praetorian info ?

Raphael.caluwe

Raphael.caluwe

Joined
Sep 24, 2010
Messages
273
hi
I love the look of the mkt praetorian, but i can't seem to justify 700$ for a knife that does not seem to have a use.
i'm looking for an excuse to buy one, so please enlighten me, what is good about the praetorian. the blade is soooo big, it resembles a shovel more than a knife. in what use is it better than a hinderer which is about the same price ?
 
What makes the praetorian better than a Hinderer?

Hype.

In all seriousness, get a Hinderer if you are willing to drop that much coin. You will wind up with a much more functional cutting tool.
 
As a fixed blade, the emperor has a use because it really is a sharpened prybar. As a folder.....not sure the use for the praetorian???
 
Ask yourself what you're looking for a knife. With a lot of high-end custom and production knives, you're paying for more than strict utility.

A Ford will get you to work just as well as a Mercedes. You're looking at style, preference, fashion, materials, maker reputation, collectibility, and all sorts of other things.
 
RobertK pretty much nailed it on the head.

If your really looking for an all around EDC and great slicer than the Pretorian IMO wouldn't be your best choice.

Now don't get it twisted, I love the Pretorian and will own one very soon.

However it is a large carry and even though contrary to some belief, can slice half way decent.

But remember there are a ton of amazing Custom Knife makers you can get knives from that may suit your needs, not your "wants".

If you like overbuilt folders though I would highly suggest just going for it and getting a Pretorian.

:D
 
Medford's are pretty expensive for a manufactured knife. I would rather get on Yunas list, or a Direware's. Also Demko's.

Of course, since they are not really handmade, they have higher production numbers meaning little to no wait list.

What about a Begg Bodega Field Grade? 1 month list or so and its got IKBS and a usable blade.
 
I don't understand the fascination with pocket bricks. A knife like that will not cut well. It does not have the geometry to do so.

Try this. Buy an Opinel #8. Carry and use it exclusively for a full month. Then see if you still want a pocket brick.
 
Thick folders also have their uses. It literally comes down to preference and style. I personally own 3 praetorians..(1 praetorian ti, and 2 praetorian t's) They are large, and are not the ideal EDC carry, HOWEVER, they do cut well and on top of that, can chop down a tree, or pry open anything. I also own a RJ Martin Q36...totally different knife for a totally different use...Both have their places. Choose a knife that you feel compliments what you are looking to use it for, and if you can afford it, buy it. If not, find something in your price range and do the same calculations. Just my 2 cents...
 
gktii said:
Thick folders also have their uses. It literally comes down to preference and style. I personally own 3 praetorians..(1 praetorian ti, and 2 praetorian t's) They are large, and are not the ideal EDC carry, HOWEVER, they do cut well and on top of that, can chop down a tree, or pry open anything. I also own a RJ Martin Q36...totally different knife for a totally different use...Both have their places. Choose a knife that you feel compliments what you are looking to use it for, and if you can afford it, buy it. If not, find something in your price range and do the same calculations. Just my 2 cents...
Click to expand...
They cut well compared to what? It's a simple matter of geometry. Thick prybar type knives do not cut well. You can chop down a tree with a folder? :confused:
 
Say your hiking or camping and you want to do some chopping. Medium sized tree limbs for a latrine or shelter or fire or cooking appliance. Are you going to use your XM? You could bring a hatchet or a machete (Love my Junglas BTW) or you can use a praetorian and a baton. Seriously, it's like an axe blade with handles... I just bought one and it's ridiculous (in a good way).

YES, you can chop down a tree with a folder....
 
Fanglekai said:
I don't understand the fascination with pocket bricks. A knife like that will not cut well. It does not have the geometry to do so.

Try this. Buy an Opinel #8. Carry and use it exclusively for a full month. Then see if you still want a pocket brick.
Click to expand...

Won't cut what well? Paper? If you want to cut through a tree branch the size of your wrist the praetorian will chop through it pretty quick. XM or an Opinel might take a bit longer to whittle. Again, what is the purpose of the knife? If you don't like carrying a fixed blade chopper on your hip then the praetorian in a belt sheath could be your solution.
 
Fanglekai said:
They cut well compared to what? It's a simple matter of geometry. Thick prybar type knives do not cut well. You can chop down a tree with a folder? :confused:
Click to expand...

i'll take a praetorian over a "paper cutter" any day....far more uses than a hinderer....nothing wrong with those types of knives, but far less can be done with a sharp, easily breakable blade...a praetorian can cover much more ground than any "sharp" knife can....live in the jungle for awhile and you'll be begging for a "pocket brick"...
 
Maprik said:
Say your hiking or camping and you want to do some chopping. Medium sized tree limbs for a latrine or shelter or fire or cooking appliance. Are you going to use your XM? You could bring a hatchet or a machete (Love my Junglas BTW) or you can use a praetorian and a baton. Seriously, it's like an axe blade with handles... I just bought one and it's ridiculous (in a good way).

YES, you can chop down a tree with a folder....
Click to expand...

Why would I randomly want to do some chopping? Why would I take an XM hiking? A $40 Silky Super Accel weighs 7 oz and will easily saw through medium size tree limbs with ease. Or I could use a fixed blade like a Becker instead of a $700 folder. YMMV.

Maprik said:
Won't cut what well? Paper? If you want to cut through a tree branch the size of your wrist the praetorian will chop through it pretty quick. XM or an Opinel might take a bit longer to whittle. Again, what is the purpose of the knife? If you don't like carrying a fixed blade chopper on your hip then the praetorian in a belt sheath could be your solution.
Click to expand...

Did you say cut in this quotation, or was it "chop"? I read "chop". It won't chop as well as a dedicated chopping tool and it won't cut as well as a dedicated cutting tool. Why would you ask me what the purpose of this knife is? I'm not the designer. It looks like a pocket brick designed to fulfill some tactical operator fantasy. That's what I think its purpose is. Other people might have varying opinions. YMMV.

gktii said:
i'll take a praetorian over a "paper cutter" any day....far more uses than a hinderer....nothing wrong with those types of knives, but far less can be done with a sharp, easily breakable blade...a praetorian can cover much more ground than any "sharp" knife can....live in the jungle for awhile and you'll be begging for a "pocket brick"...
Click to expand...

You have extensive jungle experience? I'm surprised anyone would want a $700 folder in the jungle. I'd rather have a machete. YMMV.
 
gktii said:
i'll take a praetorian over a "paper cutter" any day....far more uses than a hinderer....nothing wrong with those types of knives, but far less can be done with a sharp, easily breakable blade...a praetorian can cover much more ground than any "sharp" knife can....live in the jungle for awhile and you'll be begging for a "pocket brick"...
Click to expand...

I concur with the previous poster, I'd much rather have a parang or machete rather than a "pocket brick".

A hard use folder is no substitution for a fixed blade. Never has been, never will be. I don't care how much Greg Medford (or Strider, or Emerson) bill their products, the vast majority of military personnel wil simply use the the cheapest, most available tool, and will probably use it to a great deal of success.
 
Spend your money on whatever makes you happy, but please don't tell people that this knife is somehow a good choice for survival/hiking/camping/whatever. It is not. It's too thick and has too low a grind. It's questionable even calling it a knife.

Chopping? If you've ever chopped anything with anything else you know this Praetorian isn't going to be any better at chopping wood than a random rock.

This is fantasy operator art. That is all.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top