Of course I don't want to totally destroy the value of this anvil but I'm not really a collector either. I got this as a user. At the same time, if you think it could be worth a ton id probably just try and sell it and buy something new. What do you think an anvil like this could be worth? If I did keep it and smooth out the surface a bit, do you have any recommendations on how to do it without damaging it too much?
To everyone else, thanks a bunch for all the info, I really appreciate it. That would be nice if it was a Peter-Wright.
I doubt it is worth a ton of money but as it sits it would be of interest for someone to use or collect. If you modify it much it would loose its appeal to collectors. If you accidentally grind into the soft body, it will loose its appeal to collectors and users. I would just wire brush it and use it for a year or so and see how it looks then and if you really need to do anything to it. If you are new to forging you dont even know what works/doesnt work, what you like/dont like ect, so modifying the anvil is putting the cart before the horse.