Why a swedge or clip point with false edge, makes no sense??

If folks like the look have the best of both worlds and put a sharp edge on the false edge.

You maintain the same look and gain functionally - not even anyone can deny.
 
"the spear point is essentially for piercing... a swedge would enhance penetration...
however a sharpen swedge impedes batoning ... "
The above would be a sufficient enough explanation to most folks;
but the real reason behind the false edge is probably
a way of skirting legalities to enable commercial sale.
Alternatively, this edgeless swedge condition exist purely
as a result of some age old dark conspiracy
secretly agreed upon by manufacturers
which somehow winds up today
as some form of widely accepted manufacturing practice
which is now simply misconstrued by many
as some wise after thought of commercial decision
for survivalist to somehow baton with :)
Besides nobody has time for any additional form of sharpening
as it just takes all away the fun of actual use!
 
^ I think you are on to sumthin.

Also these survival types need to learn that wood splitting is best left to an axe or hatchet.......like every pioneer and frontiersman everywhere knew for centuries then viola man lands on the moon and every weekend warrior starts cutting down trees and splitting logs with knives.
 
Houlahound said:
^ I think you are on to sumthin.

Also these survival types need to learn that wood splitting is best left to an axe or hatchet.......like every pioneer and frontiersman everywhere knew for centuries then viola man lands on the moon and every weekend warrior starts cutting down trees and splitting logs with knives.
Click to expand...

This gave me a chuckle this am..:D Thanks for that!!!;)
John
 
Why a crowned spine?
Why jimping too smooth/shallow to have traction?
Why overly thick stock?
Why bearings when washers work just fine?
Why carbon fiber when g10?
Why coloured g10?
Why do Benchmade make $1200 cigar cutters instead of bringing out actual knives that are worth a dam?
Why?
Cos it's a hobby and variety.
And a touch of insanity...... Benchmade
 
Houlahound said:
If folks like the look have the best of both worlds and put a sharp edge on the false edge.

You maintain the same look and gain functionally - not even anyone can deny.
Click to expand...
Double edge can be illegal or impractical. And a LOT of this hobby is driven by aesthetics without practical applications. I love harpoon-style points and I have no earthly reason to use one, just dig 'em.

But, if properly done, a swedge can also give the end user the option of sharpening it up. I'm currently drooling over a Buck 212, so I'm in no place to criticize those who like a nice swedge. ;)
 
It lightens the blade, looks cool and thins down the point for better piercing while retaining some strength. Supposedly. Lol
 
Better for piercing stronger tip. Lightens the blade. Looks good. Biggest plus in my book. It leaves the option open to the end user to sharpen it or not.

No reason not to do it other than batoning.

Makes me wonder if it is a message from the manufacturer “Do Not Baton”. A froe is for batoning.
 
Insipid Moniker said:
Double edge can be illegal or impractical. And a LOT of this hobby is driven by aesthetics without practical applications.
Click to expand...
This reflects my thoughts. A sharpened swedge IS a double edged knife. The purpose is mostly piercing and the wound associated with that. A false edge is mostly for looks and allows for a sharper point. Example > clip blade. A bowie knife is essentially just a bigger clip style blade.

I doubt that batoning a knife was a big concern for outdoorsmen 100 or 200 years ago as they had a hatchet or axe. But I would be willing to bet that knives have been batoned for ages.
 
I agree with IM. A sharpened swedge can be considered double edge and that is illegal here in MI.
 
Swedges are one aspect I love on my knives. Especially traditionals. They look great and are functional. I’ve always liked needle point tips, and swedges do the trick. It allows for a thinner tip while keeping the blade stock the same, so it’s a win-win in my eyes.

GinWpiF.jpg


Did I mention they look great?
 
Houlahound said:
If folks like the look have the best of both worlds and put a sharp edge on the false edge.

You maintain the same look and gain functionally - not even anyone can deny.
Click to expand...
Are daggers legal where you live? They aren't here and we have fairly favorable knife laws. Something to consider.
 
In some applications that swedge or false edge also makes it easier to slip the tip under a tight fitting strap or narrow opening to cut or relieve pressure. On clip points I find it’s better for making more precise round hole cuts in various materials where as the flat top clip point makes more of a rough gouge. I like them.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top