? Well, I got to thinking, it actually isn't broken. If a folder's blade were broken, it would look like this...
Thanks, guys, I'm counting on y'all.
Here's what I already understand from previous threads and see what each has going for it.
Fixed blades:
are easier to clean/sanitize
usually cost less for the same amount/type of steel
have no pivot, so dirt/debris cannot muck up opening/closing
Ties:
Safety - Fixed blades are safer in hand, but less safe when not in hand (folders' blades are encased within handle using steel pivot pins/liners).
Ease of Access - Thinking this is a tie because it can usually go both ways: a belt/pocket sheath knife is easier to get out, but harder to put back into the sheath than a folder into your pocket, and I just personally don't consider neck knives, but they are somewhat tied because EDCing one means it will be under a shirt but carrying one in the woods will be easier to access.
Folders:
Length/Weight is more convenient
Generally considered more public friendly than sheath knife
I already have one, why pay for something I already have covered? (besides just wanting one)
I can see why people carry them: because they like them more, they don't trust folders' locks, they don't like opening/closing the blade with their fingers -- these are more personal advantages.
I'm really interested to hear what you all think are any remaining practical advantages of a 3"-3.5" fixed blade over a 3"-3.5" folder. The quick answer always seems to be that the fixed blade is stronger, but stronger for what? What does anyone use a 3"-3.5" fixed blade for that would break a folder of similar size?? The only thing I can think of is prying, but won't that break any knife tip that's thin enough?? Does anyone who EDCs a fixed blade do anything with it that would break a Buck 110 or a thick ZT??
Basically, I'm trying to get someone to talk me into thinking that I need a BK14 Eskabar. I just want to know if it will accomplish anything that my Buck Vantage Pro or USA Schrade folders shouldn't be used for.
I did see quite a few posts about how a folder's blade is already broken, so why would you want to use a blade that's already broken?? Well, I got to thinking, it actually isn't broken. If a folder's blade were broken, it would look like this...
Thanks, guys, I'm counting on y'all.