Trestle Pine Barlow

...
DA09944F-41BA-44A8-93C6-FB3EF66F4035.jpg
...

It looks similar to the blade on their "Country Cousin" sodbusters (except the nail nick is further forward). I think a spear may be a better match with the easy open notch because it would leave more room for sharpening. I think that may be why they needed to tilt the blade in the barlow. The sodbuster handle curves on the end.

large-qn70b.jpg
 
Not to split hairs, but I'd not call that an EZ open notch. Were that the purpose it'd be deeper. That area is relieved because it's necessary to access the nail nick. Without it the nail nick would be below the liners.
 
Not to split hairs, but I'd not call that an EZ open notch. Were that the purpose it'd be deeper. That area is relieved because it's necessary to access the nail nick. Without it the nail nick would be below the liners.

Can we compromise and call it "easy relief"? ;) :D

Here are some oldies for comparison...

Easy opener


Relieved area for secondary
 
I think that all of these oddities are why I find this knife so intriguing. Greg and Queen aren't afraid to throw convention aside and try things that seem a bit odd in an attempt to come up with the perfect user. The Superior is also an odd looking knife, but I've heard a lot of positives from people that have handled them. Some might call it reinventing the wheel. I choose to see it as thinking outside of the box. Either way, I think it's a fun line of knives that are very unique and I applaud them for their efforts.
 
Not to split hairs, but I'd not call that an EZ open notch. Were that the purpose it'd be deeper. That area is relieved because it's necessary to access the nail nick. Without it the nail nick would be below the liners.

You're right, it's not really an easy-open notch. But the "relief notch" is only necessary because the blade angles down into the handle the way it does, and I think that the sloping angle of the blade when closed is what I like least about this knife. It looks like someone was trying to file the kick down on a knife with a proud tip and went way too far. I'm also curious how much clearance there is between the edge and the backspring when closed, and if there are any issues with the edge hitting the spring. Seems like it would be awful close quarters in there.
 
You're right, it's not really an easy-open notch. But the "relief notch" is only necessary because the blade angles down into the handle the way it does, and I think that the sloping angle of the blade when closed is what I like least about this knife. It looks like someone was trying to file the kick down on a knife with a proud tip and went way too far. I'm also curious how much clearance there is between the edge and the backspring when closed, and if there are any issues with the edge hitting the spring. Seems like it would be awful close quarters in there.

That skinner just looks too wonky to me. It'd be fine (minus the nick placement) on a trapper or sodbuster, but it just doesn't look right on this frame.
 
I'm with Cory on this one, several aspects of the knife are unique, but intended for a practical purpose. It gives the Portage a difference in appearance that make it instantly recognizable as a Trestle Pine product. The size makes it a smooth, easy carry, and, at least on my example, the notch does make it possible to pinch open. The blade shape and size seem to make it useful for most of the tasks we call on our pocketknives to do, yet not so big as to be intrusive in the pocket. And finally, for me at least (and all opinions can vary on this) I like the lack of advertising or message shouting from the blade. Simple and sweet.

I think that all of these oddities are why I find this knife so intriguing. Greg and Queen aren't afraid to throw convention aside and try things that seem a bit odd in an attempt to come up with the perfect user. The Superior is also an odd looking knife, but I've heard a lot of positives from people that have handled them. Some might call it reinventing the wheel. I choose to see it as thinking outside of the box. Either way, I think it's a fun line of knives that are very unique and I applaud them for their efforts.
 
A relieved area is typically at an angle. The covers aren't typically ground straight down with the liner. The blade does look like it can be pinched open but someone who owns the knife would need to confirm. If the blade was a typical spear with a curved spine, then it wouldn't need to be angled down and there would be much more room to pinch the blade open. The notch wouldn't necessarily need to be bigger.

Cory, The glass is half empty. ;) With some exceptions, I like patterns to follow the oldies (I won't go into my exceptions here). They are timeless designs. But what you speak about is something that I've noticed as a general trend. I think GEC is doing it as well. Mixing and matching may lead to something new or a monster. Some folks think a barlow with a caplifter is an atrocity. Others want one. There's something for everyone... even if it's not a traditional traditional. ...GEC pairs a Wharncliffe blade with a dogleg and many other unusual blade changes. Queen puts an Wharncliffe blade in a folding hunter and an easy open notch and a sodbuster blade in a barlow. Etc.

btb01, Based on the photos, I also wondered if there's any room to adjust the kick. I think my edge bevel would probably already be pretty close to notch. If there's no room to adjust the kick then you will eventually need to grind a curve on the spine of the blade.... and the nail nick is pretty close to the edge already.
 
The glass is half full also. I think it's a very smart idea to run this brand and the SFOs. There is a much larger market for modern knives than traditional knives and I think there is a rapidly growing group that wants slipjoint knives but not necessarily traditional patterns. There is no reason that they can't both experiment as well as follow traditional patterns. The next run could be extremely traditional if they want. Or it could be something completely new. I look forward to seeing what's next.
 
I want to like the knife but it does just look a bit off...and I like caplifters on my barlows so that is saying something!

I think it would have looked better had they made a "curved" barlow frame so that the end sweeps up to cover the blade tip and allows the nail nick to be exposed without any notch.

