The BladeForums.com 2024 Traditional Knife is ready to order! See this thread for details:
https://www.bladeforums.com/threads/bladeforums-2024-traditional-knife.2003187/
Price is $300 $250 ea (shipped within CONUS). If you live outside the US, I will contact you after your order for extra shipping charges.
Order here: https://www.bladeforums.com/help/2024-traditional/ - Order as many as you like, we have plenty.
You know what's better than a 9? Two BK9s!
It is a good user, but there is better for the same price or less, notably the Ontario SP-52 or SP-53. The BK point and edge are sharp, and this gives the BK-9 unusual versatility for a cheap big knife.
I've often wondered why BK-9s are so often slightly cooling warped (curved when looking down the spine): A very interesting explanation came up, on a Youtube comment section if memory serves: The sabre grinds are very loosely ground in height, so you have vastly different surfaces of full thickness from right to left in that the height of the sabre grind is very different, due to loose grinding tolerances: This means, as the blade cools down from the heat treat, that it is susceptible to cooling curving, because there is more mass on one side of the blade than on the other.
I find the blade stock is too thin at 4.9 mm, and that 6 mm like on the Ontarios is way better.
Be prepared to deal with a humongous amount of handle vibrations while chopping, this because of 3 factors: 1-thin blade stock, 2-Exposed metal in the handle, 3-Large skeletal handle slots (not a solid full tang)
I don't know if the SP-52 or 53 have had breakages, but be assured breakages are a long way from unknown on the BK-9, and hand vibrations from Ontario's full-surround Kraton handles are nil in comparison...: I have used the BK-9 extensively and I would consider this a major issue.
The best thing about the BK-9 (besides the edge) is the well-fitting sheath. It is really is quite good for what it is.
Another good thing is a fair level of edge finesse, 17 degrees per side on a roughly sub-0.040" edge shoulder, which means it is one of the few big knives with some small work versatility, especially in this price range: My recommended SP-52 will likely have somewhat less versatility in small task slicing.
The BK-9 is not a bad knife, but blade heat curving is unacceptable in my view. Chopping power is very likely less than half that of the SP-52-53s, although a side by side test would be nice to see. I have no doubt the Ontario knives will utterly pulverize the BK in chopping, for an identical weight in the SP-52 case (18 ounces, the 53 is 22 ounces).
Gaston
Re: aluminum handles.
While they would work and would not add an enormous amount of weight to the overall picture, I think they would be a tad impractical in very cold weather if trying to use the knife bare handed.
Another factor would be bi-metallic corrosion. Steel bolts/tang to aluminum handles may promote faster corrosion in all 3. Mitigated with lubricants, but still a down-check.
And! I would hope one doesn't do any Battoning with Aluminum Handles, that would Hurt![]()
Petelele,
Please provide with your thoughts on the knife once you have a chance to handle it for a bit. Please do not be afraid to use it that is what a 9 needs someone to use it. It will work Promise
Not to worry. 1095CV rusts....but you can prevent it some with a little care. After you dry it, try a little mineral oil or some other preventative treatment - wax, petroleum jelly....anything that will keep the moisture at bay. It's not a problem as long as you don't let it sit too long. A little unnerving, yes....but there are a LOT of knife brands that this happens with. I live on a saltwater tidal pond, so I know how carbon steel oxidizes, believe me. I have a little bottle of Howard's Butcher Block treatment (mineral oil & beeswax) that goes everywhere with me. Glad you're enjoying it otherwise.It has worked wonderfully for mei love the blade just have a small problem with the rust
don't know if i should be worried about it but i kind of am.
There are brown spots all over the non-coated parts of the blade like on the tip and the kabar logo itself. i even dried the knife with a napkin after every use so i didnt really expect this to happen![]()