What do you knifelovers think about my custom tracker knife?

I just like the design of the wsk. I can understand all the arguments against it's perfomance and that most people think it's just a useless chunk of steel. But I just love the design and as I said, if it totally sucks then it will do a superb job at looking cool in my knife display. :)
 
I just like the design of the wsk. I can understand all the arguments against it's perfomance and that most people think it's just a useless chunk of steel. But I just love the design and as I said, if it totally sucks then it will do a superb job at looking cool in my knife display. :)

May I ask you a few questions?

Have you designed and made many knives before?
Did you base your design for this knife on what you think "looks cool" or did you base your design on what has worked for you in the wilderness?
 
I have designed a few knives but I don't make knives. Sorry if someone got that impression. This knife is made by a knifemaker from Spain...just trying him out to see if the quality is ok. The big plan is to have him make me a knife that I can give my father in law for his 60th birthday. This knife was designed with looks in mind. If it actually works for something that's just a bonus.
 
Oh, I didn't see that. One thing, if you take this camping you may not want to unsheath it around people you don't know, haha!
 
I promise to move as far away from people as I possible can before I start swinging it arround like a crazy man... ;)
 
I have designed a few knives but I don't make knives. Sorry if someone got that impression. This knife is made by a knifemaker from Spain...just trying him out to see if the quality is ok. The big plan is to have him make me a knife that I can give my father in law for his 60th birthday. This knife was designed with looks in mind. If it actually works for something that's just a bonus.

So you designed this one based purely on what you thinks looks cool, correct? That's fine, but...

1) Why ask what we think about it? You think it looks cool. I think its ugly. That's kind of where the conversation ends. I don't think I'm going to convince you it's ugly, and you're not going to convince me it looks cool. If "functionality" was taken into account in it's design, that would be something we could discuss. De gustibus non est disputandum, you know?

2) I hope you are going to find out what your father likes in a knife before you have one made for him!

3) I hope you bring a backup knife with you on your "...weeklong trips into the wilderness..." because bringing a knife that, if it works for anything its a bonus, along on a trip like that is a "survival show" waiting to happen.
 
Sorry if I asked a question you didnt like. But then you should not spend time responding all the time. No need to be sarcastic about everything.

I know what a good functional knife is and I very well know how to use one. I'm not giving my father a knife, I'm planning to give my "father in law" a knife. He is a hunter and I wanna give him a nice skinner knife. Not a fantasyknife like this.

AND I live in the nothern most part of Norway, almost in the bush so I know how to survive and what kind of tools I need. If you really think this is the number one knife of my choice then you have not read my earlier posts.
 
I have designed a few knives but I don't make knives. Sorry if someone got that impression. This knife is made by a knifemaker from Spain...just trying him out to see if the quality is ok. The big plan is to have him make me a knife that I can give my father in law for his 60th birthday. This knife was designed with looks in mind. If it actually works for something that's just a bonus.

I'm sorry...another question. Did you ask that knifemaker to make you a chisel-ground WSK style sawback tanto, or did you ask that maker to make you a "wilderness knife"?
 
Lol @ Thrustus. That would be a GREAT Klingon knife.

I don't think anything in marcinek's response is sarcastic. Everything in there looks to be something you should seriously consider.

1. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder (basically what marcinek said in Latin, same gist). If you like it, that's fine. Most everyone else on here thinks that it belongs in the "Tacticlol" thread, myself included. But hey, to each his own, latin aside.

2. For a gift for your father, given the response you've gotten on here, which is pretty much universally towards the idea that the knife is essentially useless, I do also hope you know what your father would pick. Because I can tell you for a fact that if I gave that to my father, he would hate it. Blade Forums is not the mall-ninja crowd. And most of us hate anything that reeks of mall ninja.

3. There are a lot of very knowledgeable and respectable folks on here that think that you will have a very hard time using that knife in the bush. Isn't that worth paying attention to? Either way, I think it's probably worth the warning that if you plan on depending on a knife, please bring a backup. No sarcasm, just we'd prefer not to read some story about a dead Norwegian with a Klingon knife.

That being said the finish, for what it is, looks well done. I prefer simple, functional blade shapes myself, so seeing that happen to a nice piece of Damascus kinda makes me sad. But since you love it, that's great, and you should be able to get a nice gift for your father. But maybe have him design his own knife?

-edit- Now that I think about it, PLEASE send your design to the folks making the new Star Trek movies. When they do get Klingons in there, how cool would it be to see that bad boy in the hands of a Klingon warrior. It's a better looking design for a Klingon than most of the usual Klingon knives. Or maybe send it to United Cutlery. If you're gonna make a crazy-looking fantasy knife, why not try to get some mileage out of it. Honestly, if you'd titled the thread "Fantasy knife" instead of "tracker knife," I think the response would have been a bit different.
 
Well I think it looks cool. Whether it works for you or not, that will be up to you. I hope you like it!
 
Sorry if I asked a question you didnt like. But then you should not spend time responding all the time. No need to be sarcastic about everything.

I know what a good functional knife is and I very well know how to use one. I'm not giving my father a knife, I'm planning to give my "father in law" a knife. He is a hunter and I wanna give him a nice skinner knife. Not a fantasyknife like this.

AND I live in the nothern most part of Norway, almost in the bush so I know how to survive and what kind of tools I need. If you really think this is the number one knife of my choice then you have not read my earlier posts.

Sorry..."father-in-law"...my mistake.

I'm not trying to be sacracstic...I'm just trying to figure out what is going on in this thread! I will just make one more comment, then leave...

If you are going to have the maker who made this knife make the hunter/skinner for your father-in-law, I think you might be making a mistake. Not becuase I think the knife is ugly or silly, but because I would want to see how the maker makes a hunter/skinner first. I don't think this knife represents the work he would do on a hunter/skinner.

Its like seeing an artist's oil painting in an art gallery, and then asking the artist to paint the outside of your house. Different things.
 
This knife is not for my father in law damn it!! I had the knifemaker make this for me to see how well the craftmaship is. If the quality is good t h e n, and only then will I have him make a knife for my father in law. As I said in an earlier post, the knife I mostly use when I go on trips is a Brusletto Fjord knife... I know this knife is not very useful just said that as a joke in the original post. Actually just wanted to hear what people think of the design. Now I know most everybody hates it. :)
 
Sorry..."father-in-law"...my mistake.

I'm not trying to be sacracstic...I'm just trying to figure out what is going on in this thread! I will just make one more comment, then leave...

If you are going to have the maker who made this knife make the hunter/skinner for your father-in-law, I think you might be making a mistake. Not becuase I think the knife is ugly or silly, but because I would want to see how the maker makes a hunter/skinner first. I don't think this knife represents the work he would do on a hunter/skinner.

Its like seeing an artist's oil painting in an art gallery, and then asking the artist to paint the outside of your house. Different things.
I see your point but I would just like to see if the finish on the knives he makes is good or not.
 
Sorry. Don't get upset. I know this knife is not for your father-in-law. What I'm saying is that because your knifemaker makes this style of knife well, it doesn't mean that the maker can make the hunter/skinner for your father in law well.

If I know a maker who makes a great machete, it doesn't mean that the same maker will be able to make a great slipjoint pocketknife. That's all I'm trying to say.
 
I see your point but I would just like to see if the finish on the knives he makes is good or not.

Very good. We are making progress. Do you like how the "damascus-style" finish came out on that WSK style knife?

Or by "finish" are you talking about "fit and finish"...like how neat the edges of the steel are and how well the pieces of the knife fit together?
 
Back
Top