Strider AR VS. Extrema Ratio M.P.C. -- a Pictorial Comparison (lots o pics)

Burch, super pictures, thanks !!
First off, I gotta ditto both of the Dr's. earlier replies: The ER doesn't have those smooth lines that many people enjoy, and the history of Strider is well documented as compared to the newer ER's.
But, the ER does have a thicker and a bit longer blade, and the cross bolt lock may prove itself over time, when compared to liners.
However, IMHO, if both of these are so similar that it's difficult to pick one over the other, then I'd go for the Strider.
Why ? Well, not to start any flames or trade wars, but the Strider is made here in the USA, and that does mean something to me. Also, the Strider customer service is well known as great, ER would have to prove itself in that department also. Nothing against Frank, either !!
 
Um, why does the ER have the word "Lock" under the lock ?
Is this for people who aren't sure where it is :D

A bit like writing the word trigger on a gun :p
 
PhoulPlae -- I'd love to do a comparison of the two, but if the Strider's liner is out of whack, it would need to be fixed first. I do know that I'm going to tear the ER up sometime soon -- it's too "new," and it needs some character. :D

Ajrand -- Personally, I'd pick the the ER. I know a lot of people don't find it appealing to the eye, but I like it (if I didn't, I wouldn't get one.;) ) It's like a tank, not aerodynamic, but tough as nails and built to perform. The handle is comfortable in the hand and I don't think that there is a chance in hell that the blade is going to move once it's locked open.

As far as the steel goes, awhile back I bought a Harpoon and was extremely impressed with the blade's performance.

Thanks all for the comments on the pictures -- trust me, it's all in the camera, not the user's abilities. ;)

Yog -- I bet you can guess what the other side says.:D I don't really know what its for, but I don't think it's there to point out that it's a lock. Since the other side says "unlock" I believe its on there to show if the lock's engaged or not.
 
Originally posted by yog
Um, why does the ER have the word "Lock" under the lock ?
Is this for people who aren't sure where it is :D

A bit like writing the word trigger on a gun :p
Click to expand...

LOL :). Actually thats the cross bolt safety. You slide the bolt to the side that says "Lock" and you can't press the back lock down. You press it to the other side that says "Unlock" and you can unlock the blade. Prevents you from accidental release in a tight grip. The cool thing is that when you lock the blade when the knife is closed it will stay shut.
 
Thanks for the fast and no BS response Burchtree. Too many people are so timid about making a choice, especially in public. It makes your candor seem so refreshing. Terrific pics by the way. I think the ER folders look really rugged and cool myself.
 
Thanks for the nice pics, Burch.

Sure, the ER is butt ugly, but it also looks like it would eat the Strider for lunch. How's that for no B.S.?

That lock-up is pretty sick on those ERs. Two pieces of 1/4" steel locking together. Mean.
 
Good thread. Burchtree, do have the respective weights of the two knives? I'd be curious to see how these two mega - folders compare weight - wise.
 
Don't sell yourself short. Close up picture are a b*tch; I have a $500 camera and I can't do half as well. I played with the ER at Blade; it felt tough as nails. Let us know how it holds up for you.
 
Nathan -- I'm not sure about the weight, but someone might know the specs and pipe in.

Roadrunner -- I only showed the pics that were good, you didn't see the other half of my 256 card that was full of fuzzy, craptacular pics. :D
 
Hmmmm...were'd you get that perdy AR from??? ;)

I have played with both. I have actually used an AR(infact, the AR in the pics). For a knife to be able to cut with, the edge geomtry of the AR is far superior. I really like the AR and Strider is one of the most respectable and incredible companies out there. I believe were the ER has it beat is in the locking system. The Back Lock is much stronger than the liner/frame lock. However, for practical cutting applications, the AR shines. It really cuts well. However, I'd vote if you needed a very tough knife to be like a fixed blade, the ER would be a better choice.
 
Cool pics. I was thinking of doing something similar with an AR and the Lone Wolf Harsey...Maybe I will...

--dan
 
Both of those things are pocket swords! I can feel my wallet burning because now I have to have one of both.
 
I think the Strider is more practical because of the one-hand opening and closing lock as well as the thinner high flat ground utility shaped blade.

The ER would be more valuable as a fix blade substitute where the the bolted backlock would be more desirable.

I want them both. The Strider would my choice if I could only have one.
 
<<<1) None of them, particularly the one pictured here, "flow" very well. They do not, IMO, have clean, smooth, flowing lines>>>


I agree totaly with this sentiment about the handles... That is not true about the blade on the Nemesis imho. For some reason lookin at the blade on the nemesis makes me want to cream myself it just seems perfect!
 
Burchtree,

With the 'classic' Strider AR having been on the market for nearly a year now, and the ER only being around for a few months...

How dare you be so presumptuous as to compare the two?

Have you no humility? ;)

Mel

p.s. Thanks for the pics!
 
Burch:

The liner on my Tac GB engages FULLY with the blade. Your AR worries me. Send it in to Mick, and he'll be glad to fix it for you at no cost to you. He'll even sharpen and give it a general "tune-up" if you wish.

I agree that the ER locking system is very impressive, but again; I have never heard of a Strider's "measly" liner-lock system failing.

Not to say that the ER is overkill (no such thing, IMO :D ) but would it really be BETTER? I doubt it...

Anyhow, thanks again for the pics, and GET YOUR STRIDER FIXED!!!
 
A very good visual comparison, Michael. Thanks.

Actually, I am beginning to like the ExtremaRatio knives. They show enormous potential.
 
If it's "defective," there's no worries about it not being sent in -- I like my fingers too much.

As far as toughness, I really doubt that there is too much that either knife couldn't do.

As far as me personally liking the ER better than the Strider doesn't have much to do with the liner lock placement. it's just a matter of taste -- different knives for different people. I do like the extreme overkill though. Personally, I've never had liner lock fail on me before. I've used an CRKT M18 a lot and it's never failed. The difference is, I hold back on that knife because of it's liner lock. I think it's a mental thing for me -- even though I've never had a liner lock buckle on me, I still "hold back" on using a lot of force on them. With the ER, I feel it's the closest thing to a folding fixed blade and I don't have that "vunerable fingers" feeling. I know you're not supposed to treat folders like fixed blades, but damn it's close. :D

Just my two-cents. Thanks for the replies about the pics - I'm still working on my "digital" photography.
 
Originally posted by drjones
Burch:

The liner on my Tac GB engages FULLY with the blade. Your AR worries me. Send it in to Mick, and he'll be glad to fix it for you at no cost to you......

Anyhow, thanks again for the pics, and GET YOUR STRIDER FIXED!!!
Click to expand...

It looks like, to me, his Strider's liner is working perfectly and doesn't need to be fixed.
 
"Sure, the ER is butt ugly, but it also looks like it would eat the Strider for lunch. How's that for no B.S.?"

My sentiments exactly.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top