best survival knife?!

100_4008.jpg

My test was slicing paper ofter being shoved thru the bonnet of the car ... I figure it would show any rough spots on the cutting edge from the exersize
100_4010.jpg


not playing silly buggars either , Its not a big deal to grind out a knife able to do that easily
knifeduntest.jpg


knifedunpass.jpg



If I want to brag about how tough my knives are , Im going to have to go lay out some $$ on a brand name one I guess ... who would be impressed by a knife with thats back yard made ?
:)

I might be interested in one of your knives if the price was right.:) There is something about a rough looking knife that I simply can't resist.:D
 
I appreciate the interest :) , but at the moment , I dont do knives for $$ ...

I dont actually have any I made left either .. they all find homes real quick .
 
While in the woods, my personal choice for a "survival knife" would be a Sissi (Ranger) Puukko, with a mag bar attached to the sheath. It's big enough to double as a hatchet, strong enough to baton with, and even though it is a bit bigger than I would prefer, it's still small enough to be handy for all the smaller tasks also.

I'd prefer, however, a 4" blade puukko and a small axe; thats what I usually carry anyhow.

In an urban environment, my knife-of-choice is the Leatherman Charge TTI.
 
The last two posts that mentioned an Urban Survival setting got me thinking: just what requirements would an "Urban Survival Knife" have to fulfill??? I almost always have a Leatherman or an SAK on me while in town and they are extremely handy, but have I ever needed them to survive?

Has anyone here really been in an Urban Survival situation??? Urban and Survival almost seem to contradict each other. In town there's plenty of food, water, shelter, and easy navigation, what's to survive???

The only two Urban Survival situations I can think of are a SHTF scenario, i.e. Katrina, or a homicidal wierdo who want my wallet (and/or my kidneys). In either case Urban Survial seems like it would boil down to the problem of two-legged predators...? What else would an Urban Survival knife have to deal with???
 
car smash , either getting out before it goes up in flames ( assuming no spinal injury ) or getting the guy inside out before his wreck goes up in .

Opening cans , doing screwdriver and coldchisel duty opening windows , maybe lifting door hinge pins out too .

opening packets and slicing food up , skining duty on city dwelling game as pigeons

maybe prybar duty on windows and doors ...

last desperate line of defense against predators , including two and four legged vicious animals

just my ideas ....
 
The last two posts that mentioned an Urban Survival setting got me thinking: just what requirements would an "Urban Survival Knife" have to fulfill??? I almost always have a Leatherman or an SAK on me while in town and they are extremely handy, but have I ever needed them to survive?

Has anyone here really been in an Urban Survival situation??? Urban and Survival almost seem to contradict each other. In town there's plenty of food, water, shelter, and easy navigation, what's to survive???

The only two Urban Survival situations I can think of are a SHTF scenario, i.e. Katrina, or a homicidal wierdo who want my wallet (and/or my kidneys). In either case Urban Survial seems like it would boil down to the problem of two-legged predators...? What else would an Urban Survival knife have to deal with???

I have a little story that I have posted in another thread, so I'll just cut and paste it here since it seems to be about the same thing seeing as how we're all wondering about urban survival situations.

I have a small story to tell that happened to me about 2 years ago at a gas station. First off, stupid me wanted to air up my tires after coming back from fishing at 2:00 in the morning. I had my drivers side door open and I was hunched inside my car looking for quarters when these two cars full of guys, that obviously looked like they were up to no good, pulled in and parked around the backside (which was facing where I was at). They had parked around back and were trying to get inside of the restroom right away. Well, from inside of my car I'm watching them with me still hunched in and my door still open when one of the guys starts walking towards the backside of my car. He was walking very fast (like trying to make some ground before I could see him ) and when he was finally close enough to the backside of my car I stood up and immediately reached for my right side pocket. I didn't draw my knife, but he looked at me a little differently. Then slowly made his way to the car wash which had a side door and tried to play it off that he was looking for the restroom. I looked at his hands and he had blood all over them, still having my hand at my side, I looked at him and he tried to explain the blood. Right off I knew he was lying when he started trying to smirk and started waving his hands like it wasn't a big deal. He said that he had "cut his fu**ing hand and he needed to wash up." So I nodded my head in the direction of the bathroom and told him that it was over where he had come from. It appeared to me that he was going to jump me for my car if I hadn't have stood up and reached for my knife. I drove off immediately and called the cops. The cops called me back and asked for my version of the guys story and said that all of the seven guys had different stories as to why there was blood on them, so I guess the mere presence of my knife saved the day.
 
