Who Carries a Small Traditional Knife?

Joined
Jan 8, 2007
Messages
55
I got the idea from a thread over in General called "Small Knife Carriers". With all the discussion of Peanuts, Lobster Knives and Sheffield Pen knives, I thought it would be interesting to explore the topic over here.

My EDC is an Al Warren Mini T: a wharncliffe trapper with stag handle -- 2.5" handle and 2" wharncliffe blade. It pretty much handles everything I need in an EDC knife.

Who carries a small traditional or fixed blade as their EDC? Pictures if you can.
 
I got the idea from a thread over in General called "Small Knife Carriers". With all the discussion of Peanuts, Lobster Knives and Sheffield Pen knives, I thought it would be interesting to explore the topic over here.

My EDC is an Al Warren Mini T: a wharncliffe trapper with stag handle -- 2.5" handle and 2" wharncliffe blade. It pretty much handles everything I need in an EDC knife.

Who carries a small traditional or fixed blade as their EDC? Pictures if you can.


I've always carried a nominal size knife, but in my later years my taste has run to smaller. Up untill middle age, my regular edc was a 3/12 scout knife or a 3 7/8th stockman. I had some 3 1/2 inch sodbusters I carried a lot. After about age 50 I started to carry more compact knives. Case peaunts, sak recruit, 3 1/4 size stockman like the Buck 303 cadet, pen knife size knives. I found that for most of what I did, I really didn't need much in the way of size. A 2 inch blade was plenty for me and my lifestyle. Slowly I found out what all those old guys I grew up around knew; a nice lightweight little knife in the pocket that is un-noticed till needed is a nice thing. Knives like peanuts, texas jacks, butterbeans, mini trappers, and a host of others will do 99% of what you have to do with a pocket knife. Maybe I'm suffering from a form of extreme pragmaticizim that comes with age, but I never did want to lug something around that was more than what I needed. I'm probably the only knife person in America who never owned a Buck 110. At the time they were selling like hot cakes, I went for the three blade stockman, which I still consider one of the best edc knives on the face of the planet. 3 or 4 or so onces of weight, three different blades to choose from. The smaller stockmen are near penknife size, but pack a very great deal of use in a very small package. Knives like Schrade's Old Timer and Uncle Henry small stockman or junior stockman as they called it, can go anywhere. Not a small thing in todays world.

Before 9-11, a lot of people thought they couldn't take a knife on an airplane. Actually, if it was a small penknife size, it went through security. I used to fly with a Vic classic on my keyring, and a sak tinker in my carry on bag. They looked very briefly at it, and let it pass. 9-11 changed all that of course. But here in Washington D.C. its very tight security.

My better half Karen, and I, go 'downtown' very often and in the museums like the Smithsonian, the National Gallery Of Art, and federal buildings, there seems to be a limit on cutlery. About 2 inches of blade seems to be the tilt mark. Sak classics, Buck cadets and companions, Case peanuts or similar size knives don't seem to get the uniforms upset. In fact, the only comment I've gotten on my knives was, at a government building one young guard looked at my red bone peanut and said his granddad carried one just like it. That's okay, I don't mind being associated with a grandad since I am one.


Yes, I like small knives. They'er lightweight, and take up very little room in the pocket. Of course, that means if you wish, you can carry more of them. My old Uncle Paul carried those little two blade jacks abut 3 inches in size. One in each front pocket and a spare one rolled up in his tobacco pouch. Not a bad idea to have a spare knife around.:D
 
I carry a Vic Classic on my Keyring, and a Buck Solo in my pocket. I have learned a lot in this thread, and thanks to Jackknife and his stories, have come to realize that you really DON'T need a big knife. We no longer live on the frontier. We are not pioneers, living off the land, toiling our land all day long. At least not the vast majority of us. We live in cities, suburbs. Hunting for food usually consists of us walking to our refrigerators, opening the door, finding said food, putting it in the microwave, and pushing a button. Our jobs have us more often then not working in office buildings. Some of us work construction jobs, or something similar, but for the most part, we are no longer in NEED of a large knife. We LIKE large knives, but most don't really need one. What we DO need, as knife lovers, is to be discreet. In this day and age of anti-knife legislation, we need to keep the sheeple from getting scared and instead EDUCATE them on the use of a small sharp implement to take care of our daily chores. I don't care how many of them say they don't need a knife, YES THEY DO!!! LOL. I see it all the time, people wrestling with those clam packages during Christmas, using keys or pens to open boxes or cut twine. A small knife like a Classic or a small slippie gets it done, scares no one, and is a TOOL, not a weapon.
 
Very well put, Jackknife and Voltron! I've learned much from you both (and others) over the past few months - either in direct posts or from reading older threads you have contributed to.

BTW, Carl, how's the hand? I know you were doped up last week, but your above post sounds like the old jackknife is back. I'm sure I'm not the only one wondering how you're doing!
 
