aproy1101 said:
The flashlight is one specific item I was wondering about. You have flown with one and it wasn't confiscated. I've paid too much for my SF L2 to have it taken by some min wage dufus who has no idea what it is. Where do you get the QC powder? What is a smoke escape hood? Where available? Is there a list of allowed tools somewhere?
when i fly, which isn't often, and under protest as it's the only way in any reasonable time to see my dad 3000 miles away...
o i print out the current TSA list; that way i can argue about what they try to "take", like my knitting needles, or other items.
o "take" - they are not allowed to take/confiscate ANYTHING from you unless they are also going to arrest you, or it's outright illegal to posses anyway - though some items in theory by TRYING to get them on a plane, even by accident might land you in trouble (and then they'll probably try to arrest you anyway).
the term you want is "voluntary surrender" :jerkit: . they might imply, strongly you have to give it up, and you might think they're taking it, not so. "that's not allowed, you'll have to leave it" is totally correct. you do not however have to give it to them - chances are they'll keep it for personal use, or if it's actually logged... sell it on ebay, or then take it "legally"

want to buy SAKs by the pound? ebay. airport sales.
o #1 carry-on : a self addressed stamped padded envelope, lots of postage... to secure you items into should someone want to "take" them. mail them home, send them ahead [1], whatever. barring that, just plain leave the line if they let you, and throw give it to someone outside security, even a stranger. it's ... the higher ground.
[1] sending ahead - left from tsa checked luggage is out of control. things go missing. a lot. i'm told a lot of knife shows have suffered because guys could no longer trust that their very expensive knives would make it - so they either send it ahead via a secure shipping service, insured, extra expenses, require someone to receive the package, etc... so, if you know you're going somewhere for a time, send it ahead. trust nothing to checked that isn't insured (home/apt insurance, do they even OFFER flight insurance?).
one possible thing: if your item can be taken apart, to make it look broken, less attractive, do it. put pieces in different places. pockets, tote bag, shoes. whatever. easy grabs are what these guys look for. *cough* officially of course, there is no theft
you can also ask the TSA guy to lock your luggage at check in, after they look at it for you. they won't let you touch it. i also ask them to thread a colored zip tie through the latch for me. the know exactly why i ask, and they've done it for me. if that zip tie is missing, know someone has been in there. you could also use safety tape perhaps, but they get cranky at anything you check, that they can see into, or open. expect everything to get rifled, touched, and played with if they like. they wear rubber gloves for a reason ;P
as for flashlights, well, it is required by the FAA and other regs, iirc that flashlights are mandatory on flights. required to be easily accessible, so taking them is wrong, checking them is wrong too. i've never had a problem, and if i did, i would take names, and kick ass (later), and mail my flashlight home. don't be too surprised that the mall ninja min wage guard guy doesn't know exactly what your flashlight, or knife, or other pretty item is. chances are they know EXACTLY what is valuable, and what is not.
before the 9/11 incident, i used to fly with nice knives and whatnot. had a guard try to take mine, claimed it was dangerous and too long. you could tell he just wanted it for himself. a VERY official looking guy in a swanky hat comes over, asks what the problem is, and the guard says "dangerous weapon sir". i pass it over to hat guy, he looks at it and says "very nice, i carry one myself, let him on the plane". bwa hah hah.
fly safe, but personally, boycott it if you can.
bladite