Actually, they are reasonable users for the money. The problem with Windlass/Atlanta Cultery/Museum Replicas is their spotty quality control. They do have an excellent returns policy, which is a good thing given that spotty quality control. Also, they tend to cut corners in strange ways. For example, their Primitive Bowie is a pretty reasonable knife, but it comes with a sheath that is more in line with a $5 cheap POS knife at the corner gas-n-go mart. Another example is their "historical" costuming. They make it all out of cotton or cotton/polyester when the clothing of medieval Europe, at least in the more northern portions, was made of wool or linen. Of late, they are not telling you the material of which some of their costumes are made. I could go on, but it is mostly a waste of time.
Bottom line, if you buy from them, be prepared to return the item if there is anything wrong with it and be very picky about that.