To Griptillian or not

Congratz. The m390 Kershaws probably ARE the biggest bang for buck available.

I think if you lived with an axis lock for a while, especially a nicer one like the -1 grips, you'd love it like the rest of us, but the m390 Kershaws are certainly worthy of your cash.

I think Kershaw on while is likely the best bang 4 buck brand I can think of, closely followed, or maybe even equaled, by Spyderco.

In all honesty, I will give Benchmade another shot and will likely do it my next payday. Lol

But as long as I'm finding better offerings elsewhere I will jump on then first.

Thanks again to all, I appreciate you playing along any making offers. Because of the info here if/when I buy that Griptillian mini, it will almost assuredly be the 20CV instead.
 
I think Kershaw on while is likely the best bang 4 buck brand I can think of, closely followed, or maybe even equaled, by Spyderco.

In all honesty, I will give Benchmade another shot and will likely do it my next payday. Lol

But as long as I'm finding better offerings elsewhere I will jump on then first.

Thanks again to all, I appreciate you playing along any making offers. Because of the info here if/when I buy that Griptillian mini, it will almost assuredly be the 20CV instead.

Sharpening ZDP-189 isn't all that bad either by the way. It takes a long time to work out a chip or broken tip, but simply returning an edge isn't too bad.
 
The benchmade griptillian feels really cheap IMO. The handles make it feel very uninspiring. The knife is nice to be sure, but the griptillian is definitely not good bang for your buck.
 
Everyone should have at least one large Grip, just like everyone should have at least one Endura. They are both light, and fun to use. The color options are also a huge plus.
 
Last edited:
Sharpening ZDP-189 isn't all that bad either by the way. It takes a long time to work out a chip or broken tip, but simply returning an edge isn't too bad.

Good to know, thanks for that! I mean, honestly, it's just the tiny Manbug that I own in ZDP-189, so it's not like I'll be using it on anything that could possibly be considered abusive. I'm really not worried about chipping at all. I am worried about trying to sharpen anythingharder than 440C, though, as that's my only real sharpening experience, other than cheap old 420 stuff on my old Bucks.

I'm really looking forward to the thread about you in W&C...

I have no idea what W&C is, but that sounds very ominous. I don't like doing something so annoying or wrong that I'm the new guy being "talked about".

Everyone should at least one large Grip, just like everyone should at least one Endura. They are both light, and fun to use. The color options are also a huge plus.

Yeah, like I've said, I'm pretty sure I'll have one at some point, against my own judgement. I never accept that I know something for end all best all fact, and things change over years so may the one I had experienced before was totally different than the ones are.
 
I don't know man...starting a thread about a brand looking for a recommendation just to go and say how bad you think they suck isn't a good idea. Just sayin...
 
I don't know man...starting a thread about a brand looking for a recommendation just to go and say how bad you think they suck isn't a good idea. Just sayin...

It could be perceived that way, I can see that. I would perceive it as an opportunity, because that's exactly the way I presented it, or at least I thought I did.

I didn't bash the brand, I just said I don't like it and why. It's subjective, just as anything is. It came down to one thing, cost. I didn't say their axis lock was a bad system, just that I didn't particular understand the crazed devotion to it that I see a lot. I guess we see what we want to see in things. But if that's the way it was seen I can confirm for you that it was not the way it was intended.

I always focus on the bad because the bad is the hurdle that needs to be overcome. Same with Spyderco and I own two of them, one I love to death, despite how much I hate two aspects of most Spydercos, deeply. Just as a comparison point to illustrate no ill-will.
 
part of me wants to try a Griptillian again

Maybe I don't understand the question. You had one so you must know what it is like.
My opinion can be covered by this very recent (last week) photo.
The Mini is 154CM just got it last week; carried it the last several days :thumbsup:
I own zero Kershaws but many, many other mid range knives (~$100 to $300)
IMG_5469.jpg
 
Maybe I don't understand the question. You had one so you must know what it is like.
My opinion can be covered by this very recent (last week) photo.
The Mini is 154CM just got it last week; carried it the last several days :thumbsup:
I own zero Kershaws but many, many other mid range knives (~$100 to $300)
View attachment 970985

Yes, had one a long time ago, something like 5 years or thereabouts (time flys when your old, so don't hold me to it). Anyway, I just wasn't left with any great feeling from it, evidence in the fact that I gave it to a buddy.

But, and it's a big but, I also didn't have any monetary attachment to it either. I found it in a parking lot. Also it was partially serrated, which I really don't care much for. So even though I'm being honest and forthcoming about the fact that I don't have any taste for them at all, at this point, I'm open to finding a reason.

So that's why I came here, to be convinced. To hear others' reasons, because they may be things I haven't thought about it.
 
The benchmade griptillian feels really cheap IMO. The handles make it feel very uninspiring. The knife is nice to be sure, but the griptillian is definitely not good bang for your buck.

