ABS Forum???

Anthony,

I want to read stories about and by the makers that I collect. Cutting contests, hammer-ins, knife shows, and famous pieces that they have produced.

That sounds like something for the Custom forum. Now all we need to do is get those makers to post here...:D

-Jose
 
Darby,

Listen, (my opinion only), it would grow a forum,(COLLECTORS AS WELL AS MAKERS!) if like one day a week, the MAKERS could post a knife with specs...NO PRICES!!!!!!!!!!!! and NO FEED BACK or post from another member) with contact information only. HUMAN NATURE, the makers would participate more and the collectors would too!

I agree with this statement. Our only disagreement seems to be that you feel a new forum is needed and I think the Custom Forum can cover these issues. All that's missing is the makers posts.

-Jose
 
a better solution is to remove the artificial restrictions against "commercial" posts by makers and let collectors/buyers post pics of their new treasures....

makers have been driven away by the counterproductive restrictions....if you make the bf.com custom forum a comfortable place you will see more makers and buyers posting here

and then you will have a fun and informative forum once again :)
 
Originally posted by bandaidman
a better solution is to remove the artificial restrictions against "commercial" posts by makers and let collectors/buyers post pics of their new treasures....

I agree with that. Personally, as a collector, I see "commercial" posts as a + thing rather than detrimental. I don't see how having a guy like Dave Ellis coming & showing us his ware would be detrimental to the quality of the custom knife forum.

JD
 
Originally posted by bandaidman

makers have been driven away by the counterproductive restrictions....if you make the bf.com custom forum a comfortable place you will see more makers and buyers posting here


Makers (and collectors) are driven away by the constant posting of drivel by people only interested in the number of posts they can tally up.


Regards,

Pat
 
Jerry,I agree with you and it would leave me out also as I am in a whole new learning curve at the moment and a beginner has been teaching me the new tech's that I am needing and I am teching him what I know to help him along..
I just figured that saying it was advanced might help people want to get into it...

:grumpy:
I am going to go out on a limb and say what I think..People may get mad at me or not..

I have been on the forums for close to 3 years now or something like that.When I first started posting I was hesatant to as I figured I didn't know enough to add anything.But I did start posting when I could and found that the more people that would post there ideas could really help others out.Now at that time we had makers and collecters that bounced between custom and shop talk.Some people only had time to visit one forum a day and so didn't go to both.Now when we would post a picture of our latest creation we had both other makers and Collecters giving feed back,and most of the time someone would say hey those guys over at ..the other forum would love to see that,you need to post this there also so we would and get even more feed back.Most of the time as a maker when I post a picture the knife is already sold but you still want to show it off.Well we started having som,e people start fussing that we were posting our pictures in all the forums and they didn't want to see that,even thgough we were asked to ,they didn't care about that and just wanted to fuss.
You know they didn't have to click on it on all postings if they didn't like it.We had that trouble in shop talk when Tom and Jerry always started cut up posts that would make a bad day go away,what happened to them a new forum on a different set of forums completely..Thus a loss of people here..
Then the rules of no pictures on the other forum if you already posted it on one,so use makers had to decide who we wanted to show it to..Not that I don't think we should pay for the forums but when that happened we lost a bunch of people,then when 9-11 hit allot of people disapeared from the forums for any number of reasons..The new restrictions on how you could post a picture and were,plus the wording you use has to make it not sound like a add.Heck we don't have any trouble in shop talk and we can help each other out and when a flare up starts we all stop i ourselves most of the time,How many moved or locked threads do you see in shop talk.When someone askes a question about making in the forum they chose to go to it always gets moved,when a few years ago it just got answered there and someone would usually post a link to it in one of the other forums to direct help to that person....If a collecter wanted to ask how or why they got the same treatment as if they were also a maker,thus they were educated as well as the rest of us.
I wish we could have the forums back the way they were a couple of years ago when they were fun and more interacting between everybody went on.Instead a few jerks have caused rules to stop this,I understand the economy hit Spark hard on the cost of the forums as he lost advertising But don't forget us makers that have been hit hard by the economy also,I know more than one maker that went back to work full time because of it,I went months at a time without orders also,It has hit us all hard but that shouldn't meen that we have to stop posting in different places does it? Me I had to drop my Knifemakers subscription as it was a bill that wasn't justified at the time,food and house hold bills were more important at the time,plus I was just posting a quick pic and not keeping my website updated and there I could show and sell if I wanted and it was paid for,If all I could do was show a maker my knife and not collecters that could possiably become a customer it wasn't worth it anymore either.Even though we have a paid subscription we can't post in any other part of the forum than we can being non-paid with the exception of the for sale forum..Were I used to post and to tell you guys the truth in 2 years there I never sold a knife,it would always be a collecter off a different part of the forums that would see it and email to see if it was available,Nobody really visited the Gallery as they still don't,when you post a picture there you don't get the feed back that you can like in shop talk.
So to me what you guys are wanting is what we had 2 years ago before all the BULLSHIT started and the bickering..Just open the forums back up like they were so the makers and collecters can interact btween each other no matter what forum it is on,I agree that a purveyor or factory or anyone being a assmbly line type of maker should buy advertising and not use the forums for a free be on Spark.But when you sell all you make why should we be punished from showing off what we finished at the end of a hard week to who ever wants to see it or asks to see for fear that we will be kicked off the forums completely because we advertised ina post by giving a price or posting in a different forum like we used to..

