Talk me out of the Bear Grylls Scout Folder!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Jan 1, 2010
Messages
1,157
I've been taking a number of short, quick hikes at the local trails here in So. Cal. Around where I live, black bears, rattlesnakes and mountain lions are a very real threat, albeit lessened by the great amount of foot traffic the trails get. I've been trying out different carry methods for my BK11. Both pocket and belt carry have become a bit awkward, and regardless I'd really like to move away from a fixed blade knife for these short hikes due to the murky legality of carrying a fixed blade in some of these parks and trails.

I have an Al Mar SERE 2000 that I used to EDC for years. It was my first knife before I really got into knives, and despite all of the knives which have come and gone, it always has been around. Again, however, the SERE is a bit heavy and I really don't care for the blade shape for outdoor chores.

My eye keeps going to the Bear Grylls Scout folder to fill the role of a stout, light and convenient folder. I've never owned a Gerber knife, and I can't tell what to think of them from BFC. Some days everyone seems to love them, other days everyone seems to think they are crap. I know that the BG lineup gets a lot of laughs from knife knuts, but frankly I'm not very interested in his name on the knife one way or another. I think the lineup would likely have existed even had he not been attached to it. I also don't see how anyones opinion of him as a person, survivalist, scout, actor, or any other role really impacts the performance of a knife.

The few people I've told that I'm interested in one or two of the knives form the series look at me like I have cracked. I just can't tell why some people don't like this knife. Is it because of Gerber? The BG name? Country of origin? Has the knife been proven to be crap? The one thing I don't care for is the tip down carry, but otherwise the length, grip, design, and lock all appear to be decent.

I've searched around a bit on the forum, but I find little related to this knife. Mostly talk about the Parang and Ultimate knife. If this topic has been done to death, by all means direct me to the threads and I'll close the thread myself if the mods don't do it first.
 
Can't help talk you out of it, because I have found mine to be just fine. I've not had any problems with it.

I do prefer the larger USK folder with the belt sheath over the Scout though.
 
If you're drawn to the knife, I say get it, use it, and report back to the community! If you like it and don't get it, you'll always be wondering about 'the path not taken'... :)
 
Can't help talk you out of it, because I have found mine to be just fine. I've not had any problems with it.

I do prefer the larger USK folder with the belt sheath over the Scout though.

That is good to hear. Not a big fan of a folder in a sheath, although I have been thinking about it.

I would go for the Buck 110 ecco light, or a Kershaw blur they are US made.

I have a 110, although not the Ecco. Again, no clip and no stud aren't what I'm looking for, although I wouldn't dare say the 110 is inferior in any way. It's just not what I'm looking for with this knife. As for the Kershaw, the Blur is nice and I typically insist on keeping my knives stateside, but it is also double the price. It also strikes me as more tactical and not so much of an outdoors knife, although that could just be the marketing talking. The liner lock is also a drawback for me in this category.
 
Don't know much about the knife but it looks nice enough. It kinda has a "hiking color scheme" to it. I noticed you were in Monrovia, can you recommend any trails near there? I am in Arcadia for a few weeks and would like to try out some trails in that area. Already tried chantry though.
 
Don't know much about the knife but it looks nice enough. It kinda has a "hiking color scheme" to it. I noticed you were in Monrovia, can you recommend any trails near there? I am in Arcadia for a few weeks and would like to try out some trails in that area. Already tried chantry though.

Monrovia Canyon Park is nice, clean and well kept, but crowded as hell. Eaton Canyon is nice, easy and has some good streams. Millard Canyon in Altadena is where I used to go all the time, but have not been back since the nasty fires just a year or two ago. Lots of trails have just reopened, so you should have no shortage of places to go.

Back to the post... Yeah, the orange and black does have its appeal!
 
I fingered the larger of the folders the other day (the one with the clip). Very nice grip (the rubber coating works well), but otherwise lvery ight and almost a "tinny" kind of feel.

For something about that size, but with a much more solid feel, I would look at:

Benchmade Mini Bone Collector
Spyderco Native

Or for a similar sized knife that is a tank, The Spyderco PPT.
 
Ok, don't buy it cuz it's a cheazy looking POS. Good enough job of talking you out of it? :D
 
Get a cold steel raj or voyager series... they make blade ranging from 4 inches to 6 inches... They have zytel handles which is super light weight and durable
 
I have the clip folder and the sheath folder, and I really like them for what they are. These are not hard use, indestructible knives. They are both lockbacks, but they don't have liners in the handle. The clip folder is really thin but still comfortable in use. The orange on the handle may look tacky, but it makes it hard to lose. The clip carries deeply, the thumbstud works well, and the blade shape is practical. The serrations are decent, nice and shallow so they won't snag, but they still cut well. The blade steel isn't outstanding, but its perfectly serviceable. Nice and easy to sharpen, very stain resistant, retention isn't fantastic but that's why you have serrations, for the tough stuff. Considering the price, I'm really happy with it. Another cool feature that was probably accidental is the blade notch for the lock is exposed when the blade is about halfway open, so its easy to knock any lint or crud out. I use it as an easy to carry folding knife that cuts things and cuts things well. Respect its limitations and it'll work really well for you.
 
Every time I see a product with his name on it I cannot get the visions of him drinking his own urine out of a snake's skin. That image gives me the heebiest of jeebies....and that right there is the reason I would not buy it.

It sounds like you really do not want to be talked out of buying one though. If you can use and judge the knife on it's merits and not the BG logo, go for it;)
 
Not trying to talk you out, as each knife deserves evaluation on it's own merti :J

Some alternatives I can think of, for light but sizable blade:
Coldsteel Voyager, old one is lockback AUS8. I used to have one, sold it when I was out of my "knife phase". Regret it :)
Enlan EL02. Bit heavy, but really solid with good steel heat treat. My current EDC, carry it RFP or IWB
Swiss Army OHT (there's Sentinel with one blade, no tools)
From reading:
Spyderco Endura
Spyderco Resilience (the large one from Tenacious family)
 
Video by the great Cutlerylover( Jeff I hope this is cool)

[video=youtube;24S3SpIl7RY]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=24S3SpIl7RY[/video]
 
Around where I live, black bears, rattlesnakes and mountain lions are a very real threat

If your intent is to defend yourself against lions and tigers and bears with a 3.5 in blade, you need to carry one other thing - metal dogtags with your identity information on them. Why? They are not digestible.
 
If your intent is to defend yourself against lions and tigers and bears with a 3.5 in blade, you need to carry one other thing - metal dogtags with your identity information on them. Why? They are not digestible.

The point I'm making is that a blade more substantial than my EDC, which I didn't mention is a Canoe on most days, is not suitable for hikes in the area. In some parts of the country, carrying a 3"+ blade for short hikes is really unnecessary, but I would argue that given my particular area, the need is slightly greater. At 200lbs and 6'2, I still stand no chance against a bear or a mountain lion, but given that I can't carry a gun, and a large fixed blade is just silly for short day hikes, the primary role of the knife would be for light bushcraft, emergency survival, or defense. I don't think the idea of wanting a knife to offer even a modicum of protection against wildlife is all that silly of an idea.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top