Well, I'm done.

Joined
Jan 28, 2007
Messages
1,236
I am a pretty simple guy. I find things that work for me and I use them. When I have a set of tasks, I pick tools that I think will help, then I experiment with different ones to see what works best. After a while, I end up settling on a particular tool that seems to work for me, and I get myself set up with that tool, or that type of tool.

A good example is the M14. Years ago I decided I wanted a rifle that was non-restricted in this country, capable of putting down animals up to a few hundred pounds at any distance I think I'm good enough to shoot at - rarely over 250 m, but with an upper limit of maybe 800 m, not that I would hunt at that range. I want fast reloads in the event of using it as a defensive rifle, so that means mag fed. Semi auto also seems practical.

After toying around with various rifles for a while, I got my hands on my first Norinco M14. That's the tool for the job. I have five M14s now, but I really only need a couple. The others are just for fun and a couple of them are only half built anyway. Further experience led me to the 18.5" barrel and the USGI fiberglass stock...then the NM spring guide, and M1 sights. I now feel as though I am done on defensive rifles. I don't really need anything else, and whatever I buy now is just for grins.

But this isn't a gun forum. It's a knife forum.

I have been using knives - mainly fixed blades - a lot, since I was a little kid. I guess I was lucky to grow up with a deranged hermit of a father, because I always had knives and carved and whittled and cut things from when I was quite young...I probably had a childhood more like someone raised eighty years ago than someone raised in the nineteen eighties!

Like a lot of heavy knife users, I ran across Moras pretty early on. I think we always had a few in the house and they are, of course, great cutters. It's a good shape for a knife, bit of belly, good geometry for slicing, comfy handle...I have never wanted all that much more. Just maybe a little more durability, not that I've ever really hurt one. But if you couldn't get another knife, you'd maybe want something just a little tougher. The carbon steel is pretty good. Maybe tool steel would be just a bit better, though.

But the basic proportions are about right. I don't really go for wide blades...to unweildy as you cut. Only really good for chopping. Don't like thick blades, either...my Scrapyard Guard is thick (and wide) and it's not particularly useful, really.

No, I just wanted something like a Mora, but better. Like a Mora on steroids.

So I started a thread asking for suggestions. I got a lot of good advice. One knife I considered right off the bat was a Bark River Aurora, and ultimately that's what I bought, with black and green linen micarta handles. It arrived today.

I was concerned about the convex grind that the Aurora has...shouldn't have worried. It's barely convex at all. More like a very shallow scandi grind. The blade is maybe 3/16 thick, I would say. Just about perfect...good and strong but not chunky. Proportions very much like a mora. Handle fits my hands well...could be a little bigger but it's not small to the detriment of handling and a bigger handle would be ugly. Locks up good in the hand in every cutting position I can think of that I use.

Of course it's not 20 times as good as my good old red-painted birch handled moras, and if someone were to ask what I recommend for a wilderness knife, the Mora still comes in very close to the top...but the Aurora is really the ideal wilderness knife for someone with my combination of requirements and abilities.


So that's it! I'm done. I don't need anything more than this. If you live in the Northern woods, and you have an axe and an Aurora, you are good to go.


So there you have it, guys! It will be a long time before I buy another knife...unless it's just for grins.
 
:eek:

:eek:

:eek:

:eek:

:eek:

:eek:

:eek:

:eek:

:eek:




no





really


we at least you left it open - "just for grins" is a good enough reason.;)


Strangely I myself have been looking at the BRKT bushcrafty blades, they look like the next purchase, well one of 'em.

It's good to get to the point where you feel like your tool choices are matching your skill set, and the "what more do I need" question comes into your head.
 
congrads in completing your quest......I'm still looking for mine but getting closer...Perhaps you should post a celebratory pic of your girlfriend....JK...That's awesome....I know you're laid up for a bit but a Whittling review if you have the time might be cool...Congrads and good luck
 
As soon as the month ends... I will be ordering a Bark River Aurora... which handle did you get? I don't care much about looks so I am about to get the black micarta just because it is the cheapest. Green micarta and antique Ivory micarta (wtf is this anyway? it looks like clear yellow to me) come close, just $3 more expensive. I would love a red or blaze orange one... but they don't carry it in that store and they will be for sure a lot more expensive.
I am glad to hear that you like that knife so much. Take some pictures of it... some in-hand pictures will be very wellcome!
Mikel
 
My next blade purchase will be a bravo 1 w/ leather sheath in black or green micarta. I like a thick blade and a convex edge. I was looking to replace my manix, but took advice I got on here and found another manix. I am 100% satisfied w/ the manix and my swiss army soldier for EDC, and will only buy folders for grins now. I have my eye on a few fixed blades Id like to get (all bark rivers:D) then I will be satisfied w/ those too.