Come on guys,we want the old forums back but we won't get them without everybody getting along,will we get the old collecters and makers back maybe/maybe not.But we can make them fun again and get new blood in without fear of getting into trouble...

Now I said my piece and I am sorry if I mad anyone mad,but this is just how I have felt about this for a long time and I bet I aint the only one:footinmou :footinmou :footinmou
Bruce
 
Bruce

Point well taken.
It's Sparks ball park, If he wants the old posters back to play ball, then he can do it. If not, it's still his ball park.

Let me know how it turns out, I have knives to make.
:) :) :)
 
Just to keep people updated as I promised; there is a great deal of interest on the part of the ABS in having a forum here.

By the way guys, it is not up to Darby to change the custom forum back to the way it was when posting pictures was not looked upon as a bad thing. It was not Gus and Blues that brought in the rules against the picture posting. It was done by Spark, and if I am not mistaken it was done at the bidding of some makers that were unhappy that they paid for a membership and that those that didn't were allowed to advertise their knives by showing pictures of them in the custom knife forum. It will not be Darby or nifrand that change things back; it will be Spark that has to make this decision.
 
Thanks for the update Keith - I look forward to hearing more. I had certainly hoped that there would be interest on the part of the ABS and its membership in having such a forum.

Cheers,

Roger
 
Originally posted by pff
Makers (and collectors) are driven away by the constant posting of drivel by people only interested in the number of posts they can tally up.


Regards,

Pat

well pat...if one is going to participate in online forums one will have to put up with "drivel" to some extent.... the other option is a little password protected club.

i find the vast majority of what is posted on all forums to be bs, irrelevent or just plain silly....that does not matter though...i read these forums for fun.

as a bonus i do learn something new once in a while...i have come in contact with several makers that i have become repeat customers of...and friends with.


keith...i am well aware of why the changes were made and who made them...the same thing occurs now in the "gallery" so the only real difference is that the custom forum has become rather moribund and many makers no longer post there

i am not opposed to the ABS having a forum like the AKTI here but i fear an exclusive "forged" knife forum as conceived here will promote a degree of divisiveness... you can already detect hints of it as
there seems to be an undercurrent of elitism present among certain collectors and makers of forged blades (the relative merits of that can be discussed ad nauseum) ... and that rubs some people the wrong way

AND if it run with the same restrictions that the custom forum labors under and is not a "shop talk"...i dont see it being really that interesting.

however, if all "custom forums" here were less restrictive on posting content..that would be great!!! and worth supporting
 
Originally posted by Keith Montgomery
By the way guys, it is not up to Darby to change the custom forum back to the way it was when posting pictures was not looked upon as a bad thing.

So just make this ABS forum where the rules don't apply for ABS/Forgers and phuck everybody else?
 
Sam,
I dont think that has ever been discussed.

BUT,

Since a Gold membership or Custom maker membership is the ONLY way you could post pictures, it therefore makes sense that Custom makers who have paid their MEMBERSHIP fee should be able to post pictures wherever they like.

Posting was prohibited on the custom forum before the custom maker category was changed and the priced lowered.

Maybe that can change?

Until then, a Bladesmith forum will just simply have to link to Gallery pics. No big deal.
 
Originally posted by Keith Montgomery
Just to keep people updated as I promised; there is a great deal of interest on the part of the ABS in having a forum here.

By the way guys, it is not up to Darby to change the custom forum back to the way it was when posting pictures was not looked upon as a bad thing. It was not Gus and Blues that brought in the rules against the picture posting. It was done by Spark, and if I am not mistaken it was done at the bidding of some makers that were unhappy that they paid for a membership and that those that didn't were allowed to advertise their knives by showing pictures of them in the custom knife forum. It will not be Darby or nifrand that change things back; it will be Spark that has to make this decision.

While I'm sure that is all true, setting up a defacto 'old Custom' forum and calling it the ABS, Guild, Tactical, Stock Removal, or whatever-your-flavor forum is still circumventing the problem.
How much support would you guys be giving this proposal if it was for Tactical knives, to the exclusion of all others? Be honest with yourselves.
I'm all for the ABS, attracting new makers and collectors, and bringing back the dialog, but how can you miss the irony? Why not plea to fix the Custom forum and parse it into subforums, if necessary. Then you wouldn't have to deal with types of knives you aren't interested in.
In the big scheme of things I really don't care as long as the divisiveness doesn't extend to Shop Talk. I just hoped some could see the forest for the trees.
 
