Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'General Knife Discussion' started by Jay Hiewd, Jan 15, 2021.
Who makes the strongest folder and fixed camping survival knife? I'm looking into ESEE.
I’d say that ideally you don’t want a .25” thick folder and a .25” thick fixed blade for outdoor “survival”. I think that a person would be best served with a small and thin folder or fixed blade and a larger knife like an ESEE Junglas-II. This allows more versatility and dexterity when performing finer tasks like food prep, skinning of small game, and other light utility tasks. Then the bigger knife is reserved for larger tasks like hacking/wood processing.
But to answer your question, I suppose one of the strongest folder might be something like the the Extrema Ratio RAO or one of the thick Tri-ad lock folders from Cold Steel and for fixed maybe something from TOPS Knives, Becker, or ESEE with a .25” spine or thicker.
What's your budget?
For a fixed blade, British MOD Survival knife, of course. LMAO! It's called "the Prybar with an edge". But really, there are lots of choices. As far as Folders, it's only the strongest in comparison to othe Folders. Anything with a joint is a compromise at best. JMHO, YMMV.
The "strongest" knife isn't necessarily the most practical knife. It depends on what you want to use the knife for.
I suppose if someone wants to hammer their knife through steel cable or use it as a prybar then having the "strongest" knife possible would make sense. But if a person wants to be able to cut a lot of different materials effectively then the "strongest" knife likely won't be the best choice.
Are you asking for a knife recommendation or is this some kind of fantasy/theoretical topic?
That’s a bold statement lol
Other than “strong” and “heavy duty”, I don’t know what you’re looking for (materials, lock type, etc...), but based on those two I’d probably go with the CS 4max and an ESEE 5
Depends on what you mean by “strong”.
If you mean thick blades and unlikely to break (and truly do have that unlimited budget) maybe a Medford for the folder and a Busse of some type for the fixed blade.
Cold Steel 4 Max
Cold Steel Warcraft .
At least that I can afford !
Not sure about the "strongest" folder, but my PM2 is pretty darn strong.
For a fixie, my Bark River Bravo 1 is about as good as it gets in my opinion!
IMO, the Extrema Ratio RAO or RAO II is the strongest folder ever made.
See: Blade Forum - Extrema Ratio RAO II Review
And see this too:
Always wanted to buy one but it's expensive and there are a lot of fakes out there but it's still on my buy list if I can find a "real one" for the "right price."
Strongest Fixed Blade:
Many candidates and depends a lot on its planned use but for camp/survival I'd grab a Glock 78 or 81 (one one of each) because they're cheap, durable, easy to sharpen and versatile.
With the Extrema Ratio RAO or RAO II, a Glock 78 or 81 and a Swiss Army Knife and/or a Gerber Multi-tool, you should pretty much have everything covered that might come up in the field.
Strong doesn't mean thick and heavy and unwieldy. It also doesn't mean it has to be expensive.
This knife for example has been used repeatedly to baton hundreds of wood over the last 5 years and is still going strong. It's EDC sized with 4oz and has 3.5mm blade stock.
Cold Steel for folders (SR-1, 4-Max, Pocket Bushman etc)
Busse for fixed almost any model
Coating held up really well
Yup, Cold Steel's DLC coating is no joke. This knife chewed through so many knots and miles of cardboxes, the DLC coating is still shiny and mostly new.
must be nice...
Seriously though, I think having some idea of what your intention to use them for might give me a better idea of what to recommend. Everything comes at a trade off.
The custom maker you hire to do so.
Cold steel sr1, Sr1 lite and the folding bushman. Are cheaper tank options.
I have the sr1 and the bushman. I really like sr1 I am not that big a fan of the bushman. But not for strength reasons. It is just a clunky knife to use.
Fixed blades? Probably something from CPK or Busse. Folding knives, probably the Cold Steel 4Max. There are plenty of niche, or limited run folding knives in 3V, but the issue will always be the pivot, so as long as the steel is at least decent it's really a secondary concern.
Plenty of guys making super big chunky folding knives (like Medford, as someone else mentioned), and others all the way into the custom scene where you will pay massive cash. Also, there are a TON of custom makers out there who make insane impossible to break fixed blades, but you will pay accordingly. If you don't like Busse or CPK because they don't weigh enough to suit you, there's always Miller Bros for example. LOL
If money is truly no object, then you should research makers and have someone make something for you to your exact specifications.