What's wrong with me?

Shotgun, I do see anything wrong with you, unless you tried to force your ideals on use large blade liking folks. ;) If it works for you, use it! I've found that a 4 to 6 inch fixed blade paired with a folder and a Machete or Light Khukri works for me. Different strokes for different folks and all that good stuff.

BTW If you ever try cutting up Large onions, mellons or squash on a campout, you'll find that a 5 inch plus fixed blade is really handy!
 
I prefer a 4-5" fixed blade. It is just what I am accustomed to using and reaching for. I also carry a SAK but pretty much mostly use it for the saw. Funny, on my last canoe trip, I brought a mid-size axe (B. Andrews modified S&N) and found that I didn't really use it that much. I split a couple of rounds that I sawed with the take down saw. Wife asked me something and I put the axe down for a moment. Then went I went to continue processing the wood, I just instinctively grabbed my knife and baton split the other pieces to complete my fire prep. Those two rounds were the only times I used the axe the entire trip.

Like the OP, I understand an axe has its place and advantages, but I mostly like using a knife. Somtimes a mid-size blade goes with me to facilitate splitting bigger wood. I guess I mostly just like to saw cut and baton things.
 
Shotgun, I do see anything wrong with you, unless you tried to force your ideals on use large blade liking folks. ;) If it works for you, use it! I've found that a 4 to 6 inch fixed blade paired with a folder and a Machete or Light Khukri works for me. Different strokes for different folks and all that good stuff.

BTW If you ever try cutting up Large onions, mellons or squash on a campout, you'll find that a 5 inch plus fixed blade is really handy!
Nope I think a good sized fixed blade is useful, to me it's more of how to carry it. Out of all the carry methods I've tried none seem to work. I actually find carrying my hawk comfier then a 4 inch knife. And another weird thing is I like using small blades for food prep. Back when I had it my Gossman PSK (2 1/2") was my kitchen knife.
 
I like the people friendliness of folders, and the multi-tasking capabilities of my SAKs, however having to choose between the two I'd still take a small fixed over a folder for 95% of my uses. I nearly always have a SAK on me these days because I really like the saw and the awl, but I almost always have a 3-4 inch fixed blade as well and reach for it more than the folder when I am not in a public area. In a different time I'd still be carrying a 6 inch fixed, but larger knives are getting so stigmatized and I need to have and practice with something I can keep on me that can cross back and forth between urban and woods. In the woods I'll just add a hawk or a 12" machete.
 
I like the people friendliness of folders, and the multi-tasking capabilities of my SAKs, however having to choose between the two I'd still take a small fixed over a folder for 95% of my uses. I nearly always have a SAK on me these days because I really like the saw and the awl, but I almost always have a 3-4 inch fixed blade as well and reach for it more than the folder when I am not in a public area. In a different time I'd still be carrying a 6 inch fixed, but larger knives are getting so stigmatized and I need to have and practice with something I can keep on me that can cross back and forth between urban and woods. In the woods I'll just add a hawk or a 12" machete.

As a kid I always carried a Vic SAK and then for some reason I just stopped. Since I had this one for Christmas off Mrs Pit I take it everywhere. I don't know how I managed without for so long !
Every trip I take the SAK goes in my pocket, if it's not there I feel lost now.
Just like you it's the saw and awl that I seem to use the most !!!

p32100081.jpg

By pitdog2010 at 2011-03-21
 
Good point..... but if I may ask..... what is THAT. Depending on WHERE you are the choice of tools will vary. Also..... the persons skill level I.E. (use of machete, hatchet, axe, large fixed blade) will most assuredly vary from person to person. Yes?????

"The normalcy bias refers to a mental state people enter when facing a disaster. It causes people to underestimate both the possibility of a disaster occurring and its possible effects. This often results in situations where people fail to adequately prepare for a disaster," http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Normalcy_bias

Exactly, tools vary on location. when users develop their own software with hardware they give themselves more options.

"But what I'm saying is once you have a piece of general knowledge, determine how many different ways it can be used to increase localized and specialized capabilities. And if you do that you start to have the one thing that's the most important thing in any survival situation: More options. The less options you have, the more critical each option becomes." Jack Spirko

"I think he means not carrying a large knife because of what others think. And no that ain't the issue. My unkempt beard and Nessmuk tattoo pretty much sums up my feelings on what others think. "

Perfect brother Shotgun. Limiting your options is never a good thing, especially when someone tells you don't need something.

Normalcy Bias has effected my way on thinking about tools. Some options I give myself I may never have to employ them, but I want them as an option in the "rare" event that I do need them.

That event will threaten my survival. To not develp mindset, skill and training with objects is foolish in my opinion. I would much rather have a hawk/large knife/machete etc to defend my life then my primary SAK trekker. I'd much rather have a "heavy tool" http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/s...or-survivng-th-first-24?highlight=first+hours incase I need to get a lot of work done fast!

Today I was working outside. I had my glock on my side. I used my SAK trekker to cut some hose to hook up to a plant system. DID I NEEEED my glock to cut through a hose? Of course not, but I may have needed it to actually KEEP LIVING AND BREATHING AIR if something threatened my life that could kill me VERY quickly.

Yesterday, I was out landscaping, I used my mora more then my machete. DID i NEEED my machete for most of the day? no, but when I did I was very thankful I had a blade with long reach that could vastly outperform my mora knife.

