The 2010 Forum Knife Continues!

[mqqn]

The post was about as clear as mud, so it was not you....

Knife A is the second picture. It is a wood handled equal end Harness Jack. One blade is a hole boring type of tool, not really a blade, but useful....However, the plan for the equal end is for 2 blades, moose style clip blade on one side, spear on the other, that is a nice combo.....
Knife B is a non locking Remington style trapper it is the top knife pictured, it has 2 blades..sort of like a hunter pattern, with a trapper spin on it.
Knife C is the last thin one at the bottom, with the wharncliff blade, which I find very interesting, whittler which has 3 blades, because it is new, but I am cautious, like to hold one of that pattern in my hand before I pull the trigger.

Thank you, sir!

I would say B - A - C then -

Thank you for the clarification.

best regards -

mqqn

 

[DaveT63]

C only for me

 

[waynorth]

I am voting A-C-B
and this is the cutoff post.
I will add the totals;

O.K., the first choices are in a tie vote.
24 votes each for the Equal End (Jack or Moose), and the Slim Whittler.

I've gone back and reviewed the entire thread. To help streamline this process a bit, I've counted the comments and assumed we would choose a Jack style over a Moose style, and with jigged bone handles. The Slim Whittler choice would be in Ebony or Blackwood.
So at the risk of boring you with too many votes, I will start another thread to simplify things, and ask for one more choice.

Remember we will still ask for proposals from all three Cutleries, Queen, GEC, and CSC and vote on those later.

 

[puukkoman]

A
B
C
That's how I see it.

 

[neeman]

O.K., the first choices are in a tie vote.
24 votes each for the Equal End (Jack or Moose), and the Slim Whittler.

I've gone back and reviewed the entire thread. To help streamline this process a bit, I've counted the comments and assumed we would choose a Jack style over a Moose style, and with jigged bone handles. The Slim Whittler choice would be in Ebony or Blackwood.
So at the risk of boring you with too many votes, I will start another thread to simplify things, and ask for one more choice.

Remember we will still ask for proposals from all three Cutleries, Queen, GEC, and CSC and vote on those later.

Thanks for all the work and patience.

Have we done a count like this on Queen and CSC?

 

[FLymon]

I am voting A-C-B
and this is the cutoff post.
I will add the totals;

O.K., the first choices are in a tie vote.
24 votes each for the Equal End (Jack or Moose), and the Slim Whittler.

I've gone back and reviewed the entire thread. To help streamline this process a bit, I've counted the comments and assumed we would choose a Jack style over a Moose style, and with jigged bone handles. The Slim Whittler choice would be in Ebony or Blackwood.
So at the risk of boring you with too many votes, I will start another thread to simplify things, and ask for one more choice.

Remember we will still ask for proposals from all three Cutleries, Queen, GEC, and CSC and vote on those later.

I don't know if it matters but I got confused by the pictures being out of order. I tried not to vote for the equal end at all and wound up leaving my favorite out. Oh well.

 

[waynorth]

It was too close. One or two votes wouldn't change anything. To be fair, we've got the top two in a "sticky" above, so vote again please.
Just a few more threads and we'll be done!!

 

[mhawg]

It was too close. One or two votes wouldn't change anything. To be fair, we've got the top two in a "sticky" above, so vote again please.
Just a few more threads and we'll be done!!

Just hang it there, you're doing great!!!