I'll answer these in order:
>>Jim..why the need for a bigger blade? Where are you going to carry it...<<
Everwhere. There's no length limit on concealed folders in California, I'm twisted enough to convert an Ontario Black Wind Katana blade to folder, although it wouldn't be daily carry. Like my 6" Vaquero Grande or 5.5" AlMar folders are.
>>...and what will you do when you use it...<<
Render any mugger or similar idiot *extremely* sorry he ever saw me! That's if he (or they) prove stupid enough to charge something like that.
>>...and more impotantly what will you say AFTER you use it?<<
"Officer, I was attacked, the guy was tryin' to kill me, that didn't work out so well."
>>It can't be reach advantage.. 2"?<<
Three. My current carry folders are up to double the blade length. If you're going to try the "slash at an incoming enemy arm while dodging gag" found in the Bujinkan and most if not all of the FMAs the extra blade length can be the difference between a hit or a miss.
>>cutting ability? It really cuts as it is..<<
At Knifignugen my Vaquero Grande was able to cut 1" free-hanging synthetic mountaineer rope, possibly the TOUGHEST such test possible. My serrated Mad Dog WSP1 ATAK variant (similar to DSU) could NOT perform the same feat; at first everybody thought it was my technique, but Kevin McClung couldn't do it either. I *then* pulled out my Vaquero Grande and went through that crap like it was twine.
No 3" blade could have done that.
Leverage isn't an issue.
>>tactical reality? hell its for close encounters...<<
In addition to all of the above, there's one more LITTLE detail.
Intimidation.
I have no doubt that the Escalator is one of the very best 3" fighters ever made, possibly the best. But if I'm facing four homicidal transvestites armed with hammers who want to kill the guy behind me (as happened to me once
), I do NOT want to draw something the size of a Swiss Army Knife. I want the huge "CLACK" sound a megafolder makes as it snaps into battery, I want as many inches of gleaming steel as I can possibly score. I want to put on an evil grin and beat their MINDS, make them mentally unable to attack without ever having to draw blood and the related legal problems that will sure as hell follow. YES, I'll use it if they make it necessary, no problem at all.
But a megafolder makes it less likely.
See also the megafolder thread on the Camillus forum.
I will not buy a 3" "pure fighting knife". No way, no how, forget it. I doubt I'll ever buy a 4". I hope REKAT is listening.
Jim March
[This message has been edited by Jim March (edited 20 March 1999).]