referring to a custom as a woman?

Joined
Dec 3, 1999
Messages
9,437
I keep seeing this more and more...

"she" is this kind of knife, "she" is that kind of knife

What the heck is up with that?!?!

Makes about as much sense to me as naming your... uh, nevermind.

A knife is a knife... why are so many people calling them women???

-Nick-
 
I guess it's the same reason cars or boats are refered to as female.
 
NickWheeler said:
I keep seeing this more and more...

"she" is this kind of knife, "she" is that kind of knife

What the heck is up with that?!?!

Makes about as much sense to me as naming your... uh, nevermind.

A knife is a knife... why are so many people calling them women???

-Nick-

You just stop typing and hurry up and finish "Betsy", will ya? :) :D
 
ships were a "she" too. it's just tradition to use the feminine form for inanimate objects, possibly due to homophobia - can't imagine saying "oh, I spent last night playing "'Danbo", can you?" :p

sorry Danbo - just kidding.... :D
 
NickWheeler said:
I keep seeing this more and more...

"she" is this kind of knife, "she" is that kind of knife

What the heck is up with that?!?!

Makes about as much sense to me as naming your... uh, nevermind.

A knife is a knife... why are so many people calling them women???

-Nick-


I agree with your concern, Mr. Wheeler. A lady and a blade should never be considered in the same context, unless of course; you are ladyless. Then; there are so many other questions raised about the practice.
Can you imagine feeling the same way about a favorite pair of boots......" SHE feels so good when I slip my foot into her"......I don't think so........a favorite skillet; we won't EVEN go there.
It's Monday.
 
The furthest I will go is calling a knife a "puppy". :D
 
Ok Nick
im sorry but i must try to explain this .
Many call a knife a her beacuse they can be as complicated as a woman .
Sometimes she is Beautifull and gracefull dressed to go out on the town , other times she is just wearing sweat's ,or jeans. when the time is taken to correctly put on lipstick/nail polish it look's good . when done badly it look's like crap. ah women! very complicated at times but i should not have to tell you this right ? take care ill see ya in Eugene :)
 
NickWheeler said:
I keep seeing this more and more...

"she" is this kind of knife, "she" is that kind of knife

What the heck is up with that?!?!

They need to get l... you know what (must remain PC in here :rolleyes: ).

Makes about as much sense to me as naming your... uh, nevermind.
A knife is a knife... why are so many people calling them women???

It's a tool, it's called 'it'. If Willie could talk he'd agree with me :D
 
May be connected with the story of Camelot and the "Lady of the Lake", w/ Excalibur.

Or, the "Iron Mistress" movie w/ Alan Ladd that came out in the 1950s.
David
 
I think it's because in the thinking prevailent in older times, some manmade objects and mechanical devices, like cars, ships, and I guess even knives require care, maintainence and if treated with care and sensitivity to their needs and limitations, will perform for and reward their owners, like a woman, of course I realize this is an outdated and non-PC concept, but to some extent, it used to be that way, and when I say "perform" I'm not meaning it in the sexual way, but it seems to me that's why in older times and still to this day, cars and ships and I guess even knives, would sometimes be called "She", because in some ways, they were like a woman, requiring special care to "work".

Think about how in older times, you might have a ship's captain saying something like: "Oh, she'll make it all right, I changed her oil, gave her engine some loving care, waxed her hull, she's in tip top shape, and she'll be ready for this voyage..."

No, obviously, I'm no writer, but it's something you could envision being said way back when, and why, well, for the reasons I outlined above. It's not exactly a PC concept, but I do think that's where this idea springs from.

The closest I come is saying something like: "Check out this bad boy!" :)

Nick, did you get those pics I sent you the other day? :confused:
 
Reminded me...

A few years ago I went to the Pigeon Forge, Tennessee knife show.. While I was at the table of someone I regard as being a respectable man, a customer walked up to him asked to see a couple of his knives and said "Yeah, I'll take this one, Dawg!" He paid and left. The dealer showed no sign of surprise at being referred to as "Dawg", maybe that was part of the humor too. But, I laughed about it then and now thinking about it gives me a chuckle. In the end, it was just a "name".
David
 
Mike, I 'bout fell of my chair on that one!!! LMAO, Thank you sir, I needed that good laugh!

Most of you guys chose female over male. This I can understand... but that would imply we HAVE to refer to a knife as he or she.

I guess I'm a little more simple in thinking that a knife is an "it."


two little monologues here with "it' and "her"---


"I am proud that I nailed the heat-treat on it. I beat it through that block with a baton and it held up fine. So what do you think it's worth?"

Or

"I am proud that I nailed the heat-treat on her. I beat her through that block with a baton and she held up fine. So, what do you think she's worth?"

Perhaps it simply fits into some of the bull$hit hype that people like to create??? Maybe?

I am not poking fun at anyone or belittling anyone. I just keep seeing/hearing this and wondered why. I can see that some guys think I'm crazy, and others agree with me. Okay, the world is still going round ;)

Thanks Folks-
-Nick-
 
Now that you bring some of that stuff up, I do refer to knives more as "it" than "her." I don't pronoun around when I'm talking about someone else's knife ("that's awesome!" as opposed to "she's awesome!") I usually just use "her" when I'm referring to a blade that I made for someone. And even then it's usually limited to "she's done" or something -- never about how "it looks" or some such. I wonder why.
 
Nick Wheeler said:
Makes about as much sense to me as naming your... uh, nevermind.

What's wrong with namin' 'yer nevermind'?!? I seem to be awfully attached to the one I got, whether I call by name or not!!! :eek: :D

As far as the knives go....... :confused: :)
 
Back
Top