Are Spyderco Prices becoming unreachable?

I agree with you that *IF* you use your knives hard, and for long durations that ergonomics become much more important. That said, I'd bet the vast majority of even knife enthusiasts here, are not using their pocket knife for any significant amount of time per day much less a significant amount of time doing consecutive hard cutting. I'd also be willing to bet that if people had to use many of the popular folding knives we see here for hours a day for constant cutting, they'd quickly start wearing gloves, or they'd be looking for a new knife with a better handle for long term hard use. Ergonomics are part of function of a knife as a whole, I just believe that for the vast majority of knife owners, they aren't using their knife enough to even know if their knife handle is ergonomic in the first place, so at that point a blade that holds an edge longer is more important for their use case.

Let's say I use my folding knife for actual cutting 30 minutes a day on average (I'd be that's even WAY too high for 90% of people with a knife in their pocket. Most probably don't average 5 minutes, a lot of guys I know with a pocket knife don't even use it every day for anything. Not only that but it's probably not consecutive cutting time through hard to cut things. Meaning the possibility for developing hot spots, blisters, etc. from a knife with poor ergonomics never has enough time to happen in the first place. Now of course there are limits, no one wants an uncomfortable handle, one with splinters, razor sharp machined edges that were not properly finished etc. but most folding knives don't have those issues.

I'd even go a step further that if you do really use your knives hard and for long durations, folding knives in themselves are a poor choice for handle ergonomics. A fixed blade handle is going to be much more comfortable because there's no gaps, buttons, and by their nature folding knives tend to have sharper handle angles. All bad things for ergonomics.
 
I agree with you that *IF* you use your knives hard, and for long durations that ergonomics become much more important. That said, I'd bet the vast majority of even knife enthusiasts here, are not using their pocket knife for any significant amount of time per day much less a significant amount of time doing consecutive hard cutting. I'd also be willing to bet that if people had to use many of the popular folding knives we see here for hours a day for constant cutting, they'd quickly start wearing gloves, or they'd be looking for a new knife with a better handle for long term hard use. Ergonomics are part of function of a knife as a whole, I just believe that for the vast majority of knife owners, they aren't using their knife enough to even know if their knife handle is ergonomic in the first place, so at that point a blade that holds an edge longer is more important for their use case.

Let's say I use my folding knife for actual cutting 30 minutes a day on average (I'd be that's even WAY too high for 90% of people with a knife in their pocket. Most probably don't average 5 minutes, a lot of guys I know with a pocket knife don't even use it every day for anything. Not only that but it's probably not consecutive cutting time through hard to cut things. Meaning the possibility for developing hot spots, blisters, etc. from a knife with poor ergonomics never has enough time to happen in the first place. Now of course there are limits, no one wants an uncomfortable handle, one with splinters, razor sharp machined edges that were not properly finished etc. but most folding knives don't have those issues.

I'd even go a step further that if you do really use your knives hard and for long durations, folding knives in themselves are a poor choice for handle ergonomics. A fixed blade handle is going to be much more comfortable because there's no gaps, buttons, and by their nature folding knives tend to have sharper handle angles. All bad things for ergonomics.
I think most people would agree - it’s common sense that for a constant use knife ergonomics trump all else, as long as it can also cut. My son’s work knife is a very ergonomic DeWalt utility knife. He has loads of pocket knives that he’d use if he wanted to wreck the blades, but they’re almost all ergonomic (Benchmade Shootout, Griptilian).
 
I am not quite sure what the debating (and a bit derailing) is about but here is my two cents. Ergonomics of knives (folders included) is really not that difficult to achieve. As long as no sharp handle edges/spots and not too short/slim/slippery a handle, that should usually all be good. So let's not mystify knife ergonomics. Spyderco Manix 2, Military, Benchmade Bugout, Griptian, Hinderer XM-18, Eklipse, Cold Steel Recon 1, Chris Reeve Sebenza, etc etc all feel good in my hand so to me they all have great ergo. It's not that Spyderco is the only company making knives of good ergonomics. Many other companies do too, and they do it equally well if not better. It is a weak argument to justify the price jump by their knife ergonomics. The same is true for materials used though I do applaud Spyderco for making knives of so many different steels.
 
They just gave me a free Spidiechef so they're gonna have to bump those numbers up a little more.
 
Back
Top