In my opinion the criticism of Benchmade's quality control is greatly overstated. As with any critique, a very vocal minority can shout their negative opinion far loudly that the satisfied contentment of the majority. I'm a little baffled about the Benchmade hate because the QC critics seem to almost take it personal or have an agenda. That could certainly be a matter of perception on my part. One thing is for certain: if anyone ever makes an absolute statement (
X always has terrible Y ), you can be certain that statement is always wrong some of the time.
The fact of the matter is Benchmade's "out the door QC" probably lags behind their peer rivals: Spyderco and KAI. I'd rate them, from best to worse as Spyderco, KAI and Benchmade.
In the matter of service and support the ranking flips. I see it as Benchmade, KAI and Spyderco.
Mind you, none of these brands are deserving of condemnation as the differences are mild and well within the realm of expectations. Each wins in some areas and loses out in others. It's normal. They're all great brands.
Bluntly: Benchmade hatred is an inflated internet meme and their knives can be bought with confidence.
In terms of my suggestion for "best" Benchmade under $200, I'd have to go with the G10/20CV Grip. Choose either full-sized or mini, hole or thumbstuds and you'll have a terrific knife. If for some reason the Grip just doesn't do it for you, look at the 940/943 series.
