Hey Sarah,
Thanks for the comparison pics of the Bearcub with the Bushnubs! Aesthetically I just don't like the end of the blade on the Kephart and it goes for the Bearcub as well. This of course has nothing to do with the knife, the maker, others' appreciation for them. In fact, I'm probably the one losing out because it looks like it would do well with drilling and sharp turn-in cutting.
I was bracing to do without my Bear Cub for a time, sending it back with your knives so you could compare it in person with your own known quantities, but it looks like I've been spared.

I'm the same way: if I don't care for the aesthetics of a given pattern, I'm going to keep moving, no matter what other merits the knife might possess. Shallow waters, perhaps, but life's too short (and the choices too grand) to exert energy
trying to like something.
I broke away from Shadetree with the Bear Cub (gasp), and it has no blue on it save for Robert's string (another gasp), but boy howdy do I love the knife. The contours and finish of the wood make me want to just keep holding and using it; a righteous handful. In fact, I had it out for a 'compare' with some [of your] patterns, addressing a block of basswood, and ended up just happily cutting with the Bear Cub the whole time. I didn't want to put it down. Still don't!
My only regret is that I cannot comfortably carry it at work. I mean, I can carry it
comfortably thanks to my R. Lowe crossdraw sheath, but it's a little too big for my regular contexts, and I don't want to raise any eyebrows, flags, or objections that result in a Rule that puts kiboshes on carrying even my smaller fixed blades.
[Thinks of ways to reconfigure job and life so she can carry the Bear Cub allthetime.]
Out of curiosity, where/how does the Gaucho work for you? It shares a similar pointiness to the Bear Cub, if with more belly...?
I'm also curious to hear how you chose the Bushnubs (original and II) from the number of 'bush-' knives available, and especially over against the Bushcraft, Jr.? Me, I'd go for full Bushfinger over all of them. So far.
The Batman video had me totally cracking up yesterday when I got to watch it and I don't know how he wasn't cussing up a storm. I know there's the aspect of your wanting to get through these and review, compare, use and photograph them as quickly as possible but please don't feel rushed.
... Thanks. I
have been feeling pushed. I'll be relieved once all your knives are safely back with you, but have so been enjoying this opportunity, and looking forward to more time, and it's fascinating what's come up to thwart me near and far, home and at work.
So, bite-sized pieces as I peck away at this. Everyone's comments and questions help me focus.
btw, I just received a few new Osprey K/T knives yesterday. Two of them (an Apache and a Mamushi) have carbon fiber handles which helps with the weight and still keeps the grip, just like the Raptor you have there. They are both K variants and even more appealing to me than the non-K variants. Sorry but I'm not going to be sending these to you for comparison since I don't want to put them down
I totally identify with that feeling! Chris's knives are extraordinary, if not my cup of tea in the long run. He's accomplished something with one of them in particular that I look forward to highlighting.
~~~~~~~
Onward: Jerry's supplemental batch o' knives contained another Handyman, a 1/8" TT model in Ruby Burlap to compare directly with the 3/32" SFT Sweet Gum version I already had here.
I like the Ruby one so much better, it's amazing; the two knives are so similar in size and dimension, the difference-maker has to be the Tapered Tang. Uh, right?
Similar size, relative thickness, and contours:
3/32" SFT
1/8" TT
Even though the handles are so similar, the blue knife feels so much rounder and non-balanced (not unbalanced, just no discernible weightedness) than the red, which possesses balance both unobtrusive and becoming. The blue SFT version feels over-handled in comparison, in a way that I wouldn't not have guessed simply by looking at the knives together.
I am now wondering: if given a choice between two knives of the same pattern, one 1/8" TT and the other 3/32" or 1/8" SFT, how many of you prefer a SFT knife, and why? I'm loving the TT knives I'm handling, Jerry's and now the Bear Cub, to the point that I'm going to be looking for it specifically from here on out, save for the small knives which 3/32" SFT suits just fine.
Back to the Bear Cub (best get used to it!): as compelling an argument as the Ruby Handyman makes for the pattern, in size, handle comfort, and balance, the pattern as a whole still registers as "Fine" vs. "Oh Baby Baby," the latter of which is an increasingly guiding metric for me, and which the Bear Cub evokes in spades.
My first round of Compare, I was especially cognizant of the ends of the knife handles and how they interacted with my persnickety pinky. I'm still mindful of that, but for this latest bout I've found myself honing in more on the area where the blades meet the handles, how my thumb and forefinger are oriented relative to one another when gripping the knives, and if there are any build similarities that I can key off of in considering future knives from afar.
Bear Cub, Handyman
The area of interest:
A clearer view of difference in handle contours:
(I've come to appreciate this last comparative shot very much, which is why I pictured the Bushnubs with the Bear Cub the same way. Having the handles' lower contours aligned like this, I can more clearly see the differences by noting the symmetry of the shape created between the handles, or lack of thereof-- than when the knives are lined up over one another).
More soon.
~ P.