The M14 is hands down my favorite rifle. Versitle enough to be a sporting rifle, and practical enough to be a wonderfull battle rifle. I love my AR but to me, the M14 is king.

Its nice to find gear you are that satisfied and loyal to. It makes you feel confident in your gear.
 
That is awesome :thumbup: Looking for that "perfect" blade is a fun journey, but finding that one that is just perfect is what we're all ultimately after I think.
 
I love my norinco M14 and I had a nebula (similar to the aurora)for a bit, and indeed my first reaction was a mora on steroids!
I did not like how the handle felt, though, I am very picky and it was too small, so I picked up a fox river and I am a happy camper.
 
I'm glad to hear this. I've been looking at those for a while now, and managed to get myself into a passaround. If it fits me like I hope it will, I'm going to pick one up.
 
I did not like how the handle felt, though, I am very picky and it was too small, so I picked up a fox river and I am a happy camper.

I didn't know the Aurora/Nebula designs suffered from a small handle, this is disconcerting (since you both mentioned it). I have that problem with most knives too, that it's too small for comfort. Guess we'll see when it gets here.
 
I didn't know the Aurora/Nebula designs suffered from a small handle, this is disconcerting (since you both mentioned it). I have that problem with most knives too, that it's too small for comfort. Guess we'll see when it gets here.

I didn't know either! Telling but some pictures posted HERE by Cliff Neiporte... you can see how the Aurora in top has a bigger handle than the Fox River and the Northstar while being pretty much as big as the Bravo.

Someone stated somewhere that he uses his Aurora as his gloved hand knife just because the handle is bigger (instead of the Fox River I mean).

Mikel
 
I'm just like you in the fact that I want only 1 knife for the job. Many of you like to rotate knives, however, I like to stick to one (maybe just because its so difficult picking one if I have a bunch of knives). Needless to say, in my quest to get the perfect ones, I have picked up a whole bunch along the way. Sometime in the near future I will post pictures of my stuff.
 
LOL I can't complain about the combos that I have acquired since being on here or about yours for a matter of fact. But.....if you keep hanging around on this forum your collection will grow. :)
 
I didn't know the Aurora/Nebula designs suffered from a small handle, this is disconcerting (since you both mentioned it). I have that problem with most knives too, that it's too small for comfort. Guess we'll see when it gets here.

I don't think all that many people would find the handle small...the Nebula must have been smaller because compared to the Aurora, the Fox River looks small, and if that's a bigger handle than the Nebula...the Nebula must have been really small.

I guess the Aurora is a little small but the shape is so good that I don't see a problem with it.

It came fairly sharp, too...sharper than anything else I recall off the top of my head. It is definitely sharp enough for use right out of the box, which is nice as a lot of knives come embarassingly dull. I wouldn't shave my face with it but it would definitely shave.

So that's the go-to cutter now! Very gratifying, this knife! I am very pleased.
 
Your lagging behind me bro, I've found my perfect knife at least a dozen times now and vowed never to buy another !!!!!
 
I did not own both the fox river and nebula at the same time, so I can't compare, but the fox river handle curves around my hand and it's very secure.
The nebula had a straight handle with a swell, but it was just a little too small, the swell didn't fill my hand up enough.
I am just very picky about how it feels in hand, most people find the nebula and aurora handles very comfortable.
 
Misanthropist- Completely forgot to mention: we'll be needing lots of pics of the Aurora!!! In-hand shots give you extra bonus points.
 
LOL!!! How similar are your "perfects" to each other? Or how different?

For hiking I have always liked a stout knife in the 4-5" blade range, when I got my Scrapyard DM I thought I had found my perfect knife, but then the doubts crept in again !
I thought maybe the handle is a little too small and maybe the blade is a little too thick.....anyways then I managed to bag a Swamprat Ratmandu and like you I have now found my perfect blade, it has now been at least a few months and I have still had no doubts which has never happened before :eek:!!!!
However the odd thing is that I still usually grab my well worn DM as it's nearly perfect and I don't care how banged up it gets !!!!:D

Regarding your ideal knife, I have looked at Barkies many times myself and I'm sure I would be more than happy carrying any of them around that size range as well !!!!;)
 
Spooky - Will work on that, hoping to get my camera back today!

Pitdog - interesting...I've never thought I was getting close to perfect (to be honest I never thought about that very much) but after a lot of use I've definitely figured out which tool to use when, and what works for what problem...long process of elimination just ended up giving me the specs for what I need.

Hope that Ratmandu keeps working for you!!!
 
Back
Top