BTW, Carl, how's the hand? I know you were doped up last week, but your above post sounds like the old jackknife is back. I'm sure I'm not the only one wondering how you're doing!

Hey, thanks for asking. I'm back about 75%. No more doing the vicoden, just dropping standard Ibuprophin nw for a bit of the throbing, or twinges I get. Plastic splint in gone, and still bandaged but less of a mummy wrap now. Flexing the fingers as per the doc's permission and as pain allows. It's actually harder to straiten them up all the way than bend. I can open my Victorinox bantam if I go carefull. Getting there!

I may miss those little white pills though, they were nice.:D
 
Hey, thanks for asking. I'm back about 75%. No more doing the vicoden, just dropping standard Ibuprophin nw for a bit of the throbing, or twinges I get. Plastic splint in gone, and still bandaged but less of a mummy wrap now. Flexing the fingers as per the doc's permission and as pain allows. It's actually harder to straiten them up all the way than bend. I can open my Victorinox bantam if I go carefull. Getting there!

I may miss those little white pills though, they were nice.:D

Ya, Jackknife the druggie is a scary thought - hope your son and daughter, being law enforcement people, will keep you in line!

But, back 75% in only a week is pretty good, I'd say!

Best wishes!
 
I carry a Vic Classic on my Keyring, and a Buck Solo in my pocket. I have learned a lot in this thread, and thanks to Jackknife and his stories, have come to realize that you really DON'T need a big knife. We no longer live on the frontier. We are not pioneers, living off the land, toiling our land all day long. At least not the vast majority of us. We live in cities, suburbs. Hunting for food usually consists of us walking to our refrigerators, opening the door, finding said food, putting it in the microwave, and pushing a button. Our jobs have us more often then not working in office buildings. Some of us work construction jobs, or something similar, but for the most part, we are no longer in NEED of a large knife. We LIKE large knives, but most don't really need one. What we DO need, as knife lovers, is to be discreet. In this day and age of anti-knife legislation, we need to keep the sheeple from getting scared and instead EDUCATE them on the use of a small sharp implement to take care of our daily chores. I don't care how many of them say they don't need a knife, YES THEY DO!!! LOL. I see it all the time, people wrestling with those clam packages during Christmas, using keys or pens to open boxes or cut twine. A small knife like a Classic or a small slippie gets it done, scares no one, and is a TOOL, not a weapon.


Great points made. :thumbup:

After WW2, a great migration took place in our society. Now most Americans live in or near an urban center, in suburbs. It's the new America, like it or not. People go where the jobs and money is, and thats the city. The surounding bedroom communities have taken over from the small towns that made up pre-war American society. Mayberry has been developed into townhome communities and outlaying industrial parks. With the change in lifestyle, comes the change in what we carry.

Ruling out deep wilderness survival issues, there is little that can't be done with a few inches of blade. A couple summers ago, my grandson Ryan and I did an experiment on how far through the summer we could get using only our yellow handle peanuts. Much to out pleasant surprise, we made it through the whole summer without using another knife. Camping, fishing, working downstairs in the woodshop I keep for making hiking staves and sticks for sale. Now there were a few times it may have been nice to have another inch or so reach of blade, like on food stuff. But we kept to the conditions of our experiment and used our heads to figure how to maximize the small knife.

Yes, we like the bigger knives, and I'm no exeception. Heck, I admit I used to go woods rambling with a Randall 14 as my go-to knife. But things change. Well one change that took place as I got older was I didn't want to lug around that much weight anymore. Okay, I really couldn't do it anymore. My backpack for trips on the A.T used be 40 to 50 pounds. I got that down to 35 to 40, then in my late 50's to 30 to 35 pounds. It's about making choices about what do you really need. Downsizing my steel tools like firearms and knives made a heck of a real difference I could feel on my old back.

And Voltron makes a good point about the public perception of us. In effect, we are ambasadores of the knife world to the public in general. Most of the public does not even carry a knife these days, so when a knife comes out it get attention. Weather that attention is good or bad can depend on us. A modest size traditional pocket knife seems to be very inoffesive to the sheeple at large. If anything, it seems to have a positive effect. The old timey appearence remindes them of a father or grandad in my case, and thats not a bad thing. People need to see knives in a positive light. Theres enough bad publicity out of Hollywierd without helping them. A modest size tradtional knife used responcibly can maybe over come somebodys feeling of the punk with a blade thing that a mall ninja flipping his knife of the month in public creates. Perception is a powerful thing, not to be underrated.
 
There are stringent size restrictions on pocket knives at work, so I have no choice but to carry a small knife.

The limits are:
- blade no longer than 2"
- overall opened length no greater than 4 1/2"

It's the overall length limit that is hard to meet and which I sometimes cheat on by a tad.

I have a Case Tiny Wharncliff trapper that is fully compliant to the limits.
I have a Camillus pen knife in 440A that is too long overall by 1/8", but which I carry anyway.
I always have a Vic Classic on my keyring, but the keys get in the way of using it effectively as a knife.

