U.S. Army Issue Machete vs. Kukri?

I may be an ignorant RA COL. but I`ll be darned what this means.
I am sure that hollowdweller knows.
But perhaps not. I am confused now.
Of course I am a male. My wife, who was an AAU diver would have no chance of going through Jump school or Ranger School, which are the easy courses.
We have a lot harder ones, believe me.
hollowdweller said:
Is that your way of saying you are of the male gender:confused:
 
Warlock6 said:
Gee Howard what did I say?
Has the forum gone the way of PC, whatever that is, since Bill left?

When you are wounded and lying on Afganistan`s plains
And the women come out to cut up what remains
Just roll on your rifle and blow out your brains
And go to your god like a soldier


Is Kipling acceptable?

I just do not know what you people want.

Stay Safe.

Col. Daniel,

Politics is as alive now as it was thousands of years ago when an Athenian general was hanged by his own countrymen for pursuing the enemy rather than stopping the ships to pick the Athenian dead out of the water.

You've seen the reality before. Best to use all of your skills to their best advantage.

You have a lot to teach.

Namaste.

PS - Kipling is great!
 
Howard Wallace said:
Col. Daniel,

Politics is as alive now as it was thousands of years ago when an Athenian general was hanged by his own countrymen for pursuing the enemy rather than stopping the ships to pick the Athenian dead out of the water.

You've seen the reality before. Best to use all of your skills to their best advantage.

You have a lot to teach.

Namaste.

PS - Kipling is great!

More info on that story please... That is one that I do not know about...:thumbup:
 
What skill ? I am not a staff officer, although I have filled out that uniforn.
I kill people and blow up their stuff.
Or plan it.
In cop mode I cuff people and call for transport.
Few are going to call me a nice guy.
But I am willing to die.
You have no better friend.

Which story was that?
 
Despite the Army`s claim to leave no man behind that is bull.
I am not going to send good after bad.
The mission comes first.
The dead can sort out their own fate.



Howard Wallace said:
Col. Daniel,

Politics is as alive now as it was thousands of years ago when an Athenian general was hanged by his own countrymen for pursuing the enemy rather than stopping the ships to pick the Athenian dead out of the water.

You've seen the reality before. Best to use all of your skills to their best advantage.

You have a lot to teach.

Namaste.

PS - Kipling is great!
 
Sure, a kukukuri can do some things better than a machete. I have an Army machete and an Army Bolo and an Army smatchet.
The thing they have in common is they are light weight, well, the bolo is not. As a Para Inf. I like that. Bring a file.
The kuk is heavy.
Only you can decide if one chop does all is what you need.



Since when have we been afraid of fights on this forum?
The kukuri has its uses. You should be able to tell by looking at one.
There are things that Pangas and machetes do better.
What is your point?
Bill woud have sent you one. If you like it, pay him.
A kukuri does require more stooping.
Notice the spelling.

kgriggs8 said:
Not trying to pick any fights or anything, I just want to know from people that use and like Kukris, what they think of them as an all around cutter vs. something like the plain old U.S. machete. I have a Ontario U.S. PE plain Jane machete and it has served me well as an all around outdoor cutting tool for about 15 solid years now. I have bought several other items to try and take the place of it but every hachet, bowie, saw or whatever ends up on the shelf somewhere and the old machete gets all the use.

It may be that after 15 straight years of using the same tool, I have grown too used to it to be a good judge so that is where you all come in. Am I missing something by not owning a good quality Kurkri? I did buy a cheap Colt Steel Kukri, it is the one that costs about $15. I was not impressed with the cutting ability of it and I don't think it had anything to do with the quality. It appeared to be of about the same quality and price of my beloved Army Machete but it just didn't work as well. I fear it may be a design thing so I don't want to risk big money on a nice Kukri only to find that the design is what I didn't like.

It felt hard to chop with and gave my hand cramps because of the angle. It felt like I had to grip it very tight where the machete can be gripped a little looser and takes much less effort to do just about any task.

In all honesty, can a Kukri be a better user and all around outdoor cutter than a good machete?
 
jamesraykenney said:
More info on that story please... That is one that I do not know about...:thumbup:

It's been almost 30 years since I read Thucydides' "History of the Peloponnesian Wars." The incident is related therein, although after so much time I wonder if I got the details correct.
 
Howard Wallace said:
It's been almost 30 years since I read Thucydides' "History of the Peloponnesian Wars." The incident is related therein, although after so much time I wonder if I got the details correct.

I found the book online HERE, but I have not found the reference yet...
 
jamesraykenney said:
I found the book online HERE, but I have not found the reference yet...

The books in that reference seem to terminate in mid sentence, before they are complete. Another reference might be better.
 
I would not stop hot pursuit to pick up bodies.
I want to make sure there are no more friendly bodies. By creating enemy bodies.
I disagree with the USMC here.
I will not kill a live man to drag out a dead one.



Howard Wallace said:
Col. Daniel,

Politics is as alive now as it was thousands of years ago when an Athenian general was hanged by his own countrymen for pursuing the enemy rather than stopping the ships to pick the Athenian dead out of the water.

You've seen the reality before. Best to use all of your skills to their best advantage.

You have a lot to teach.

Namaste.

PS - Kipling is great!
 
I have a lot to teach about how not to do it.
As I am here, I have a lot to teach about how to do it.
The choice would be up to the student of warfare.
Tis it better to folow orders?
Or tis it better to use your own inititive?
Nelson gave only one order at the battle of Trafalger.

A CAPT. can not go far wrong in laying his ship alongside the enemey.
I recognize the god that is within you.

Daniel
 
I regret that my sense of humor is so remiss. I have been a bit busy.


Thomas Linton said:
Warlock, it's a pun -- a play on words. Bust. Busty. Female. OK?
 
You do not have the details correct because I have not.

I would recommend The Will of Zeus by Stringfellow Barr.
It is readable and accurate. Actually it is fun.

With out these asides, are going to have a forum?
I have enough kukuries.


Howard Wallace said:
It's been almost 30 years since I read Thucydides' "History of the Peloponnesian Wars." The incident is related therein, although after so much time I wonder if I got the details correct.
 
Shann said:
Hmmmm. UHmmmm. Yeah. . . :rolleyes:

So do you like a machete or a khukuri better?

They are opposite ends of the cutting spectrum...So as for as usability goes, it is impossible to answer that question...

As for as value... The machete gives more cutting ability for the buck(once you convex the edge and work over the handle...

As for as pride of ownership and just plain LIKING... The Khukuri is far ahead...
 
Back
Top