P, You always show impeccable taste in knives.
Aw, thanks.
Thanks, the whittler in ebony looked so much like the old engravings in catalogs from a hundred years ago, it just seemed right.
With that, I agree. Clutchcarter continues to post images of his that are giving me fits.
Nice choice, Sarah! That white ivory bone ages so nicely.
That smooth ivory bone will age to look something like this bone, which is a few years old.
I think it's beauty will continually proceed, as opposed to people's looks.
Good choice Sarah.
Thanks, guys. I refrained from opting for white bone once before, and have regretted it ever since. I'd prefer not to feel that way again.
However, I admit to wavering when I saw others' images of the other fine choices, the antique yellow bone especially (it just looks so
right for this pattern). Now having the white bone in hand, I am glad I went with my initial and lasting instinct.
(I fear I am repeating myself with the above, but the software currently won't let me search this thread to find out. Gah.)
Here's mine in today's lighting, revealing more of the color and variegation already present:
The pile side is especially sweet (isn't it funny how often that's the case?):
Very nice Schrade P. Its funny I went through the very same thought process as you... Down the the very same knife replacement. I shuffled my feet too long on those peach seed American Whittlers and wound up picking up this Schrade Mechanics Knife (dealer told me that's what Schrade called their 804s).

For what it's worth it's an inimitable tank of a knife which covers all the bases. It's been getting much pocket knife this weekend.
Ha-- I just asked you about your knife in the 'carrying today' thread! So it
is an 804. I love its super-smooth steel (a joy to hone). You're right about its being a tank-- which makes me wonder all the more about a direct comparison with a #38 whittler.
Of course, I now also want to see #38
Jacks, as well. The frame is so comfortable, and I believe it will prove well-suited to a variety of blade configurations.
Although I'm fine as-is,
* with this Farmer's Jack insisting on coming along every day. I honestly didn't expect that to happen!
~ P.
* For now.