Jeff
A set of standards would be general information only. It should include just basic information.
Maybe Rockwell hardness of the blade in general, Blade grind type, flat, hollow, convex, tanto. So on and so on.
As you and everyone can see who the here folks who are hollaring the loudest.
This needs to be done for general public information. The information should be gathered from knifemakers, heat treaters,
And testers who can be trusted for a real NON BIASED opinion.
If we could just start with one basic database of information about knife blade materials as a beginning, the database would grow from that . All we need is a start.
Cliff has a good point. But it does not apply here.
Two knifemakers will have two opinions and make the knife in two different ways.
They will perform different to a degree.
The answer is:
The database is not about knifemakers and how they make knives.
It would be about (common) blade materials in general for now. Thats the difference. It should include some comments about how the material in question performs certain tasks as a blade material in general. There would be NO names attached to the comments.
Testing
As for companies sending knives to testers.
I think unbiased opinions are great as long as the person says nothing about the tests in public without permission. This would stop testers branding a product. This way respect for the product can be gained from real information. Changes in the products performance would be between the company and the tester. This would stop the chest swelling and BS lies that point folks to the products that are BS.
General comments:
I dont review any knives for anyone. But If I purchased a kinfe or was asked to be involved for my opinion, I feel that I can express how I used it (normal) and what I found about the product. This is totally different than receiving a free knife if you tell lies about performance. The other thing is that if you dont have a way of testing the product with the instruments required it might be a good idea to keep my mouth shut.
There are folks that know how to measure and check everything you state.
VG ---- Man I just fell off my chair!!!!!!!!
LMAO!
------------------
Web Site At
www.darrelralph.com
NEW WEB SITE TAKE A LOOK!!!!!!!!!
New projects and pics to look at !!!!
[This message has been edited by Darrel Ralph (edited 11-24-2000).]