Survival Trip terrible time

Hey Zach if anything you just learned more from that short time then reading the posts on the net for the next month. With the advice you get on here. Your next time would be much better and more fun...After all it is survival. When i go i think of it as backpacking with out all the comfort.

Sasha
 
Zach, don't fret, we've all had bad days in the woods. Don't worry about the stuff you may or may not have done. Just as long as you had fun with it and learned something. You got out there and you did it, just keep going and get outside.

Shake the water next time, it gets oxygen into the water and makes it taste better. You learned and you did good bruddah, keep at it and keep playing in the dirt.
 
Good for u for going out.

Lean too's suck, small and tight with tons underneath is key.

Water, well its survival, u gotta do what u gotta do.

Skam
 
thats a bummer but look on the bright side.. your already planning your next outting.

Myself I had problems with wet wood. about 3 week-ends ago I went out camping but only with a sleeping bag/bivy.. It was relatively warm for me since I have the MEC hybrid sac and a good bivy that breathes.

We arrived about 6pm so it was already sun down while we were trekking the mountain to get to our spot.

My first attempt at getting a fire that night failed miserably because I was unprepared with fuel. it was so cold that even splitting wood would reveal frost on the inside and damp wood was plentiful. I setteled that night with just waiting it out in my sac while morning arrived and then I gave it another go.. I spotted several dry standing trees and took them down. splitted them and prep my shavings and feather sticks and had a nice blaze going all the way till sundown, then I dropped 3 other dead standing trees to make through the night. and it was plenty with a genereous blaze the entire time. it was -15deg celcius throughout the entire week-end.

the moral of the story if any is... patience is a virtue especially when its freezing out.
 
I usually will put a little charcoal in the water, shake it and sometimes add a few pine or spruce needles while it's boiling. Works pretty well for the taste.

Sounds like you'll learn a lot from the experience. Compare your trip to sitting in an office all day and it suddenly doesn't seem so bad ;)
 
Sounds like a great experience and a trip you can take a lot away from.

As many have stated, survival is not usually about comfort, it's about making it through. A small PSK should be designed to have the bare minimum to get you through a variety of situations. I use this as my core and everything else I add is for comfort.

I spent more than a decade as a professional mountain guide and more about 2 decades as an alpinist. Alpinism = suffering. Once you realize that you're not at Disneyland then things get better. I've suffered plenty on big mountains all around the world and if I KNOW that I will suffer but I will survive then the experience becomes much easier to bear.Simply having that knowledge will get you through most situations, as long as you have a strong head and a strong heart.

If you're practicing skills and it's just too much for you at this time in your life, then set up a tent and sleeping bag (preferrably out of site so that it's not too much of a temptation) and use that as an insurance policy. If you think you can't do it, then retreat to your alternate camp. It's much better to practice these skills before you need them. It's also not good to let all of this daunt you and give up on them. When I was in the military my mantra to my men was "More sweat in training means less blood in combat." Learn the skills when you're practicing and when you really need them you'll have them and be able to use them confidently.

All too often in the past I found myself learning skills because I foolishly put myself into bad situations. Not ideal. Don't give up...as you develop your skills it'll become more fun to you.

I'm stepping off of my soap box now.

Good luck with all of it!
 
Last edited:
Well, Zach, now you know why Bear Grylls spends his nights in a hotel! :D

Seriously, it's survival, and you survived. Good job! Now think about what you'd do differently -

If you're going to stay with a tarp type shelter, learn how to make a small, enclosed shelter with a tarp.

If you know you'll be somewhere where good firewood isn't available, what do you need to stay warm at night? Make sure you always have it with you.

So the water has sulfur in it - tough to get out, not poisonous, so learn how to cover the taste, or just learn to live with it. (It's survival, remember?)

Anyway, congrats - you made it back alive, you survived! :thumbup:
 
Hi all,

Zach great job that you got out and stayed in your shelter. To bad about the water tasting bad. There has been some good advise on some things you can do to rememdy that. Pine needle tea is great and the pouring the water back and forth I have never tried that. I have in my pack some Propel packets. They really taste good when mixed in water, you might try something like that. they are made by Gatorade. 2 weeks and 1 day ago, I spent the night out and under a AMK heat sheet. I have and carry a shoulder bag with some survival goodies in it and with the clothes on my back have and still do stay out every once in while,( like 2 weeks ago and going to do it again tomorrow night ) just like if I went for a hike and got lost and had to spend the night out. I got my water from the creek that was near my camping spot. Here is what my shelter for the night looked like.

101_1305.jpg


This pic was taken about 3:30 am ( I had to go pee LOL) so I thought I would take a pic of my little camp site.