The Hawk, like a "big knife"/machete can give you that "heavy tool". You can develop software for combative purposes, and urban/wilderness survival. You have reach, options, and capabilities that the primary/general purpose knife does not.

What I see so many times is people are already carrying the "line" that could easily have a "big tool" in it. I might not need a "heavy tool" for mundane tasks, tucked behind a shoulder bag, concealed on my thigh, in my pack etc, but it's there :)
 
Last edited:
I wouldn’t say there’s anything odd about you (other than hanging out on a forum dedicated to knives and survival:D). Long ago, I accepted that some people are just comfortable with their own personal choices…not only that, they know them inside and out and they know how to maximize their effectiveness. Quite often those choices are based on years of experience, environment and their most common outdoors activities. I always discuss “bushcraft” with my son and some close friends…to me it’s more about using your mind and learning techniques with what you have or can adapt. A small blade “can” do several “large” knife chores with practiced techniques.

Your environment also has a lot to do with it. Where you’re comfortable with a small fixed blade for all your needs, I’ve seen 12-year old kids play around in a jungle with a machete like it was an extension of their body…and it was used for much more than just a cutting edge.

For me, I like to see other people’s choices when it comes to blades and how they use them…every choice will have some compromise, but it’s the user and how he/she uses the tool that is the important aspect to learn from.

ROCK6
 
Have you considered that it may not be the size of the blade but maybe the sheath? I love a medium sized fixed blade and always have one with me when camping. There are a few blades that I use more than others because of how well they carry. There's nothing wrong with a SAK or hawk but I have found that a good fixed blade in a quality sheath gets the most use when I'm camping. If you have a system that works for you and you're happy with it, why change?
 
fishiker,

I can't say for Shotgun, but I think there is a bit to what your saying. The general usage a tool, like a knife, will get over it's competitors deals not only with quality/construction/utility, but how easily it is carried, unsheathed and re-sheathed. Poor carry options have made me leave better blades at home.


God bless,
Adam
 
I went hiking recently with mates and took the War Dog, F1, Delica4 and a GB Small Forest axe.

The only things the got used were the axe and the delica. Next time I'm only taking a 4-5" blade if I plan on doing some bushcraft. And then it'll be the Aurora.
 
"What's wrong with me?"

Well, the rational and helpful responses have killed any chance for the fun responses this thread's opening question begs for.

Thanks a bunch, sane and helpful posters :D


Hey OP, I have about the same attitude as you. Not the What's Wrong With Me thing, but the Small Knife thing.

CHEERS
 
Your obviously crazy as a brick house rat!
Use what you like, its your life.
 
Nope I think a good sized fixed blade is useful, to me it's more of how to carry it. Out of all the carry methods I've tried none seem to work. I actually find carrying my hawk comfier then a 4 inch knife. And another weird thing is I like using small blades for food prep. Back when I had it my Gossman PSK (2 1/2") was my kitchen knife.

I agree. As much as I love fixed blades..I hate carrying them. I have found that only scout carry works for me..but YMMV.
I also like carrying a hatchet more than a knife, it could be that I have a hammer on my hip all day at work, but it just feels right. I am actually thinking that a hammer hoop is gonna get modded soon to have some leather wrapped on the steel loop, just so I am not making a bunch of noise in the woods..but I would feel right at home with my plumb hatchet in a loop on my hip.
I would guess that the fact that I have a tool belt on 10 hours a day is the reason that scout carry "feels" the best to me..I am use to the belt around my waist...but I don't know.
 
Hey Shotgun,

To me, a small blade and a nice axe turned out to be the better combination as well. I just sold my Busse FFBM for that reason. Izulas are a tad too small for me though, and I really like my standard bushcraft knife (and the size of it)..

I have a solution to your problem: If the Koster is "in your way", sell it to me! ;)

Best regards,

lightleak
 
Nothin wrong.

I love my 4.5 to 7 inch leukus for field work. I mean, if you want to baton, BATON!, and I have a bolochete around the ranch. Okay, and a bushbeater.

but the one that is always on my belt ALL THE TIME is a little 2 1/8 inch blade maple handled knife I made myself a couple years ago. always there, and always needing to be cleaned and sharpened, because I use it dozens of times each day.
 
Now that I think of it, I can barely remember the last time I had a fixed blade on my belt. When I do have them, they are in my gear instead.
 
For me for it all depends on what I;m doing... if I'm going hiking and don;t bring anything else I'll probably bring a mora..
its usually on a thing around my neck during any wilderness activity. and sees the mot use for general "bushcraft use" Carving.. prepping food and game etc. and general utility. I also use if for tinder prep when necessary.
The only thing I use a chopping blade for is fire prep.. and shelter construction if I'm practicing that.
I used to use a bk7 for almost everything but find the razor sharp mora to be lighter than most folders. strong enough for light use and relatively unobtrusive, and it raises less eyebrows from onlookers. My folders rarely get used when out.
I have several high end full tang bushcraft knives.. and while I love them I don;t use them much..
I;ve cut my folder collection down to only a few functional pieces..
I don't think theres anything wrong with you.. we all have a style and a system that works best for us.. when we start off down the survival road.. I think eveyones tool slection seems to emulate there mentors, or primary influences. as we progress and become more confident and figure out what skills we gravitate to and excell at.. the selection of gear changes to compliment our style.. Looks like you found a set up that suits you.. and there;s nothing wrong with that.
 
Back
Top