Super Steel

Yes, but I clearly remember my father, an engineer and quite the nerd, declaring to me in the early 70's that the Torx system for screwheads was clearly superior, and would replace all other types within 5 years. He later bought a Betamax along that same line of reasoning.
😆
the betamax was awesome compared to vhs......while it lasted.......
 
I may be showing my age but, I remember when they first started making knives out of obsidian. We all said, "Flint has been working just fine for years. I don't see why we need to change."
I'm quite partial to Keokuk chert and novaculite myself. Flint is good as long as you're not trying to work it from a raw node. Obsidian is definitely easy to work and capable of a fierce edge. Overall I'd say you'd be well served by any of them, provided you're careful cutting... They all tend to be a bit chippy.
 
Yes, but I clearly remember my father, an engineer and quite the nerd, declaring to me in the early 70's that the Torx system for screwheads was clearly superior, and would replace all other types within 5 years. He later bought a Betamax along that same line of reasoning.
😆

We sometimes forget that "tradition" is often merely a well thought out solution for problems we no longer remember having.

Oh, I can top that one. In the mid 1980s when I was an engineering student, AutoCAD was just ported the IBM PC world. All of my classmates jumped in and learned as much about CAD as they could. I, on the other hand, actually announced that CAD was a passing fad and I stuck with my board, t-square, and other drawing tools. We all know how that panned out. In the world of wrongness, I was king for a while.
 
IMG_20240104_212242340.jpg

In other news, my ffg drop point 110lt arrived today... I brought it to work at my second job for the maiden voyage. Despite not being bladed in the latest whiz bang steel, it cut up the carpet some jackass left laying in the parking lot so it could fit in a trash can just fine. 👍
 
I don't follow this argument/thinking. Is it just me?

Zieg
I have to wonder if he didn't hear somewhere that Buck was abandoning that steel.
Or, does he just assume Buck is moving on to other steels? I don't know. I don't think I've ever even tried that steel. When did Buck start using it in earnest? What were the early 110's that so many seemed to have trouble sharpening? I once got my whole backyard tilled up for a garden from a fellow mechanic that I always sharpened his 110 for back in the late '70s.
 
I have to wonder if he didn't hear somewhere that Buck was abandoning that steel.
Or, does he just assume Buck is moving on to other steels? I don't know. I don't think I've ever even tried that steel. When did Buck start using it in earnest? What were the early 110's that so many seemed to have trouble sharpening? I once got my whole backyard tilled up for a garden from a fellow mechanic that I always sharpened his 110 for back in the late '70s.
420hc came around in the early 90s for Buck as the steel they used.


it was 440c but was due to the factory edge angles more than the steel itself. the edge 2000 made sharpening much easier....regardless of the steel.
 
As my 50 year collection of Buck knives gets obsoleted by super steel I’ve become disheartened. I’m not that keen on super steel mainly because of price and I’m not convinced it’s that much better. My 400 series steels have served me well. I’m not interested in more 420HC steel because I feel it’s going bye bye. My interest in Buck is waning. I refuse to pay for super steel and I’m bullheaded enough to find a new favorite brand. Go ahead, beat me up I’m ready.
I'll help take some of those obsolete knives off your hands, if you're offering them at obsolete knife prices.... :D
 
Chart posted on this very forum from knifesteelnerds originally :

stainless-toughness-5-7-2021.jpg
Every time I see that chart I ask myself "why don't I own anything in AEB-L yet?"
 
I'll never forget the awful sounds made when the vcr would decide to eat a tape.
Same same, also remember back in the 80's when everybody was eagerly switching to cassette players for their car stereo because supposedly they weren't prone to eating tape occasionally like 8-track did. And then everybody that did so had to start carrying a pencil in their car. 😁

CD's however, have lasted for a long time, but all my stereos now have ports for USB and digital never skips when you hit a bump.

But back on topic, I will always prefer a steel I can sharpen at least fairly easily out in the woods.
 
Same same, also remember back in the 80's when everybody was eagerly switching to cassette players for their car stereo because supposedly they weren't prone to eating tape occasionally like 8-track did. And then everybody that did so had to start carrying a pencil in their car. 😁

CD's however, have lasted for a long time, but all my stereos now have ports for USB and digital never skips when you hit a bump.

But back on topic, I will always prefer a steel I can sharpen at least fairly easily out in the woods.

I just carry 2-3 dozen knives and switch when one gets slightly un-sharp.
 
Back
Top