I find biggest problem I have with a small knife is having enough handle to hang onto so that I have full control of the blade. When I come home, I always switch to a larger knife.
 
Fortunately, I don't have a blade length restriction at work, but if I carry a small knife, it'll be my Schrade mini-Stockman (2.75" with a just under 2" main blade). I always carry a small FB, too, but it's not a "traditional" FB (A HAK with a 1.5" blade).

On a small slippie, it's not the blade length that's the issue, it's the small size & my lg. hands (XXL gloves). I do find myself using the smaller blade on my slippie quite a bit, but the larger handle is just more comfortable.
 
I enjoy my old timer 12OT I think, similar to a peanut. I also have just acquired a Case Bone peanut that will be in my pocket today. One of my favorite is my Case 6244. I am not sure if it is called a texas jack? It has squared bolsters, and a long slender clip blade that is easy to maintain at lazer sharpness.
 
Hey, thanks for asking. I'm back about 75%. No more doing the vicoden, just dropping standard Ibuprophin nw for a bit of the throbing, or twinges I get. Plastic splint in gone, and still bandaged but less of a mummy wrap now. Flexing the fingers as per the doc's permission and as pain allows. It's actually harder to straiten them up all the way than bend. I can open my Victorinox bantam if I go carefull. Getting there!

I may miss those little white pills though, they were nice.:D

Glad your doing beter JK.
This 3 3/8 stockman is the perfect size for me.

P1010029-2.jpg
 
99.9% of what i do, i do with my Buck 309 "Companion". 3" closed,2" main blade,5" open length. 99.9% of the time i use the smaller pen blade, keeping the main blade razor sharp for emergencies. This is the knife i ALWAYS carry. Frequently i have a Victorinox "Tinker" for back-up. Almost never use it, but i can't give up having a toothpick handy-----------and screwdrivers. I've carried the Buck since 1977, have an identical one in case something happens to this one.
 
I teach archaeology at the university, and run an archaeology lab and field school during the summer. I’ve found that a SAK and a Medium Stockman do everything that I need done. Well now that I think about it, the machete comes in handy every now and then;).
 
99.9% of what i do, i do with my Buck 309 "Companion". 3" closed,2" main blade,5" open length. 99.9% of the time i use the smaller pen blade, keeping the main blade razor sharp for emergencies. This is the knife i ALWAYS carry. Frequently i have a Victorinox "Tinker" for back-up. Almost never use it, but i can't give up having a toothpick handy-----------and screwdrivers. I've carried the Buck since 1977, have an identical one in case something happens to this one.

You've carried your Buck since 1977? As in thirty years ago 1977? Wow. How have the blades held up? I know Buck's 420HC is awesome at edge retention, and doesn't really need that much sharpening, but thirty years. That's crazy. I hope my Solo makes it that long. It's basically the imported, single blade version of the 309. Very cool.:thumbup:
 
99.9% of what i do, i do with my Buck 309 "Companion". 3" closed,2" main blade,5" open length. 99.9% of the time i use the smaller pen blade, keeping the main blade razor sharp for emergencies. This is the knife i ALWAYS carry. Frequently i have a Victorinox "Tinker" for back-up. Almost never use it, but i can't give up having a toothpick handy-----------and screwdrivers. I've carried the Buck since 1977, have an identical one in case something happens to this one.

Hey Henry, you don't hapen to know a guy named Wayne do ya?

He's been using a Buck companion for all the time I've known him, and he's loyal to the thing. Even went diving off a crab pier to retrive it from Davy Jones's locker when it fell off the rail. He's since retired it to give to his grandson and he got another 309 from his wife by hinting strongly close to his birthday. It was his wife that gave him the first companion for another birthday 20 somethng years earlier.

Wayne won't carry anything else but a 309.
 
I have been carrying just the little guys for almost a year now as EDC. I have an old Ka-Bar jack, Case SBJ and a Case Peanut that have taken 95% of the pocket time. I have a Vic Soldier and a Case "yeller" med stockman that snuck in the other 5% of the time. I simply boxed up the rest of the slippies that were on the top of the dresser and worked with those few. It just became habit and the SBJ has emerged as the regular EDC. I really enjoy carrying and using that knife.
 
Nine days out of 10 I have a Case peanut or Old Timer Middleman jack in my pocket. Other days, I carry a Victorinox Soldier or, if I'm feeling extra Rambo, I'll tote my yella Case trapper or maybe my locking Victorinox Adventurer.
 
I was carrying these around for a bit. They did the job.


100_0123.jpg

Oh man, every time you post those, I get a huge wave of nostalgia. They are sooo 50's! Ike was in the White House, Chevy's had tail fins, and Coke's cost a nickle and had real suger in them.

Time travel on a keychain.:D
 
I almost feel naked without my yellow-handle case peanut in my pocket. I almost always carry a bigger knife but its the peanut that does the work. I say try one for a week you'll be surprised buy the little knife that could.
 
Back
Top