Have you handled the Mini ?
It most definitely does not feel cheep and has a nice weight to it due to the full length steel liners. :thumbsup:
I love the full size as well and find both very practical knives made of strong high tech materials. The full size is light and hollow with partial steel liners.
Sounds like you have one or had one so I will stop my defense of it right there.
You know what you like.
 
B BeyondTheBox , your hatred of Benchmade is based on...what? I've never seen you post a picture of a bad knife. Did I miss them?

I have a feeling you may be suffering from Knifeus Reviewus Regurgitata. Don't worry, it CAN be cured. I happens when a knife owner's "experiences" with a knife/brand are based on what they've seen others experience on YouTube, forums, Instagram, Twitter, et al.

The cure is simple. Turn off the videos, buy the knives and use them. Gain some experience that's your own rather than from the Internet Overmind.

You'll find your own experiences become valid and your opinions will carry weight. Until then, you might be better served to experience more and watch less.

I'm still not sure what the purpose this thread served other than to reveal your poorly hidden agenda against Benchmade...but I'll go read through again from the begining...
 
Nope...still looks like a strange agenda against Benchmade.

Hands-on experience that came from a "found in parking lot" Benchmade at an unknown time in the past that was later given away to a buddy. It failed in your hand due to serrations with no memory of the action or ergonomics.

I'm convinced.

No. Wait. I'm not. How do you even know you ever handled a Benchmade?
 
  • I ve always thought the Griptilian is a strong ergonomic knife. Very easily carried due to light weight.
  • It so happens that today I carried the last Benchmade I purchased a couple of years ago, the Ritter Griptilian, with m390 steel. One of 5-6 knives in my edc rotation currently.
  • The mini Griptilian is also a fine knife, but a bit small for my preference.
 
Thanks. I think it happens a lot. I know I'm prone to go and buy a knife I have no interest in because Reviewer_X calls it a Jewel or quit looking at a knife because Reviewer_Y calls it a Flop. We all have to watch for it. I have some great knives that I'd have never owned if I hadn't tried them myself before deciding. We all need to use the knives we like and like the knives we use. Like you said, same with everything in life.
 
Nope...still looks like a strange agenda against Benchmade.

Hands-on experience that came from a "found in parking lot" Benchmade at an unknown time in the past that was later given away to a buddy. It failed in your hand due to serrations with no memory of the action or ergonomics.

I'm convinced.

No. Wait. I'm not. How do you even know you ever handled a Benchmade?

It's not my job to convince you if anything. You can choose to play along or not. You can choose to go with it and assume I'm telling the truth or not. However you're 100% correct, I cannot possibly know if the knife I found on the ground was real or not. I cannot and will not deny that fact.

I can only say that knife didn't impress me in any way. And since it wore the branding I assumed it to be so. Maybe that's my mistake. Maybe it's spot on.

I've declared many times already in here that I'm completely new to this. I'm just starting to discover and identify what it is I like in a knife and what it is that I don't. I can only surmise now, in retrospect, what I may not have liked about that supposed Benchmade some years ago.

I get that you might not like the scenario, and that's totally fine and understandable, but that doesn't render your opinion any more valid or invalid than mine.

I haven't read anything bad about Benchmade, and everyone I know (because I live in Oregon) has a Griptillian and/or some other Benchmade, and boasts on about them, without any real reasoning as to it. So I come to places like this to try and get an understanding. To try and adapt others' experiences into a relatable idea of what it might be like for me.

It's all a balancing of the scales and based on personal taste and opinion. The only true facts in this are the measurable dimensions of the products themselves.

There's nothing I can say that will suddenly make someone else go, "oh wow, because he simply states that he doesn't like them I probably shouldn't like them either." So I don't get what the reaction is all about. It's harmless opinion based on taste.

If anything I would think you'd see that I'm here trying to understand. Trying to find a reason to change my mind. It's like using a soundingboard, talking through things to figure them out. If you don't like it it's okay, but what's the harm in an opinion? Offense should never be taken from a different opinion, taste or point of view. Especially when that different side is clearly trying to understand both sides. Or at least I sure think that's clear.

Anyway, if you've got a reason I should want a Benchmade, regardless if it's a Griptillian or not, please do offer, be constructive rather than destructive.
 
I own two Griptilians and like both of mine. IMO the Benchmade Griptilian series are some of the best knives on the market especially in the price range. Both of mine have 154cm blade steel and they easily took nice shaving sharp edge. Both came with centered blades and no blade play. I highly recommend them.
 
I own two Griptilians and like both of mine. IMO the Benchmade Griptilian series are some of the best knives on the market especially in the price range. Both of mine have 154cm blade steel and they easily took nice shaving sharp edge. Both came with centered blades and no blade play. I highly recommend them.

You know, I think part of what's holding me back is that they don't currently offer it in a steel I really want.

Like if they were offering one in CTS-XHP, I'd have got it already! But the 154CM just doesn't cut it for me, for the price (pardon the pun), and the 20CV just takes it to a price point I'm not sure I'm willing to go yet.

Hmmm, thanks for this post, made me think a little more about what's affecting my lack of desire here.
 
Back
Top