Your Traditional Knife of the Year 2022 (Easy Tiger! Read the rules first! ;) )

For most of the year I thought this Buck 303 my wife gave me last Christmas would be my Knife of the Year. For me it’s the perfect medium stockman - smooth medium pull on all three blades, comfortable handles, very sharp out out of the box, and built like a tank.
bdLBeFA.jpg


Then along came this Case micarta small swell center jack. As solid as the Buck, comfortable handle, not much larger than a peanut but feels more substantial in the hand. I still carry others but I keep coming back to this one. (I don’t post it every time I carry it because I figure everybody would get really tired of seeing it.)
My 2022 Knife of the Year:
GkwYkHo.jpg
 
I always enjoy this thread, Jack. It has definitely become a Porch holiday tradition. 🙂

The thing I struggle with the most every year, and increasingly so the more years I’ve been here, is remembering when I actually acquired certain knives. 😁 Some knives (especially the stuff I got in January or February) sort of blend in with knives acquired last year, and I have to do a bit of research to verify what qualifies and what doesn’t.

I’ll start, as always, with a few honorable mentions.

I picked up this first knife on the exchange back in January, and of all the honorable mentions I’m about to list, this one probably came closest to actually being my KOTY. JTB_5 JTB_5 had this Tidioute #44 modified by Javi Garcia, and it’s just super cool. I love the two tone Micarta with the thin red spacer, and the slimness of this pattern as a single-blade shadow-pattern. I have carried it quite a bit this year (especially the first half of the year), but more recently its pocket time has been surpassed by another, which I’ll get to in a bit. So for that reason, it gets relegated to KOTY runner up.

jNb09W7.jpg


In March of this year, I got to travel to Janesville, WI for my first Badger Knife Show. H herder and I drove down together, and we met up with Harry Old Engineer Old Engineer and Jeff Amir Fleschwund Amir Fleschwund for breakfast before the show. There were thousands of traditional knives to look at and handle, and while I didn’t end up with any phenomenal vintage finds or needles in haystacks, I did pick up a couple knives I’d been looking to get for a while now: two carbon-steel Schrade USA 5OTs and a Victorinox Mauser (similar to the German Army Knife, but with an additional full-size clip-point blade). I sharpened up one of the 5OTs and have carried it and the Mauser several times throughout the year, but not enough to qualify for KOTY.

e8gRVzU.jpg


0r96Wqz.jpg


I picked up an extra Natural Canvas Micarta #71 Bull Nose this year that Sacto Sacto agreed to modify for me. While I love the Bull Nose as-is (I think I have about 10 of them), the more rounded edges of this knife, along with the sort-of-spearpoint blade make it a fun alternative that I enjoy carrying. Again, this one got plenty of pocket time, but you know the rules, there can only be one.

xOsw6Sf.jpg


I really like the #35 Camp & Tool knife GEC did this year, an interesting take on this pattern that I have used quite a bit since I got it. Close, but no cigar. (Get it?) 😉

ReYGWtv.jpg


My final honorable mention is a special knife. Jack Black Jack Black has these fantastic Damascus Lambsfoot SFOs made up a couple years ago, but at the time I couldn’t justify spending the money for one. Fast forward to this year, Jack sent my kids a package full of British sweets for Halloween, and included this surprise treat for me. I was blown away. Thanks again, Jack.

CPVtVgc.jpg


gcXU3DD.jpg


So why isn’t that my KOTY? Well, I've only had it since October, and while it had seen some pocket time, it hasn’t seen as much as another knife that also came my way courtesy of Jack Black Jack Black — this stag Hartshead Barlow.

qUM8LMw.jpg


I won this knife in Jack’s May Day Giveaway, and much like Jack’s own stag HHB, it has become a frequent companion since I got it. I can’t even say exactly what it is about it, but it’s a great companion, both alone or paired with second knife. (While I am a proud Guardian of the Lambsfoot, I do still like to have a blade with some belly, as well.) Thanks again, Jack, for this knife, and the other one, and for this annual thread, and everything else you do around here. :thumbsup::thumbsup:

w8sCquZ.jpg


LKmItui.jpg


2UZJEu8.jpg


f5HdXYb.jpg


tY5KT23.jpg
 
Easy choice for me, it is this GEC 530411 in stag. I have always been a fan of and collector of knives, but for the last several years have been pretty uninterested in picking up anything new. Earlier this year I found this 530411 and it rekindled my passion for traditional knives as well as knives in general.
View attachment 2019386

I have since acquired several other GEC knives that would be honorable mentions, but none of them match this one.

View attachment 2019391
View attachment 2019396

View attachment 2019398

I have really enjoyed carrying this one. Wharncliffe blades are a favorite of mine, and the stag on this one is beautiful to me. It is fun looking back through pictures from this year.

