Some knive reviewsand thoughts of mine over the years (Busse and others)

Joined
May 27, 2006
Messages
91
Thought I would post some thoughts to better explain some of my past knife experiences. Since the last threads got out of control and some Busse owners and others had to get started with name calling and the such. So here are some of the experiences I have had with Busses, and why after owning several models ended up selling most of them. (no there is no agenda here, just a review of knives I have used over the last 5 years or so and yes some of my reviews have changed from 4-5 years ago after using them!).

As for the Busse Battle Mistress model that I had. It was a Zero Tolerance Model, with Desert grips. Don't really know the style, but was the style handle Busse was using in 2002. I was working in Cambodia in 2004, running wildlife conservation law enforcement patrols (Was working as the Project Manager at the time for the Maddox Jolie Project set up by the actress/humanitarian Angelina Jolie), in the Samlaut Protected Area ( like a National Park), located on the Thai/Cambodian border. Had taken 4 large style Machete style blades with me to Cambodia. A Al Mar Pathfinder, The Busse BM, Cold Steel LTC Khuk and a HI Khuk. The Busse was my favorite, due to the looks and design. But, after taking it out on one of my first patrols, where I had to cut down bamboo for some improvised shelters and also ended up having to cut down several 4 to 6 inch diameter limbs, to use to support some equipment being supported in the pack of a totyota hilux upon extraction, found the knife to not be that effecient in chopping down the limbs, took way to many chops in my opinion, and the way the flat handles were designed caused some serious blisters. After that I stopped using the Busse. Later did many tasks very similiar with my CS LTC and HI Khuk. No issues at all. Very effecient in the chopping and no blisters on the hand. Found the HI Khuk also to be very strong, the spine was pretty tough. Could use it for hammering as well. LOL PLus I am very partial to Khuks, as I have had three treks in Nepal and have trained with the Gurkhas and had them fighting for me in Iraq. Don't have one bad thing to say about the Gurkhas that worked for me. Anyway, ended up selling the BM, though a beautiful design, just did not find it practical. Also ended up selling the Al Mar pathfinder, again a very nice looking blade, but did not work out very well (found the blade a little too long and the double hilt was always getting in the way and rubbing against my thumb when chopping).

Sometimes I think we look at knives as beautiful peices of art almost and buy them because of the looks, but sometimes these more expensive examples are just not really cut out for the job, and/or impractical to carry and use. I also had several other Busses, Natural Outlaw, Air Rescue, Badger Attacks old and new styles, Neck knife, and a Paul's hatchet. Just my experience was that they did not cut very well compared to some other makers knives that I had. Found them to be a little to thick, the choil getting caught up on things, and the coating on the blade not so practical. Took two of them to South Africa with me, and they did not do a very good job skinning. Even the smaller ones were not very good cutters and slicers compared to some Knives from other brands I had. The only Busse I ended up keeping was the Zero Tolerance Natural Outlaw. Like the look and shape of this blade. And found it to be a better cutter with the 3/16 inch blade and polished blade rather.. Though still do not like the large choil, but wanted to keep one Busse in my collection. Plus the sheath I had custom made for it by Leatherman in pretty nice (but, I also think Randall and Chris Reeve leather sheaths are the best out there). So sold off all the Busses, except the one.

Now, I will mention a knife brand that I think is pretty tough and fits the bill, that Busse tries to fill as well, but cost a small fraction, no waiting periods and even comes with a decent Sheath. That is the Becker knives. About 3 dozen of the 5 1/2 inch models were bought for a company of the Cambodian 911 Airborne (Cambodian's Special Forces Company). These guys of course loved the knives! They took it with them everywhere and did everything with it. Very hard field usage in tropical jungle environments. No cleaning of the knives. They chopped with them, pryed with them, opened ammo cases with them, beat on them and cut with them. The knives took a lot of abuse and none of them failed. I do not know if a knife could be put through anymore than a knife given to a Cambodian field unit. So the Beckers, especially at the price (I think they were around $70) can not be beat. Plus they are good looking knives.