Brett, to honestly answer your question; I wouldn't have any problem at all with the tactical knife guys getting their own forum. Tactical knives don't interest me personally, so I wouldn't take part, but I can see no problem with those that love these kinds of knives having their own forum. I don't have a problem with the balisong forum, the knife throwing forum, the sword forum, the axe, tomahawk and hatchet forum, the traditional folders and fixed blade forum, or any of the other exclusive forums that we have, including this one. I just want one that focuses on the knives that I have the most interest in; so shot me (I know, some of you would be only too happy to take me up on that).
 
Originally posted by Brett Bennett
While I'm sure that is all true, setting up a defacto 'old Custom' forum and calling it the ABS, Guild, Tactical, Stock Removal, or whatever-your-flavor forum is still circumventing the problem.
How much support would you guys be giving this proposal if it was for Tactical knives, to the exclusion of all others? Be honest with yourselves.
I'm all for the ABS, attracting new makers and collectors, and bringing back the dialog, but how can you miss the irony? Why not plea to fix the Custom forum and parse it into subforums, if necessary. Then you wouldn't have to deal with types of knives you aren't interested in.
In the big scheme of things I really don't care as long as the divisiveness doesn't extend to Shop Talk. I just hoped some could see the forest for the trees.

Pretty hard for some to see reason Brett. The raging fire of the crusade blinds them to rationality.:(
 
Originally posted by Keith Montgomery
Brett, to honestly answer your question; I wouldn't have any problem at all with the tactical knife guys getting their own forum. Tactical knives don't interest me personally, so I wouldn't take part, but I can see no problem with those that love these kinds of knives having their own forum. I don't have a problem with the balisong forum, the knife throwing forum, the sword forum, the axe, tomahawk and hatchet forum, the traditional folders and fixed blade forum, or any of the other exclusive forums that we have, including this one. I just want one that focuses on the knives that I have the most interest in; so shot me (I know, some of you would be only too happy to take me up on that).

Keith,

I don't want to shoot you, or anyone else for that matter, if it's any consolation. ;)
We are still comparing apples to oranges a bit here. While I admit I frequent the forums you mentioned very little, I don't recall much maker to collector interaction. It has been mentioned several times in this thread that those in favor of this proposal specifically want that type of dialogue. Additionally, those forums predominantly serve the interest of non-custom knives. The point I'm making is that if we were to establish an ABS forum (100% custom dependent on your favorite definition ;) ), it would fulfill a portion of the Custom forum's role and those who didn't participate would be left with the Custom forum. We know what that means. I suppose we could establish a Custom Tactical knife forum, Stock Removal forum, or whatever else for those who were left out, but we would really just be ignoring the problem many of us see with the Custom forum.
As I mentioned earlier, I wouldn't mind this forum being parsed into subforums.
Keith, you are the only proponent that has commented on this disparity in an earlier post. I would enjoy the thoughts of the other proponents on this matter.
 
Originally posted by Darby

I know, this isn't a Church! BUT, WHAT IS THE CONCERN ABOUT A NEW FORUM????????? If Spark, THE OWNER, doesn't like the way a new forum is going... HE can turn the switch back! HELLO! What I'm saying is...HERE, SPARK HAS POWER! PERIOD, NOT YOU, NOT ME! Be honest, what is the REAL FEAR here? Could it be POw...?;)


It's true this is Spark's forum and he is free to do anything he wants. It really has nothing to do with my argument.
Regarding the power issue, I'm afraid I have to disagree. The issue is one of 'special interest'. As it is with with society, when you give something to a certain group, it is done at the expense of everyone else. Pretty soon, another group presents its plea for special treatment. On and on it goes, and the result is divisiveness and a small group of unafiliated individuals paying the price so everyone else can reap the benefits. That is the issue. Not the ABS, forgers, tactical makers, or stock removalist. It is that one group is allowed to participate and the others are not. Of course, the new forum could abide the rules of the Custom forum, but I expect the results would be abysmal.
 
WOW!~Look at all the posts!


Spark! I am really sorry for all the wasted bandwith.


Your humble servant.............
 
Brett, I hope you don't mind me commenting again, but I just wanted to let you know that I think what you suggesting is a very good idea. I am not sure of the viability of adding sub-forums to the Custom Knife Forum, but if it is something that Spark would do then I think it would work out very well. It would also be a good way to breath life back into this forum.

Mike, if it appears that I am on a crusade it is because I believe that this would be a good thing for BladeForums. You obviously disagree and I respect that. If something can be worked out to everyones satisfaction, that would definitely be the best result.

Anthony, in my opinion this is not wasted bandwidth.
 
Back
Top