Survival knife recommendations

Joined
Jan 26, 2003
Messages
5
I have a budget of approximately $200 to $300 USD for a fixed blade survival knife. I would greatly appreciate recommendations on a outdoor/survival knife... I don't have to spend $200-$300 on a knife it isn't worth it and at the same time spending a little more than $300 isn't going to break me either. If you have a strong feelings either way, I appreciate the feedback and the advice.

Some knives I've looked at and considered but can't decide if I want a knife in the 7" range or 9-10" range. My use would be mostly for backpacking/campling (hence survival).
 
The Chris Reeves Green Beret looks like a winner that would fit the bill for you. Welcome to the forums by the way

(EDITED TO ADD) You also might want to check out Swamp Rat and Tops Fixed Blades.
 
If I had $200.00-$300.00 to spend on a fixed blade, I'd be looking at some custom maker's stuff in the Exchange forums here. You can get some top notch knives from some of the makers who sell here. Or I'd be looking up Bob Dozier's stuff PDQ too. You can find Dozier's knives at www.agrussell.com . When you have a budget like that, you have some really decent options available to you.

edited to add:
OOPS! I just saw the blade lengths you stated. Sorry, I think Dozier usually does knives in the sub 7" range. He has a couple that I think are 7" and above, but they might be beyond the $300.00 range.

Good luck in your search and welcome to the Forums!


All the best,
Mike U.
 
I recently received a Camillus/Becker BK-9 Combat Bowie [9 inch blade] in a trade (and I also have a BK-2 Campanion [5.25 inch blade] "on its' way" from another trade), and after having had a day to look-over this BK-9, I'd have to put in my recommdation of one of these "Beckers", as they seem to be an excellent knife at an excellent price. The BK-7 Combat Utility [7 inch blade] might be just what you are looking for.

BTW...With your $200-$300 price-target, you can buy ALL 3 of these knives!
 
in the 15" range. You'll be looking a 9"-10" blade. A little khukuri is still a good sized knife. Plus you'd have money to spare to get a custom sheath if the traditional scabbard doesn't appeal to you. Hand forged, differentially heat treated blade with a no nonsense warranty for under a hundred bucks. You can't lose.

Frank
 
I concur with all. The best bargains are Becker and Swamp Rat. For the money you are dishing out you can get several quality knives. Just recently discovered that the Beckers have removable handles with using an allen key. Pretty cool since if the handles go to crap, they can be replaced with paracord wrap. The blade, I have read, is tough as heck. I am holding out for the new Swamp Rat Spec OPS. Modern tanto profile with a thicker penetrator tip. TOPS is nice because they use premium handle materials and the steels they use are sound. The Tom Brown Tracker is interesting. So is their Ron Hood Atax. You might want to look at Grohmann knives from Canada. Good solid knives. Cold Steel is good. Check out the Bushman. Some old standbys are Boker, Ka Bar, Ontario, and SOG. Glock makes a pretty good knife, too. And the prices on all the knives are nice enough you can afford a couple of them. Lastly, I saw something called a Ululet which made me take notice. Not a true survival knife but versatile nonetheless. Good luck.
 
For a camping/backpacking blade, it is difficult to beat the BK-9 for those size requirements. It is a very stout, well-made blade (.210" thick) of carbon steel. It has a thin edge and is very sharp.

It is full-tang construction with a skull-basher type thingie at the end of the handle.

The knife comes to a nice taper at the point, which could be helpful if finer work is needed.

This knife would make a decent chopper if necessary.

You can own this bad-boy for only $60.

For the money you want to spend, you can get the knife, plus a Kelty Redwing 2900 rucksack, and a Surefire E2e.
 
aosthed:
I have a budget of approximately $200 to $300 USD for a fixed blade survival knife. I would greatly appreciate recommendations on a outdoor/survival knife... I don't have to spend $200-$300 on a knife it isn't worth it and at the same time spending a little more than $300 isn't going to break me either. If you have a strong feelings either way, I appreciate the feedback and the advice.

Some knives I've looked at and considered but can't decide if I want a knife in the 7" range or 9-10" range. My use would be mostly for backpacking/campling (hence survival).

What part of the world are you located in? That should be a consideration in any true survival knife.

That being said, as a starting point:

When I think of Backpacking, I am thinking of roughing it softly unless you have specific details or mention something more severe. That being the case, you generally want something that is strong on general utility and light work.

For Camping, I tend to want something larger and heavier.

With your budget, I would consider a two pronged approach. A smaller handy blade you will actually have with you all the time. An AG Russel Deerhunter or Victorinox Swiss Army knife comes to mind. A Trace Rinaldi TTKK would fit this role as well.