View attachment 2019399

View attachment 2019397

View attachment 2019395

View attachment 2019392

View attachment 2019394
 
I always enjoy this thread, Jack. It has definitely become a Porch holiday tradition. 🙂

The thing I struggle with the most every year, and increasingly so the more years I’ve been here, is remembering when I actually acquired certain knives. 😁 Some knives (especially the stuff I got in January or February) sort of blend in with knives acquired last year, and I have to do a bit of research to verify what qualifies and what doesn’t.

I’ll start, as always, with a few honorable mentions.

I picked up this first knife on the exchange back in January, and of all the honorable mentions I’m about to list, this one probably came closest to actually being my KOTY. JTB_5 JTB_5 had this Tidioute #44 modified by Javi Garcia, and it’s just super cool. I love the two tone Micarta with the thin red spacer, and the slimness of this pattern as a single-blade shadow-pattern. I have carried it quite a bit this year (especially the first half of the year), but more recently its pocket time has been surpassed by another, which I’ll get to in a bit. So for that reason, it gets relegated to KOTY runner up.

jNb09W7.jpg


In March of this year, I got to travel to Janesville, WI for my first Badger Knife Show. H herder and I drove down together, and we met up with Harry Old Engineer Old Engineer and Jeff Amir Fleschwund Amir Fleschwund for breakfast before the show. There were thousands of traditional knives to look at and handle, and while I didn’t end up with any phenomenal vintage finds or needles in haystacks, I did pick up a couple knives I’d been looking to get for a while now: two carbon-steel Schrade USA 5OTs and a Victorinox Mauser (similar to the German Army Knife, but with an additional full-size clip-point blade). I sharpened up one of the 5OTs and have carried it and the Mauser several times throughout the year, but not enough to qualify for KOTY.

e8gRVzU.jpg


0r96Wqz.jpg


I picked up an extra Natural Canvas Micarta #71 Bull Nose this year that Sacto Sacto agreed to modify for me. While I love the Bull Nose as-is (I think I have about 10 of them), the more rounded edges of this knife, along with the sort-of-spearpoint blade make it a fun alternative that I enjoy carrying. Again, this one got plenty of pocket time, but you know the rules, there can only be one.

xOsw6Sf.jpg


I really like the #35 Camp & Tool knife GEC did this year, an interesting take on this pattern that I have used quite a bit since I got it. Close, but no cigar. (Get it?) 😉

ReYGWtv.jpg


My final honorable mention is a special knife. Jack Black Jack Black has these fantastic Damascus Lambsfoot SFOs made up a couple years ago, but at the time I couldn’t justify spending the money for one. Fast forward to this year, Jack sent my kids a package full of British sweets for Halloween, and included this surprise treat for me. I was blown away. Thanks again, Jack.

CPVtVgc.jpg


gcXU3DD.jpg


So why isn’t that my KOTY? Well, I've only had it since October, and while it had seen some pocket time, it hasn’t seen as much as another knife that also came my way courtesy of Jack Black Jack Black — this stag Hartshead Barlow.

qUM8LMw.jpg


I won this knife in Jack’s May Day Giveaway, and much like Jack’s own stag HHB, it has become a frequent companion since I got it. I can’t even say exactly what it is about it, but it’s a great companion, both alone or paired with second knife. (While I am a proud Guardian of the Lambsfoot, I do still like to have a blade with some belly, as well.) Thanks again, Jack, for this knife, and the other one, and for this annual thread, and everything else you do around here. :thumbsup::thumbsup:

w8sCquZ.jpg


LKmItui.jpg


2UZJEu8.jpg


f5HdXYb.jpg


tY5KT23.jpg
Great post Barrett, I know what you mean about remembering when you acquired particular knives - I usually check the dates of my first pic! :D Your trip to the Badger Knife Show seems longer ago, as does my May Day Giveaway, I was thinking last year! :rolleyes: 🤣 I love all your pics, I think those Ironwood models were the best of that Damascus run :) I'm glad you're enjoying your Hartshead Barlow so much, I couldn't say what it is I love so much about mine either! :D Thanks for the kind words my friend :) :thumbsup:
Easy choice for me, it is this GEC 530411 in stag. I have always been a fan of and collector of knives, but for the last several years have been pretty uninterested in picking up anything new. Earlier this year I found this 530411 and it rekindled my passion for traditional knives as well as knives in general.
View attachment 2019386

I have since acquired several other GEC knives that would be honorable mentions, but none of them match this one.

View attachment 2019391
View attachment 2019396

View attachment 2019398

I have really enjoyed carrying this one. Wharncliffe blades are a favorite of mine, and the stag on this one is beautiful to me. It is fun looking back through pictures from this year.

