Sebenza Alternative

i'd get a mnandi, sophisticated, frame lock, but not hard use and shouldn't have the issues you have with them. a BM anthem seems like a really good response. probably your best bet within the rules.
 
All locking mechanisms can get gunked up. As you said, the ball detent is the Achilles heel in a frame/liner lock design. The thing is that every other mechanism I know of has even less desirable attributes. Whether it’s small moving parts, small or thin springs, complicated mechanisms, mechanisms prone to/shown to quickly undesirably wear or whatever... Frame locks have really proven to me that of all the trade offs in a folding knife’s makeup, they are certainly one of the better designs out there for what I like in a knife. I will almost always avoid a flipper knife because typically too much attention is put into making it a fidget toy and more often than not that takes away from other key features that are important to me.

So because I personally don’t think a knife exists that fits your desired bullet points that I also wholeheartedly endorse, I will 1. recommend something that fits some of the criteria, 2. recommend something that also doesn’t fit my usual criteria, 3. both confirms and contradicts statements in my previous paragraph, and 4. is 100% a fantastic Sebenza alternative.

Get yourself a Shirogorov Neon.
 
GermanyChris said:
I like them and had one on order but the first run hit just as I was PCS'ing so money was very tight. The reason I don't carry slip joints unless I'm traveling is because they turn in my pocket and it annoys me.
Click to expand...

I wouldn’t let let keep you from a Roundhead/Shuffler/Dom; they are great little knives. Get one of these little pocket purses to keep the knife in place. I thought I would hate it but it works very well and I can’t imagine not using one now. The one in the photos is a Hitch & Timber Pocket Runt and works great with these LionSteels or a 2-layer SAK.

i.ashx

i.ashx

i.ashx


I also carry at least one CRK daily.
i.ashx
 
GermanyChris said:
I'm actually going to start a recommendation thread :eek:

While I like my Sebenza a great deal and carry it every day the frame locks are getting kinda old. It seems like every week or two I'm cleaning it out because the action is getting stiff, it could be from pocket lint or just dust from cutting stuff but regardless it needs to happen. I've been perusing BladeHQ searching for knives with different locking systems but nothing has been appealing. I want something that is proportionally like my Sebenza, something that looks like an adult would own, non flipper, non frame or liner lock, preferably thinish, around 4oz, 3.5 to 4" blade, non-chinese and ~$600. While I'm sure I can find someone to build me something in that price range my last hand built in that range turned me off to another.

What reasonably sophisticated knife would you buy at that price.
Click to expand...
I'd check out William Henry or maybe one of those klotzli swiss border guard knives:

https://www.knifeart.com/wiheb30safok.html
https://www.knifeart.com/swiss-border-guard.html
 
I too would suggest a BM Anthem. This is by far the best Axis version that BM has put out since it uses a coil spring around a guide rod verses the omega springs. The action very smooth and the blade just flies out. Great ergos and light weight for an integral titanium knife.
 
Well, I do not keep my large Sebenza in my shoe, but instead clipped to top of pocket or IWB, and it pretty much just needs a teeny dab of lube on locking surface of lock bar and detent ball from time to time, and virtually never needs any manner of cleaning, whatsoever. Of course, I am not in the military making mud pies anymore, either, so, I stay pretty clean all day long.
Perhaps carrying the knife in a cleaner spot might be easier than blowing $600 on a knife that is identical except different.
 
I didn't read the entire thread, but after skimming the replies, I don t believe anyone mentioned the Cold Steel Storm Cloud.
20cv steel, carbon fiber,3.5 inches, less than 4 oz, made in Italy. If you re not offended by the price tag of $170 , it might be worth a try.
All of my Cold Steel folders have been very durable, some used for fairly hard work. I ve been pleased with the quality of my Taiwan Cold Steel folders. But being made in Italy checks that box for you, and your other requirements are also met with this knife.
Except for the part about $600 dollars.!!!
I might get one myself. As if I need another knife right now.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top