Now, as for Busse, I think a lot of people like collecting them but many probably do not really use them (other than some backyard photos of them cutting a peice of wood to post on the forum LOL). (Same could be said for Randalls as well). Though there are probably some that do use them very often and are quite fond of them. They just were not for me, or the other two members on one of my teams who bought them from me and ended up selling them as well. I think what appeal to many about Busse, is the Cultish way the Busse owners and forum is. I am not saying that is a bad thing, just that when people buy a Busse they are buying more than a knife. They are buying into a small little Knife cult with their own nicknames, freinds, sales, gimmicks, banters and so forth. So Busse become a real hobby to many, hog this and hog that, etc.. To me Busse is just another company that is selling a product. Now, I personnally do not agree with some of the Bussiness aspects: long waiting periods, no sheaths, limited distribution, etc... When a person wants a knife they want to buy a knife to use now, not have to wait and they want it with a sheath. Busse to some it becomes like a family, almost a Religion, and pity anybody who does not hail to the fact that Busses are the best. I think that is why one forum member went out to say I had some sort of Secret Agenda or something against Busse directly, since he could not fathom why anybody would not bow down to Busse and claim them the best knives or would sell their Busses and use different knives and say that in their experience that other knives worked better for them than Busse. Again, if a person likes Busse knives, then go for it, collect away!

Now, I will state from my experience working in Cambodia, Iraq and Afghanistan, and Kosovo and a few other places over the last almost 6 years I have never seen another Busse, not saying they are not out there -this is just my observations, other than the ones I had and the ones I personally sold to two team members. Now the custom/high end knives that I have seen a lot of and have gotten a lot of use by people I have met over the years are: Randall (believe it or not, myself included, see a lot of military personnel still carrying and using), strider (a brand I do not particularly care for, but others love), and Chris Reeve fixed bladed knives. (now of course these are higher end knives, of course you see many basic Gerbers, Buck, cold Steel, Becker, KaBar, Bayonets etc.. as these are sold at the PX and or issued). But, also reality is that in most military or wilderness environments a big bladed knife is really not needed or hardly used. All you really need is a smaller folding knife and a multi tool and depending on the environment maybe a Machete type blade or axe. A bayonet, has many practical uses as well and is usually carried if in a combative arms type position in the military.

As for smaller/medium fixed blades knives my favorite are my Randall #15, still like the Busse Natural Outlaw Zero Tolerance though never carry it or use it too much anymore (though it did get carried during one of my tours in Iraq and held up pretty good), Chris Reeve "Rhino" skinner, and one of the original Chris Reeve Jereboam IIs made in South Africa. And for EDC it is Chris Reeve Sebenzas or a Bechmade 940. For the future I really am set on getting some additional Chris Reeve or Ryan Wilson Tactical knives. Also have back in the states several Andre Deviellers Custom folders that are great knives and very rugged as well. Andre makes some great knives, and used them with much success on a hunting trip I did in Africa with Andre. Also like a knife company called Citadel, they are custom made in Cambodia and mainly then sold in France, and Europe (and are starting to be sold/distributed in America). Met with the founder/owner a couple of years ago in Phnom Penh and he makes some really nice custom knives and Japanese swords. (going to Malaysia and Cambodia next week, and will probably buy a couple Citadel knives - plus buying them direct in Cambodia cost about 25% of what he sells them for in Europe and America!)

One thing also, about the Randall #15 Airman. Great service from Randall!! I was overseas at the time with the military in 2003. Called up RMKs and asked for a Model #15 with some custom modifications. They had it to me in less than 2 weeks!!!! And even gave me a good discount. Love the history and tradition that Randall has with the Military over the last 65 years. There is just something special about being overseas and having a Randall strapped to your belt!

Personally if I had to choose only one knife company to go with, it would be Chris Reeve. Love their one peice designs, very strong and hollow handle. Some of their newer micarta handled Fixed blades and of course all their folding knifes with options of wood inlays or graphics.

Well, just some of my knife thoughts! Cheers.
 
Interesting stuff, thanks for the thoughts.

I also find it funny when people say 'Post your camping/woodcraft/survival knife' and half of the photos are of knives that don't have a single nick or scratch on the entire thing, And the blade is in perfect condition. It's like "what the hell kind of camping and bushcraft do you do?'' I'm certain half of these knife owners wouldn't even spread butter with their high-dollar cutlery. I have a few moras and a opinel that I actually use:eek:

To each their own though, :thumbup:
 
I had to modify my BM's handle, and its edge as well. It's now convex edge and the handle is much rounded. I was not really fond of the factory edge, and definitely hated the original handle.
 
Well just realized that Becker Knife and Tool, who I spoke highly of in my post went bankrupt and out of bussiness!!!! That is a real bummer. Well, guess I have been out of the knife community for several years, so old news is new news to me. LOL
 
Becker per se was not the company who went out of business, wasn't it Camillus, who bought the name? It's a picky point, but some may take it Ethan Becker was at fault.

