The Bark River debacle; where to go from here?

Feedback: +0 / =0 / -0
Joined
May 11, 2022
Messages
326
So the recent allegations that came out about Bark River Knives are quite damming, which really only adds to over two decades of shady practices from old Mike. However, the stuff that happened with Blackjack Knives and the various allegations thrown around mislabeled steels on some models, though obviously damming, were just that, allegations from decades ago and the occasional curveball (not denying them, especially in light of recent events) and for people like me who were simply looking for high quality materials, full convex, lifetime warranty and a family-run business instead of a massive faceless behemoth company, were outweighed by what we found in such company. And in the end, the performance was definitely there and the quality control was (mostly, we could open a can of worms on this one) there, though steadily declining through the years, with more recent runs of knives like the Squad Leader 2 having uneven, scratched fullers (the 2016ish run was far better polished), the ditching of brass guards in favor of aluminium, the usage of crappy hardware store hex nut to hold down pommels as opposed to the old Randall style nuts, uneven plunge lines becoming a coin toss, suspiciously underpriced and un-announced knives like the Highwayman 4 allegedly being made from Chinese steel kits... etc. Just gross.

Now, what do you think are companies that actually are what Bark River feigned to be for so long, or at the very least lost along the way? Family run, made in a western country, lifetime warranty, high quality materials, client first. I can think of White River knives, though they lack the sheer variety of options brk had, and don't know much about them; same for LT Wright. Great companies, but you don't have everything from small carving knives to survival knives to large bowie knives to even obscure traditional designs, to machetes etc. like we did with brk (again, flaws and all).

Is custom really the only viable way left if you want extensive options, high quality materials, not overpay, be put first as a client and not feed some faceless leviathan?
 
Personally, I don't need one knife company to "do it all." I don't need to buy everything from a small carving knife to a large Bowie from the same company. I tend to buy knives from different makers who excel at certain niches, and focus on specific styles/designs that are that maker's strengths. There are many very good options out there.
 
Personally, I don't need one knife company to "do it all." I don't need to buy everything from a small carving knife to a large Bowie from the same company. I tend to buy knives from different makers who excel at certain niches, and focus on specific styles/designs that are that maker's strengths. There are many very good options out there.
What brands have you found to be most reliable qc and price to performance wise? Nowadays it looks like everything's being bought by some faceless firm outsourcing labor; everything just feels both cheaper yet more expensive than just 10 years ago.
 
What brands have you found to be most reliable qc and price to performance wise? Nowadays it looks like everything's being bought by some faceless firm outsourcing labor; everything just feels both cheaper yet more expensive than just 10 years ago.

Buy from hardworking individuals like some of our forum makers and you won’t have to worry about being disappointed or feeling cheap.
 
There's no company like Bark River was. In terms of volume, handle material choices, and design variety, they were more or less in their own class. There are a lot of great companies with a better-run business and more ethical leadership making good knives, but nobody with the sheer variety of things Bark River put out.

There are a lot of good knifemakers, not all of them are good businessmen, and of the ones who aren't good businessmen, some of them are also unethical.
 
Just a few bad folks do not spoil the industry. So many great companies and makers that turn out great products at fair prices.
 
Just posted this in cpk's random thoughts thread, but figured it is on topic here too...

So, thinking back, I'm pretty sure I can credit BRK for leading me to CPK and blade forums. I had been using and abusing an ESEE 3 and an izula for a few years and started to get the hankering for a "nicer" (steel/handle material) knife. BRK were readily available, good looking knives and they really got my attention. I'm a person that tries to do his due dilligence when spending money, and started reading everything i could find on BRK. Well I found plenty of reasons/allegations to not take a chance with their product.

Instead I spent my money on a Fiddleback forge, then a mid-tech from them. Eventually my DEK 1 in aebl from CPK's website. So I'm of the few today that can be "thankful" for Bark River and leading me to these forums lol.
 
Last edited:
I don't think it will have to much effect on knife lovers . But now is the time to grab one up If he was using outside labor or steel to make more product, good riddance. I feel sorry for some of the big dealers that stocked his stuff hopefully they can unload at a profit. I just ordered a knife from a small time maker in my beloved 1095 .
 
Back
Top