For a heavier hard use knife, the Chris Reeve One Piece line and Busse Combat are well proven and affordable. There are many custom makers capable of making a good knife in this price range as well. I have a Trace Rinaldi Armegeddon in CPM 3V that is capable anything I can throw at it. Because it is heavier and larger, I am less apt to have it with me when I really need it. I always have a smaller lightweight utility knife with me so, which one will I have in an unexpected survival situation? :confused:

Trace Rinaldi
Chris Reeve
Busse Combat
 
A full featured Victorinox Swiss Army Knife and a Fallkniven A1 or F1. Spend the money you save on better boots.

Fallkniven make superb, economically-priced, bomb-proof knives. My A1 is a stainless 6" razor that'll fell a tree or fillet a field mouse.

maximus otter
 
http://www.knifecenter.com/knifecenter/index/hunt.html

Click on both the Survival and Combat knife links, there are several nice one's. With 200 to 300 dollars there is allot to choose from!

The very best would be:

Busse - Steelheart
CRK - Green Beret Knife

I own the Becker #7, which some people recommended. The thing is tough as nails and low in price. Really a steel, only US$ 50 !!

Let us know what you buy!

Regards,

JB :)
 
Thanks for the feedback - it s much appreciated! A lot of good suggestions in a couple of different directions.

Anyway, sounds like I have some browsing to do!!
 
Get a Bk&T 9 and put a good multi-tool in the front pouch . . . you'll come out under $125 and be able to do more than ya could with a more expensive knife and no multi tool. Just my two cents.;)
 
Modern backpacking typically involves no shelter building, and not too much fire building either. Tents and those tiny stoves are the norm. For such journeys, a good Victorinox Swiss Army knife is a "must have" tool. Even among knife nuts, the inexpensive SAK is the best tool for the largest variety of small outdoor jobs. My favorites are the Camper (which is thin enough to easily be carried in a pocket) and the slightly larger Huntsman. I purchase and carry a lot of knives, but most of the hobby is simply ego. A good SAK would suffice for 90% of the cuts I make every year.

A convex ground fixed blade, such as a Marbles or Blackjack, is a nice addition to the SAK, providing a handy blade for hiking stick whittling and other woodcraft projects. The convex grind is the key to the best woodcraft with the greatest amount of edge durability, IMHO. Then let the smaller flat ground SAK do the small stuff. A medium sized knife, like a Marbles Woodcraft, would make a perfect outdoor compliment to a SAK. Then send the knife off to somebody like Kenny Rowe, as the production sheath leaves much to be desired. Nothing sucks more than a great knife in a lousy sheath.

If you’re going camping, where shelter building a fire making are a large possibility, I’d add a Gransfors Bruks axe or hatchet to the mix. Just choose whatever model fits into the desired weight of your pack. People rave about the Gransfors Wildlife Hatchet for a lightweight alternative.

This is assuming that you’ll be backpacking and camping in a northern climate. If you’ll be in a southern climate, I haven’t got a clue.
 
i recommend the Fallkniven S1...not that expensive but good quality VG10 blade...

since you can't have a knife do everything...you should get something like a kukri...


So my recommendation would be to have a multitool like a leatherman or a gerber, a fallkniven S1 and a kukri for bush clearing and light chopping duties...that way you have knives to do everything ...oh yeah and get a sharpener like the DMT diafold...

i don't think you should spend 300+ bucks on a custom knife meant for survival...in the end survival might mean you having to pry something open with it...or maybe shove it in the ground to secure a line...and you don't really wanna do that to a beautiful custom knife...

OR MAYBE YOU DO...
 
the karda (little knife) that comes with the khuk sharpens up nicely and the chakma (burnishing tool) that sits next to it in the scabbard, helps maintain the khuk's edge in the field. With only steeling the edge with the chakma I've chopped through an old fence post and still kept the edge sharp enough to cut clean through a free standing dandelion. I've seen cheap Indian khuks where the karda and chakma were useless, not so with HI. Just food for thought.

Frank
 
That Buzz sure loves his SAKs! ;) Hey Buzz, I got a question for ya...How much bigger is the "Hiker" to the regular "Tinker"?
 
Originally posted by crazy nicky
That Buzz sure loves his SAKs! ;) Hey Buzz, I got a question for ya...How much bigger is the "Hiker" to the regular "Tinker"?

The Hiker should have one extra layer for the saw, adding about 3/32" to the thickness of the SAK. The Hiker is still thin and light enough to carry in your pants pocket without feeling like a boat anchor.
 
Thanks Buzz! I just bought one...My two SAKs I love...I got a Tinker and a OH Trailmaster. I have had many over the years and always seem to misplace them...this time I wanted something as big as the Tinker with a saw and something smaller than the Trailmaster! The Hiker caught my eye and I think it was a wise choice!
 
High End: Chris Reeve Project 1

Low End: Kabar Warthog

Have both knives, both are great in the woods.
 
Back
Top