101_1322.jpg


Here is a pic of me and the fire after I got in and under the heat sheet. I just held the camera and in the back of me and took the pic.


101_1312.jpg



This pic was taken at 5:30 am I was getting another pot of water so I could have some more coco.

101_1320.jpg


Thank God for being able to take pics with the night exsposure thingy on cameras LOL


Getting out and practicing these over nighters like this will get better and you will learn from them and it will really open your eyes as to what you carry and if it really is going to work for you the way you want it to if you ever have to do it for real. ( Like going for a hike and getting lost and have to spend the night out, with what gear you have with you and the clothes on your back.

I live on a farm here in south east Neb. I was out this morning. I went to a spot that I put up a canvas lean to type set up. I set this up almost 3 weeks back . It has been through 2 rainy days and 1 snow storm that dropped a couple of inches of snow, since I put it up. This pic was taken after I set it up and then went home and got Kathy. We went back that evening to have a fire and coco and just plain relax around the fire for the evening. Here is Kathy in the lean to holding a Axe that I got from Brian Andrews.

101_1337.jpg

After we got there and got the fire going. ( on purpose I did this) I asked kathy if she was warm enough by the fire. She said yes but the ground is cold sitting on just the tarp. I said to her well what should we do about it. She said umm LOL I said how about I get some dried grass. Here is the pic she took of me with the grass stalks I had collected. It took about 3 minutes to collect that much. Way more than enough to insulate us. the temp was 21 degrees with a north breeze.

101_1336.jpg


Once I put that grass under the part of the tarp we were going to be sitting on. Again once we got back in under the tarp and settled in. I asked her a few minutes later if she was warn enough. This time she said yes. That grass that I put down was only about 2.5" high. Only through practice and with using different materails for insulation will you know how much you will need. I have used prairie grass just like that, before so I knew how much I needed to get for insulating us from the cold ground. Remember the temp was 21 degrees and with a breeze comming from the north.

I used just about that much 2 weeks and 1 day ago to when I stayed out then.

I know some have said that the lean to is not any good to use and that you need so many inches and feet of this and that to keep warm. I happen to like the lean to and have practiced enough to know what I need for insulation form the ground. Every body is different so you will have to try it out and see what works for you. Yes a three sided and shelter is warmer but in a pinch the leanto is set up and with a fire going I am plenty warm. I only learned this through practice and in different temperatures.
Now as to wood the same thing will appy. How much wood do you need to make it through the night with the clothes on your back. only through practice will you know that to. So when you go out again take your watch and do a time study on the wood that you use ( hopefuly you will know what kind of wood you use) to see how long it will burn. At 50 degrees If I have a pile of sticks ( roughly 1.5 feet wide and 2 feet long and 12 to 14 inches high and a light breeze) that are small finger to double thumb thickness in that plie it will take about 2.5 to 3 hours to burn through them. That is adding a few sticks ( 3 to 5) on at a time. That is what I did 2 weeks back. I started my fire at 7 pm and by 10pm I was ready to put on my wood that I cut earlyer in the day. I had 31 logs for my night fire they were in lengths of 24" or so and 2.5" to about 5" thick. I used roughly 3 logs every 45 minutes and all throught the night. (I used 24 logs) I put my camp fire out a 6:15 am thursday morning. and went home I had a 3 mile drive on my ATV to get home and then get couple of hours of real sleep LOL and then in the shop to make knives. doing these over nighters or even a couple of them you really do not sleep you doze while sitting or lying by your fire ( or that is how I do it LOL) . Even Horace kephart said in his book Camping and Woodcraft on page 34 and in the chapter called Bivouacs. Horace says the next morning---
A nights rest, even though FITFUL will help you feel better. doing a nights like this are not like sleeping in your bed. Well that has been my expereinces when anyways. like I said you doze and then put more wood on your fire and then doze and so on till morning. In the same chapter but at the end of it Horace says to Keep a stiff upper lip and do not let your self think of this as a tragedy ( that you had to stay the night out) but aninteressting adventure. I like to think of these times that I spend out at night with a tarp and fire. as a camping trip but with out my sleeping bag, tent, hotdogs, and marsh mellows and so on and so forth. LOL unless you really carry these items for just a hike or walk LOL. I am sure some how see what I carry think that is way to much gear for a hike. ( my shoulder bag and the contents inside and the axe and the knife that I carry on the sling weighs in a just under 11 pounds.) But I do not care, I carry what I carry because of the practice that I do and the years of hiking and camping. So keep practiceing Zach only by doing this will you know works for you and what does not for a night or more out. If am on the tractor moving big round bales of hay for my brother to feed cattle or on my ATV moving cattle from one part of the farm to another or just going to the shop ( to make knives) from the house I take that shoulder bag with me. If I am in the shop and decide to quite making knives because I decide I feel like going for a walk/hike all I do is grab my coat and sling my shoulder bag over my shouder, put put my gloves on ( i always wear my filson hat LOL) and grab my walking stick and whistle for Kelly Girl ( she is always ready for a walk LOL) be a 45 minute walk or heading into the timber and then setting up a AMK lean to ( I normally have a canvas tarp or 2 set up lean to style some where in the timber just for this purpose. Heat sheets cost money and they never pack up like when you first take them out of the packge LOL) and getting in a nights worth of wood for a fire to lay by it for the night, that pack is wtih me.