He's definitely organizing things having gotten the name and designs back, there are a couple of threads on it this month earlier.
 
leopardprey - I hear what you're saying. There sure is a lot of brand loyalty and fanaticisim with some brands like Busse, Strider and Mad Dog Knives. So much so that I bought the new Busse Battle Mistress, and while I was sure INFI is a great steel, the knife itself felt as alive as a boat anchor. Sure it looked sexy, but performance wise I knew it didn't have it in there compared to my kukris, beckers and Livesays. So it got sold and I'll probably never buy another one.

Then got a Strider SnG after all the talk... and once again disappointed. Looks cool, but the design was pretty unergonomic for me - the corner kept digging into my palm. I'm not into their laser cut blades with $2 of paracord wrapping either.

Definitely Beckers are good value though sadly no more - but they'll be back soon. I'll be buying.

Newt Livesay's knives - still sorta available and if you can get over all the bad past (I managed to get everything) - are also dark horses. The steel is not sexy 1095, but top notch heat treatment and amazing handles.

Remember, most of us are "collectors" or should I say hoarders rather than true hard core users like yourself!
 
Becker per se was not the company who went out of business, wasn't it Camillus, who bought the name? It's a picky point, but some may take it Ethan Becker was at fault.
Correct, and worth clarifying. Becker knives were made by Camillus. Camillus went out of business in spite of, not because of, Becker's popular and profitable designs.
 
Interesting stuff, thanks for the thoughts.

I also find it funny when people say 'Post your camping/woodcraft/survival knife' and half of the photos are of knives that don't have a single nick or scratch on the entire thing, And the blade is in perfect condition. It's like "what the hell kind of camping and bushcraft do you do?'' I'm certain half of these knife owners wouldn't even spread butter with their high-dollar cutlery. I have a few moras and a opinel that I actually use:eek:

To each their own though, :thumbup:

Haha, yeah I see this all the time on this forum. People saying they edc customs etc yet they look more new than any knives I own (including ones ive never used haha). Take a look at the "what do you edc" thread. 90% of people on there do not edc those knives pictured or at the most open mail or very wimpy tasks. Those customs are really being put to the test...

I believe for a lot of people, knives are more of a have and want than actual use thing. Nothing wrong with that as I also have knives I just like to have (including my busse actually =)). I do find it rather annoying when people pretend to use their knives and defend their use religiously--yet they only cut open some mail or a hang nail...just my opinion of course. To me a real knife is one that is really used--it is a tool. Other than that its just an art piece.
 
I am also eagerly awaiting the return of the becker line. My BK 7 out chopped larger knives of higher cost brands. Also the handle is amazing. I have never owned a Busse and never will I refuse to spend that much money on a knife that doesnt come with a sheath and I have to wait that long to get.
 
leopardprey I could see the reason for a post like this, but it does appear you have something against Busse knives or their owners in general. I have read you other posts in the wilderness forum and don't under stand why you would start another after seeing where that thread went. You act like you want to bring drama to the forums, hence placing "Busse" in the title.... Sure you put "and others" but why only name Busse in the title? And the others you speak of you only bring up to compare vs Busse.

You also try and stereotype every one that owns a Busse (claiming they dont use their knives). This post seems like nothing but pot shots hidden in what you try and pass as a review.

Why a review after all these yeas? Why just a day after you got into a fight with many members in the wilderness forum (which was locked)?

I own many different brands Busse, Strider, Chris Reeve, Fehrman, Mayo, Emerson, Randall...... So I am far from one of your so called "cult members", but I love all high quality knives and Busse is no different. And it does not matter what brand you pick it will have a following and there will be both collectors and users. Who are you to claim one is better then the other, maybe all your special ops missions have gotten to your head.
 
There is free Kool Aid being served in the Busse Forum:eek::eek:
Better HURRY!!!

Kool-AidMan.jpg
 
Leopardprey,

Thanks!

It's really refreshing to hear real world information about a knife instead of hype.

Your comments about the culltish nature of the Busse owners is spot on. It is a major reason I decided not to buy a Busse, {that ,and the fact the waiting time for a smaller model takes forever}. Still I kept wondering if I was missing out on the consummate bush knife. You just answered my question.

I also appreciate not reading the words 'oink' and 'drink', when describing the Busse experience....
 
Leopardprey,

Thanks!
It's really refreshing to hear real world information about a knife instead of hype.

I appreciate not reading the words 'oink' and 'drink', when describing the Busse experience.

I don't think you're getting "real world info", just some of his BS hype. He has dissed Busse lately and it does appear he does have an agenda against Busse.
Just wish he would tell us what it is.
Why else would he put "Busse" in the title. If you want some "real world" info check out some of the videos from the Busse room. You will be amazed.
 
Bkultra...

Those pics look very familiar... looks just like the ones my mate took awhile back in the alpine areas of Victoria, Australia... ;)
 
Back
Top