View attachment 2019399

View attachment 2019397

View attachment 2019395

View attachment 2019392

View attachment 2019394
Great pics :cool: :thumbsup:
 
This would be a tough tough thought inducing decision that would take time to ponder and would likely end up with a lack of reply on my end as I wouldnt be able to make a decision IF time wasnt a factor. That said, I will toss my knife of the year out quickly and without much thought at all because this year I have had one knife that has taken my attention and pocket space up since I first bought it, took it apart and then completed the blade swap on it. Im usually not one for knives this large but now I cant put it down and cant stop finding ways in which to use it. Food prep to opening mail, cutting tags off the kids toys or shirts you name it. I often find myself (nothing new) holding it even when not in use...sort of a nervous tick sorta thing. This knife may not be deserving up against some that have been posted and will follow but personally...I can think of no other more worthy than my carbon blade swapped Rough Rider large work knife. It has made me a believer in the style and I look forward to a future with this knife in my pocket.

View attachment 2018109

This is a fun thread and I look forward to seeing what others have been captivated by enough to name it knife of their year!

Matt
For the first time I clicked love not for the knife but your sentiments, which is probaly high praise.
 
Hello friends,

Well, Jack Black Jack Black , you're right we have not to choose a favorite child ... but how to choose a favorite friend ? Impossible so I will play to your game being sure to loose because I will have to cheat 🤣

Of course the first his the one which is stuck on me for 4 years now :

Capture d’écran 2022-12-18 à 12.28.10.png
I never changed , I add one but I don't let it in the drawer. No need to write it the 20 reasons why ;)

The second is the fruit of an extraordinary bet which is always possible with the one to whom I proposed it. Asking to a great knife maker ( Rhidian Rhidian ) to realize an iconic knife. Of course it has been a success beyond my expectations:

52436948591_6d32cdb604_c.jpg


The third is my bridge over the Pond, a great lesson to those who try to make us believe that two countries which have 1000 years of common history can't be friends. Bull s... as could say Shakespeare 🤣

52080139418_34d786bca5_c.jpg


And as I'm a real European man, which means stretch between the four cardinal points, I can't forgot two great Italian friends :
Cosimo De Benedetto :

Capture d’écran 2022-12-18 à 12.44.18.png

And Clemente Esposito Amendola with his Mozzetta :

52401763928_b587ca2ae0_c.jpg



Oups ! I lost 🤣

Â
 
I collect more than I carry, I've had the same GEC 92 in my pocket every day since the last run.
It's been another great year for me adding vintage knives to the collection but this year was easy to pick just one. This large J. M. Schmid stag sheepsfoot jack easily stands out from all the others, combination of rarity and aesthetics will be hard to beat in the hunt for vintage knives next year.IMG_6660.jpegIMG_6666.jpegIMG_6668.jpegIMG_6677.jpeg
 
I have to say it’s been a long time since I have had a knife that is my knife of the year but I have to submit this case moose. Started out as a richlite red moose and J jsdistin recovered it in worm groove. It has been in my pocket almost everyday View attachment 2019879
That turned out really nice Al :) Nice range and cookware too ;) :) :thumbsup:
Hello friends,

Well, Jack Black Jack Black , you're right we have not to choose a favorite child ... but how to choose a favorite friend ? Impossible so I will play to your game being sure to loose because I will have to cheat 🤣

Of course the first his the one which is stuck on me for 4 years now :

View attachment 2019881
I never changed , I add one but I don't let it in the drawer. No need to write it the 20 reasons why ;)

The second is the fruit of an extraordinary bet which is always possible with the one to whom I proposed it. Asking to a great knife maker ( Rhidian Rhidian ) to realize an iconic knife. Of course it has been a success beyond my expectations:

52436948591_6d32cdb604_c.jpg


The third is my bridge over the Pond, a great lesson to those who try to make us believe that two countries which have 1000 years of common history can't be friends. Bull s... as could say Shakespeare 🤣

52080139418_34d786bca5_c.jpg


And as I'm a real European man, which means stretch between the four cardinal points, I can't forgot two great Italian friends :
Cosimo De Benedetto :

View attachment 2019882

And Clemente Esposito Amendola with his Mozzetta :

52401763928_b587ca2ae0_c.jpg



Oups ! I lost 🤣

Â
That's not cheating Jean-Marc, it just means that, like many of us, YOU DON'T HAVE A KNIFE OF THE YEAR! 🤣 You had some nice knives though :thumbsup:
I collect more than I carry, I've had the same GEC 92 in my pocket every day since the last run.
It's been another great year for me adding vintage knives to the collection but this year was easy to pick just one. This large J. M. Schmid stag sheepsfoot jack easily stands out from all the others, combination of rarity and aesthetics will be hard to beat in the hunt for vintage knives next year.View attachment 2019887View attachment 2019888View attachment 2019889View attachment 2019890
That is outstanding John :cool: :thumbsup:
 
