The next one! (Or, a great fighter thread)

I agree with ndog (as usual). The Gelbu Specials are usually a little beefier than Sirupatis or Chitlangis of the same length. I say "usually" because there's a lot of variation in these hand-made blades. Regardless of weight, the edge geometry of the GS makes it more versatile as a chopper than the others.

I've never been convinced that any one type or size of blade is better as a fighter. It depends too much on the strength and fighting style of the user, and the prevailing conditions. In general faster is better, but if the user has no training and just wants something for occasional self-defense any medium-weight blade will serve and a Gelbu Special is as good as it gets. Keep in mind the huge difference between a skilled martial artist and the average person who likely will not be able to make good use of the extra speed of a very light blade.

I would avoid a blade that's too long or too heavy. It might be slow, or awkward in confined spaces. My main issue with the HI Ultimate Fighter is the weight. I have one, and it's beautiful, but not my first choice as a fighter. However, it looks intimidating and might scare off a potential attacker.

The Kobra tends to be slimmer and lighter weight than the other models, but the very long Kobras (25" and up) are pretty heavy, and feel even heavier because the center of mass is a greater distance from the hand.

Here are a couple of Gelbu Specials, showing the deep-forged fullers. The first one, by Tirtha Kami, is 21" OAL and 29 oz, fairly large for a GS. The second one, by Sher Kami, is 17" OAL and 19 oz, which is at the lightweight end of the GS spectrum.

GelbuSpecial21in-Tirtha29oz-for Dave-01.jpg GelbuSpecial17-Sher19-05.jpg
 
Thanks Mr Azar, pmwc78, RedEagle, Scara, Ndog, moparsbob, David for your timely input... waiting on Auntie to get back on inventory (GS, Siru, Chit). That 18" Kobra on the latest DOTD is also singing its siren song!
 
Last edited:
For a fighter, I'm surprised that no one has mentioned the reti knives (made from worn-out shop files). The larger retis are incredibly light and fast, about as far away from a chopper as you can get.
The reason I didnt mention the Reti is because it is generally accepted as a Kobra except the fact that is is made from a file with a little higher carbon content than the 5160 Kobra. Otherwise they are the same knife. I have a Reti and its one of my favorite knives. Its probably in the top handfull of favorites as far as practical use. Not the chopper but dang near everything else. Files usually come in carbon content of 1.0 to 1.2% or even higher depending on brand etc. They retain an edge beautifully but are a bit harder to get an edge on. If you want a fighter im with Bob on that one!
458b4a75fba916b2bdf847d69f758750


db45ec1db9fef27b2b0c558a089e652e


Definitely a fighter!
 
Yup, I prefer my fighters to be light, fast, and the center of gravity as close to the bolster as possible.

My Bashpati is 18", 24oz, and fast as hell, I am wicked quick with this my 2nd favorite.
9-16-13003_zps2cdb819d[1].jpg
Of course, my first choice of all is my BAS at 15", 17oz
BAS Lok.jpg
This Crow Knife I like as well
Bura Crow.jpg
I've been practicing with my East meets West knife, and it's actually very nimble.
East Meets West 01.jpg
Love the Reti as a fighter for sure! 17", 13oz
Kumar Reti.jpg
The Suga is a true fighter with a wicked top swedge! I've got a pair both at 11", 11oz
Bday Suga.jpg
The Tamang can be utilized as a serious fighter. 17", 18oz
Tamang 1.jpg
Of course, you can just us a Tin Chirra from Thamar!
Thamar Tin.jpg
There is also the Trisul! Got a pair of these too! 12.25", 14.5oz
7-16-14004_zps6237e2ef[1].jpg
One of my favorites that comes along quite often concealed is the Western Style Knife
2-27-15 008_zpsglzigt27.jpg
Take your pick!
 
Last edited:
Fantastic fighters Cul. Thanks so much for sharing! I never knew about some of these. I agree with your first choice! The BAS.
Update: Now that I have a BAS by Ramkumar I see exactly why Cul said his BAS is his first choice.
 
Last edited:
Fantastic fighters Cul. Thanks so much for sharing! I never knew about some of these. I agree with your first choice! The BAS. Mine is 17" as well. Your post makes me wonder if I'm looking for something that has already found me...

The BAS was my 2nd blade from HI, in fact auntie hand picked that one for me. It was far and away my favorite. I have many others I enjoy too, but I always come back to this particular BAS, made by Lok kami. It's really special to me, even more so that my carved SMAK, and UBE.
SMAK.jpg UBE.jpg
 
Love this little Reti 12.75", 7.8oz, Bone or antler handle, forgot which one auntie said.
Reti in antler - 12.75 inch.jpg
 
I love my 14" Kobra, but my 12" Pacthar is a fighter! I butchered a deer with it and it was amazing.

I love that Western Style Knife!

If I HAD to fight someone, I'd want a Cherokee Rose!!!!
 
May we see a photo of that 12" pachthar please, when possible? This one is new to me.
 
First Pic, second knife.
Second Pic, first knife.
Third Pic, third knife.

The first picture is actually mine.
 
Those Pacthars are awesome! I was on the fence about getting one, then auntie showed the wife and I one in Reno, the wife fell in love with it, that's when I made up my mind to get one.

The one auntie had was from her personal collection, so I have to wait until the next batch is made.
 
For pure fighter, it's impossible to overlook the liberty series. I think the L-2 is the slender Bowie ( Bagwell style) and that is hard to beat. I have a soft spot for the Cherokee rose as well.
 
Summing up: factoring in your input, assuming lighter is better (I'm now considering a smaller blade) and while there would of course be variations given these are handcrafted, here are the blades (from lighter to heavier) that I'm looking at: BAS followed by
Reti, Pachthar, Kobra, Sirupati, Chitlangi, Gelbu Special, Ultimate Fighter.

Which one is your recommendation?

P.S. The Ultimate Fighter, Chit and Gelbu seem to start at 18". I've heard of smaller Sirus and Kobras.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top