Just this morning Kelly Girl and I headed out to the timber and I went to that tarp that I set up about 3 weeks ago to have a fire and set up a poncho that I got yesterday from a camping store in Lincoln Ne. here is the pic I set it up just for fun near the canvas one and higher up. Notice the fire in the pic and my carhart coat in the lean to. I go to hot with it on and decided to vacate the lean to to take a pic. of the set up. The temp was 20 degrees and a north breeze blowing. with just a lite weight and a med. thermal shirts
on I was chilly then so I took to pics and then went back in under the tarps to warm up.
101_1380.jpg


101_1379.jpg



That is the same place I will be staying tomorrow night. With my pack and the clothes on my back. only this time I am going to wear my lite weight long john bottoms LOL. That is what I wore this morning. I was out and sitting by the fire from 9:15am this mornig to about 1pm this after noon. while sitting next to that fire and sitting on top of the roughly 2.5" of dreid grass stalks and the little bit of the canvas tarp I was plenty warm. kelly girl ran around next to the timber area looking for rabbits and what not and I just sat and feed the fire. I would go and cut wood for a little bit and then back to sitting next to the fire LOL


So Zach and all, I hope you get to get out and do some over nighters and see what they are like to do. they are great times and the practice will show you just how good your kit is or if you need to make some changes to it.

It seems to be a work in process though for me at least LOL.

Bryan
 
Last edited:
great post bryan btw the knife i got to you is still razor sharp and still the best one i own
my next adventure will be kayaking too. Man i wish i could do this for A LIVING
 
If you had a good time, then it wouldn't be a survival trip. It would just be camping.
 
Bryan - I really enjoyed your post. Your obvious experience in your neck of the woods really shows!

Interesting how different areas of the country have different needs.

Robert
 
Hi all,

Zach, Thanks, Glad you liked the write up. That is neat to hear that your knife is still going strong.
LOL Yes it would be so cool to get paid to do the out doors thing. I live on a farm. I have about 700 acres to play and hike and camp on. We have good water here to so just going to the creek and then boiling it up still taste good. I have a freind that has 461 acres that I can go to and just walk up to the springs and fill my cup and drink. ( I Know I know there are some going to say I would not do that. But I do. I have not gotten sick yet.
yes it could happen and it might. But any ways. That water tastes so good. the water just pores out from the ground under on the side of his hill. He has a canyon complex known in this area as the Steel City canyons. )

Keep practicing your skills and you will get better.

Midnight flyer, Thanks. I am able to get out and practice or play or what ever you want to call it. almost every day. and some nights to LOL I am going to stay out tonight ( my wife is going to visit her mom ) just like I did a couple of weeks back. sitting and laying next to my fire and inside my lean to.
Yes different areas have different ways that make your practiceing of out doors skill interesting to say the least.

Well I will chat with you later all,

Bryan
 
Last edited:
Were the tablets water purifying tablets? They use sulphur to kill the bugs and taste like bad eggs!

If you boil the water properly you don't need purifying tablets. Tablets are only for when you drink the water cold. A lot of the taste goes away if you leave it to stand for an hour or two, then you can add some kind of flavouring and it should be fine.

If you boil your water, make coffee or cocoa or such like with it. Not tea, tea is water fussy.

Hope that helps!

Andy
 
some random thoughts:

tea bags, fussy or not..whatever "fussy" is, change water flavor. And, hot!

don't set fire to a stump, fire smoulders down through the roots...days later, could be a fire.

filter crud, purify after.

as mentioned, elevate bed...makes huge difference...grass, boughs..whatever.

Lean-to is what you wanted, but any wind movement wicks heat away from your body. At very least, in those conditions, see if ends of cover can be blocked. Even crappy tent contains air...but inhibits heat from fire.

One firestick, or a piece of Fire log in baggie, is a wonderful thing.

Body loses most heat from extremities...head especially...wool cap, fleece cap...something extra...big difference, even face mask.

Men, especially young men, are supposed to suffer for their joys.



