- Joined
- Sep 13, 2003
- Messages
- 366
I can't say I would be able to anything with the two according to these rules. Transient 'Art' like what those two guys do... I don't consider that art. Wrapping an island in plastic, building a fence of umbrellas... these are not selective interpretations of reality. They're just attention getters; making a statement of nothing.
Then on the other hand is 'Transient' Art: ice sculptures, for example. Those can be art, but due to the nature of the material, are vulnerable and don't last long. Ice sculptures are cool, but the real experience is watching them being carved.
There are few things of beauty that exist but for a moment and are gone that I actually love. Sunsets/sunrises; a large field surrounded by tall trees, with thousands of fireflies, and a cloudless, clear night sky above; thunderstorms. While these aren't art, they are beautiful, and can move me as if they were.
For the most part, I vastly prefer more tangible forms of art. My favorite form of art happens to be music. Music is special because it actually crosses this boundary between tangible/transient art in a way. It's a form of art that you experience, and then it's done, and you only have the memory of the experience. Recordings are possible for repeated experiences of a piece of music, but more important is the possibility of learning how to play the piece yourself. Then it resides in memory in more than one way, so that it isn't quite tangible (and then only by the sense of hearing), but isn't quite transient, either.
Wait... what were we talking about? Sorry, got carried away there, but I don't feel like deleting it.
Then on the other hand is 'Transient' Art: ice sculptures, for example. Those can be art, but due to the nature of the material, are vulnerable and don't last long. Ice sculptures are cool, but the real experience is watching them being carved.
There are few things of beauty that exist but for a moment and are gone that I actually love. Sunsets/sunrises; a large field surrounded by tall trees, with thousands of fireflies, and a cloudless, clear night sky above; thunderstorms. While these aren't art, they are beautiful, and can move me as if they were.
For the most part, I vastly prefer more tangible forms of art. My favorite form of art happens to be music. Music is special because it actually crosses this boundary between tangible/transient art in a way. It's a form of art that you experience, and then it's done, and you only have the memory of the experience. Recordings are possible for repeated experiences of a piece of music, but more important is the possibility of learning how to play the piece yourself. Then it resides in memory in more than one way, so that it isn't quite tangible (and then only by the sense of hearing), but isn't quite transient, either.
Wait... what were we talking about? Sorry, got carried away there, but I don't feel like deleting it.