Lovely to see tough knife nuts wax lyrical about the why and wherefore...
I do use knives everyday, they're elementary, that's a real motive. That the most elementary things can also be the most sophisticated is a quality that makes for fasincation and collectability - just look at the Japanese tradition.
The fascination, though, does seem to have sth to do with the quality that makes them such efficient objects, the flip side of which is saying, the danger. I remember as a kid being fascinated by the longest, sharpest and pointiest knives in the drawer. And still today, it's always great fun to play with the sharpness of a blade until I got another nick on my hands :thumbup:
I agree with all the anthropological background.
I don't buy the argument that it's never the weapon, only the intent. SUV drivers don't mean to be dangerous, but there's an awful toll. Atom bombs in whatever hands are dangerous, etc. Certain types of guns are far from being a tool, they're nothing but dangerous weapons, hence their availability, when proven to do awful harm and no good, is legitimately subject to restriction.
Knives, however, are something one can't do without. You can be killed with a kitchen knife, but we all need them. Pen and pocket knives, rescue and gardening knives, sailing and diving knives, and so general-purpose pocket knives, are needed as well, sth so useful in all kinds of daily activities, that while you can go without them much of the time, you can hardly do without them in general. Except in such "liberal" places as Britain