Kis
 
If you had a good time, then it wouldn't be a survival trip. It would just be camping.

I don't know that that's entirely true.

Unless of course you're including bare bones trips as camping, and meaning survival as that if you get lost. Even then, if you're prepared (like you should be), you won't have a horrendous time. Maybe not even a miserable time. Hell, with the right location and a thick enough bed, you might even experience something that passes for a form of comfortable.
 
One thing we use to do in Scouts years ago (a lot of years!), was we always carried a pack of Lifesavers. When ever we boiled the water, we would drop one in while it was still hot. Helped a good bit with the taste.
Trips like that may seem awful at the time but they teach you where you need to improve in both skills and gear.
 
Hi all,


Terrill I never thought about the life savers trick . I some time carry candy canes and put them in my coco and boy does that taste good. well to me LOL
Thanks for tip on the lifesavers.

Kem SAT. You make a good point I think. If you go out prepared. that is the key even if you do not want to carry a sleeping bag while hiking carry a pair of inslulted cover alls( if it is winter time). they really work pretty good. I use them all the time and when it is cold they really work good. My little trip tonight I am taking my shoulder bag. knife and axe. I always wear a filson insulated with the wool ear liners for covering my ears if they get cold. It is still winter here, my carhartt coat. leather gloves and SAS head over. It really is one thing to go out and practice in the cold ( tonight lows 20 degrees ) these over nighters acting like you might have gotten lost. It will just be a caming trip but with the clothes on my back and hiking kit but with out the sleeping bag and hot dogs and so and so forth LOL. It is still practice and I even though, I will not be like, really lost and all or even hurt. But try this with a broken foot or what ever and see how your kit really holds up then. Or LOL try to set up a shelter and get your night wood into camp with a fake broken foot I once took 2 bandanas and 2 sticks and put them on my leg ( like if I had a hurt my leg.) and then set up my shelter and got some wood. I was thinking what a inconvience this was and I did not have any real pain like if it was for real LOL UNTIL LOL I did trip and bumped my knee and scraped my hand as I was trying to catch myself. I did not get hurt bad but for the first 45 seconds I swearing like a Marine and I was not even in the Marines yet:eek: LOL. You will really learn what your kit is like when you practice that way and what you carry after that to LOL. I did untie them 2 sticks and burnt them LOL. I learned that it pays to be real careful when walking inmy neck of the the woods LOL.

Go prepared that is the key.

yes I carry a little belt pouch with some basic survival goodies and with that and a amk heat sheet or a trash bag you can make a pretty good shelter and by draggin in wood to my camp area and starting a fire and burning the longer logs in half and all that stuff but that really is not all that fun. I carry that basic kit in case I loose my pack. but I still carry my bigger pack.
That is the really being prepapred and it is good common sense why take a risk if you do not have to. that crap is for bear griylls. well that is my thoughts.

Bryan
 
some random thoughts:

tea bags, fussy or not..whatever "fussy" is, change water flavor. And, hot!

...

Kis
My experience is horrible water just makes horrible tea but hey, whatever works for the individual concerned!
 
I agree with those who forget the leanto. A lean to is basically useless without a nice fire. I'm always afraid I'm going to roll into the darn fire. Just build a trapezoid or A frame or trap and insulate the crap out of it. I close off the feet end no matter what. I often position myself so that the head end is generally away from the wind.

I usually build a fire near the open end (head end) and just let it burn out. I've tried the "feed itself" style fire but it only works sometimes.

Oh yeah, I generally build a refuse shelter and use whatever tarp I have to wrap and waterproof myself inside the shelter, but if time is tight I sometimes use the tarp as the shelter. Keep in mind the refuse shelter is essentially a big tinder box with you inside. Be very conscious of fire safety. Heating up a few rocks is much safer.

Regarding the water... just get used to it.
 
My experience is horrible water just makes horrible tea but hey, whatever works for the individual concerned!

Interesting. I think I just found myself a taste challenge.

I'm more than willing to take different drink mixes and try them in some sulphur water. (Regular tea, green tea with flavors, mint, lemon, etc., also some hot chocolate and coffee.)

Not to far from where I live is a state park called Indian Springs. It's claim to fame is the Sulphur water that comes out of the spring there. The area used to be inhabited by the Creek Indians and they used the water.

To quote the site: "The Creek Indians used the springs for centuries to heal the sick and impart extra vigor to the well. "

Indian Springs State Park

Yeah there is probably very little chance of getting the flavor of sulphur out of the water, but this is an interesting challenge to me.

I think I might try Terrills Lifesaver trick. (It will probably taste as good as rotten eggs with cherry flavor added to it. :barf: )

The challenge will begin on Monday. :D
 
Back
Top