- Joined
- Dec 2, 2005
- Messages
- 69,267
This thread has LEGS! I'm going to have to dig out some of my other lighters!

I should point out that my butane insert takes flints (it sparks like a Zippo)



Great postIf I didn't smoke I would most likely go butane 100%. It's hard to say. However, I do smoke and can maybe offer a different perspective
I appreciate the weekly ritual of topping off my Zippo with fuel. Like oiling my blades to prevent rust. Could I just buy stainless? Yes, it is more convenient. But I enjoy the pleasures and functional benefits of carbon steel and the maintenance that goes along with it. The history of lighters and what made Zippo successful brings me joy. I can fix my Zippo insert if almost anything goes wrong, which cannot be said of butane inserts.
Fwiw, I also use "the bag trick" and on my EDC insert replaced the rayon with "cotton bacon". I can go 2 weeks without needing a refill if need be. And I light it about 20 times a day. A 12fl oz can of fuel lasts me about 6 months and it's less than 5 bucks. I also have a small fuel canister on my keychain just in case but have never needed it. Spare flints are stashed on top of the cotton. If I'm packing a lighter for long term storage and reliability, I simply pack a bic.
No hate on the butane inserts! They are great too! I know that lighter fluid, flints, and wicks are not for everyone. But, I also think there is a time, place, and perspective that supports doing things "the old fashioned way"![]()