I've slowed down quite a bit, but have bought a few nice knives this year. I really haven't been disappointed in any of them, but my favorite for the year would be this sowbelly stockman. It's a little more hefty than a medium stockman, yet it's still pocket friendly. It's shown here with the runner up, an ALOX Pioneer that I added this year.
i-RPXkTxk-X4.jpg
 
I've slowed down quite a bit, but have bought a few nice knives this year. I really haven't been disappointed in any of them, but my favorite for the year would be this sowbelly stockman. It's a little more hefty than a medium stockman, yet it's still pocket friendly. It's shown here with the runner up, an ALOX Pioneer that I added this year.
View attachment 2019952
Nice pattern :) :thumbsup:
 
These knives arrived in a package from Roland Proctor in Canada on 1-7-22. I had started out in mid-December to buy the two largest (93OT and 98OT) from Roland, but as he was trying to liquidate his collection he came back and offered me a couple more at a good deal, so I took all four (seen in the middle row of my picture below). Upon opening the package I saw Roland had thrown in a couple bonus knives, the tiny Lockback at the top (I never realized Schrade had offered an LB1) and an Uncle Henry penknife (804UH) shown at the bottom. I had wanted the two large knives to add to my EDC rotation, being a lover of the medium Stockman and any medium Jack knife on the same frame that offers a Clip main and a Sheepfoot secondary. The Wrangler had the perfect amount of blade scratching and wear so after touching up the edges and oiling the joints, right into the pocket it went, and went, and went, and went...........by June I knew I had my KOTY and have waited for this thread of Jack Blacks. So for me it is not difficult at all this year. The 93OT joined my other top two EDC knives and still hogged out 60 or so percent of the total pocket time of all my knives combined. My KOTY: Schrade+ USA 93OT. OH

Schrade_-_Ulster_haul_1-7-22.jpg

Schrade-93-OT-Wrangler-EDC-2.jpg
 
This was the year of the tear-drop pattern for me. I had an acrylic GEC 85 recovered in black ash, by David Valdivisio. This was the first time I’ve ever had tried more customized knives. I was totally stoked to see how this one turned out. I have carried this one a fair amount, but not nearly as much as the next one...
dVpUCZP.jpg


My favorite knife of the year award has to go to this Camillus I picked up from Augie Augie this summer. It is in great condition, but it does have enough wear on it that I have no problem letting it bang around in my pocket.
VMM92nU.jpg
 
Last edited:
I haven't had that many knife purchases this year, although I did pick up an excellent stag mini copperlock early in the year and a five-bladed mini trapper recently. But in keeping with the theme of this thread, the purchase from last August that I now carry all the time is my Buck 112 Slim Select (nail nick version).

52136705758_facdf0953b_b.jpg


52261741445_89e10ca887_b.jpg
 
My selection is fairly easy this year. In September I scooped up a burlap 47 and I was smitten from the word go. I was thankful to pick up an example that didn’t have messy gaps in the shield routing. I had picked up a stag version that was quite striking during the original release in ‘20, but I decided to let it go because I just wasn’t willing to carry the stag…too nice (eventually I’m gonna get over that 😂).

It came in kinda fuzzy and lackluster.
5F2446A1-5481-46CA-9927-8274383D824C.jpeg

I brought the burlap up to a high polish and man…it really became a knife I connected with.

BEA24EA9-E160-4226-BAB2-144CAA941EE2.jpeg

It fell in line with the usual suspects just fine.

D3184623-F156-4FCA-8ADD-EB3C3838138E.jpeg

It pairs up wonderfully with this Winchester stockman which was given to me by a kind porch friend in November. The black box stockman will no doubt get a ton of carry in ‘23. I parted ways with quite a many members of the collection this year, so it’s great to see what remains, and from that, what get’s top billing. The ‘47 has been my favorite add, and the most consistently carried of the year.

6C7FA212-49AD-49E6-88C6-4D1453C3D42D.jpeg

Thanks Jack for this great yearly tradition! I enjoy it!
 
That turned out really nice Al :) Nice range and cookware too ;) :) :thumbsup:

That's not cheating Jean-Marc, it just means that, like many of us, YOU DON'T HAVE A KNIFE OF THE YEAR! 🤣 You had some nice knives though :thumbsup:

That is outstanding John :cool: :thumbsup:
Thanks Jack the range is new my wife’s choice the cast iron is my choice seeing how my adult children wanted my other cast iron I believe they wanted it because it was well seasoned but that is fine I like building a seasoning on cast iron
 
Thanks Jack the range is new my wife’s choice the cast iron is my choice seeing how my adult children wanted my other cast iron I believe they wanted it because it was well seasoned but that is fine I like building a seasoning on cast iron
I think you both have great taste Al :) :thumbsup:
 
Back
Top