There is precidence for such a pattern as I have seen pictures of such things made by the old sheffield cutlers. I do not know if they were called barlows or another name but it had the elongated bolster and bare end.
 
I think it would have looked better had they made a "curved" barlow frame so that the end sweeps up to cover the blade tip and allows the nail nick to be exposed without any notch.

There is precidence for such a pattern as I have seen pictures of such things made by the old sheffield cutlers. I do not know if they were called barlows or another name but it had the elongated bolster and bare end.

I was thinking of a curved barlow frame this morning upon seeing Charlie's pic. I really like the DE on the left side below the Case. That'd be a neat pattern to bring back.
Weird%20Barlows%201_zps4rwcqyxo.jpg
 
Nice looking tools, these Trestle Pine Barlows.

Nice to see you back, Andi!

I want to like the knife but it does just look a bit off...and I like caplifters on my barlows so that is saying something!

I think it would have looked better had they made a "curved" barlow frame so that the end sweeps up to cover the blade tip and allows the nail nick to be exposed without any notch.

There is precidence for such a pattern as I have seen pictures of such things made by the old sheffield cutlers. I do not know if they were called barlows or another name but it had the elongated bolster and bare end.

I was thinking of a curved barlow frame this morning upon seeing Charlie's pic. I really like the DE on the left side below the Case. That'd be a neat pattern to bring back...

Good idea.
 
You can find that pattern from time to time as a kabar curved barlow. Not sure who made it for them at the time, but I've seen two members post pics of these curved barlows. One green and one blue.
I was thinking of a curved barlow frame this morning upon seeing Charlie's pic. I really like the DE on the left side below the Case. That'd be a neat pattern to bring back.
Weird%20Barlows%201_zps4rwcqyxo.jpg
 
Trestle Pines Barlow first impression-

Specs-
625″ Bolster to tip
Half Stop: Yes
Steel: 154CM
Blade thickness: .063″ at the mid point
OAL Open: 6.125″
OAL Closed: 3.5″
Height: .75″
Thickness: .43″

These were produced in both reclaimed wood and a selection of "exotic" varieties.



















I'm going to barrow Will Power's format that he used for the superior as I found it very straight forward and informative. After answering the basics I will do my best as a novice to answer some of the questions that have come up now that I have had two of these in hand.

Gaps when held up to daylight? Hairline up by the bolster.
Blade play of any sort? No
Blade centered? Yes
Arrived sharp enough to shave hair? Yes
Decent grinds/bevel? Yes
Pins flush? Yes all 8
Pinch open? Yes
Pull to half stop/open 3 to half stop, 5 to open.
Spring flush open/half stop/closed? Flush open/closed. Slightly proud at half stop.


Visually both of the knives looked amazing. Better in hand than the pictures. The double dyed Boxelder burl and Black Ash burl both have great finishes and are really nice to look at. There was nothing rough or unfinished in either set of covers. I could only keep one and went with the Ash. My wife picked this one out and although my covers are not perfectly matched( this was intentional on her part to compare the difference in sides with time and age) there were others available that were very well paired.

EO cut out-
As for the EO cut out or "easy relief " I would say that this was not an addition thrown in just to be different but instead is placed to be a functional part of the knife. Yes this blade can be pinched open but I feel like that wasn't the intention. It can be done, but with medium to large fingers it becomes a pinch with the very tip of your finger and thumb. Although the cut out is shallow and may look odd with the nail nick that far down the blade these were both positioned to make it nice and easy to open. These features combined with a lighter pull puts it on the opposite end of a nail breaker.

Tip exposure from the EO cut out-
In my opinion there is a good deal more room then it appears in pictures to sharpen the knife before the tip becomes exposed in the notch. With some serious use and a lot of sharpening you could get to that point but by then I think you could do some interesting things re shaping.

Knife edge and the back spring-
it is definitely a tight fit inside the liners and I did the best I could with a small light to try and estimate the clearance of the closed blade to the back spring. From what I can see the clearance is minimal but there are no indications anywhere I can see that the blade is resting on or hitting the spring. So long as this is the case the clearance should only increase with more sharpening.

Profile in pocket-
The knife shares many similarities to the #25 in a drop point. Although the spine sticks up and then angles into the liner it's not noticeable in a negative way and is far less than pictures would lead one to believe.The thin profile of the knife and OAL really make it disappear in the pocket. If you weren't checking closely you might think you'd lost it.

I have a tendency to be hard on things. It's not intentional or abusive but all my knives( which is only a hand full) are well maintained users and I don't baby them. Being 154CM I am going to run this knife through the paces especially around salt water. I'll gladly provide periodic updates on strengths and weaknesses as they develop. Hope this was helpful-
 
Last edited:
Great review! I'll see if I can get some photos of mine up tomorrow. Fancy wood notwithstanding, they were conceived to be users, and I'll certainly carry mine plenty.
 
Great review. That handle material is beautiful. I've got one of the ash burl coming my way too. Looking forward to getting an using mine. I've been impressed with the Trestle Pine knives.
 
Thanks fellas, hope this helps anyone considering picking one up or who just likes info on new arrivals. Post up some pictures and impressions when you get em in hand.
 
Back
Top