I had a couple instances where I was kind extrememly pleased to have a knife on me in an urban environment

one we were camped just out of Perth , West Aus, near a river , when three carloads of teenagers pulled up , with a couple serious hardcore lookig dudes among them looking about mid 30s ... they went for a swim , got pretty drunk , and the girls in their crew began making out and carrying on

We were eating late lunch , that happened to be steak Id bought earlier , just as Id decided it was enough , time to pack up and go rather than put up with their racket , .. I wiped my Opinel off and flicked it shut ( I love the sound a well worn opinel makes when you flick them open or shut ) and slipped it back in its belt pouch as I stood up ... as I did it , one of the older guys kinda locked eyes with me , one of them seconds that last for minutes sorta , I deliberately left the pouch open , and he watched me do that , nodded , and began calling his crew into order , within minutes they all had packed up and left , as the last car went past , the one with the girls in it I heard them one saying "why are we leaving , I thought the guys were going to rumble the campers ?"

It turns out that there is a few gang bashings of people who camp there , its a bit too close to some pot farms , so bashing the campers is one way of discouraging anyone finding the farms , and a "good" way for the younger ones in the families involved to let off steam .

another time we had been camping our way around Au again , and were on the last stop of the trip , so we actually paid for a site in a caravan park at Nowra NSW , my cousin and I stopped up kinda late discussing the trip and the things we has seen and done ... we heard a ruckus out in the street , people fighting , then it went quiet , ... barely a minte later a figure aproached us where we stood taking , my cousin was holding is new baby son , the stranger wore a hoody , and had something inhis pocket that turned out to be a sharpened screwdriver , he produced it when he told us it was his intention to kill some white #$%@ tonight , it went unsaid that I am fair skinned and my cousin is "white" ...

I summed up the situation but it wasnt great , I had my knife , the opinel that kinda doubles as a flick knife , I figured I could have it out and use it before he did real damage to my cousin or the baby , but the way we were situated , it wasnt good , the risk of him hurting the baby was too big for me to act from where I was standing .

I decided to try just talking rather than acting .. figuring the guy hadnt just stabbed us , but talked first , maybe keep it going some and get between my cousin and the stranger , then take him down .. I asked him ( in a pleasant casually interested kinda way ) if he was in the fight we heard , he had been , and got flogged , and was going to kill some white #$%@ to fix it ... but he put his screwdriver back in his hoody pocket tho he still held it ...

I was encouraged , it wold give me an extra second or two if it got ugly , and asked him if he really wanted to fix his worries , he stopped his foot jigging and listened , so I offered to show him in the Bible where he could find the answer to his trouble ... I didnt have a bible tho or any idea what to show him if I did ... but it would give me reason to be real close and between my cousin and him ...

he had a serious attitude shift tho , went sort of shame faced and said he should look at it but not to night .. and he began walking then jogging away , stopping long enough to yell back that he was still going to kill some white #$%@ tonight tho ...

I was glad to have had my knife , even tho I never used it , having it gave me a plan b , and a confidence boost that I had a plan to work to instead of having only to rely on wits alone to talk my way out . Having it gave me the confidence to show no fear , and I guess act like I was not afraid but ready to take the guy on if he didnt want to play nice .

After tho , My cousin just grinned and said "that bible thing kinda came out of left field , I was waiting for you to take him down , but that was cool , you did it the lazy way and didnt even raise a sweat "

after the kid ran off , I was sweating and shaking plenty tho ... adrenaline overload I guess :)

another one of them longest 60 seconds of my life :)
 
Great read Myal :thumbup:. Seems like our knives came in handy even if they weren't drawn. Mine at the time was my Emerson Commander, I'm glad it was a waved knife too, quick draw and effective.
 
I usually do have a Bible close by. I've never thought of disarming someone with it but that was a great story!

What a victory- you won without ever striking a blow. Maybe he went home to rethink his life?
 
I usually do have a Bible close by. I've never thought of disarming someone with it but that was a great story!

What a victory- you won without ever striking a blow. Maybe he went home to rethink his life?

I never thought of it as a victory , then , and now , I think of it more as a close shave , being luck to have gotten out unscathed

Just me I guess .

Im hoping he did do a rethink on his life tho
 
Can I play too?

I'm really liking the Becker BK17 I just got, I think it is going to be my do it all blade.

100_0309.jpg
 
OOOH, Zombie Thread! I'll play:

Urban or woods, the "best" knife is the one you have. That said, if you live by the Boy Scout motto, you will always be prepared. I always carry a strong folder and a multitool on my person. In my vehicles there are always a hefty fixed blade, and if I'm venturing off the beaten path, an axe and saw.

The point is (HAHA - see what I did there?) be able to use whatever you have to your best advantage:)
 
I too agree with the woodsman trio of small axe/hawk-medium fixed blade-small folder.
If I don't have an axe then I would want my Becker BK9 for a chopper, either my M.D. Caldwell 1-5 or my BK16 for my medium bushcraft knife and then I'd like to have my Gerber FAST draw(partially serrated) which should come in handy from time to time.
 
Bear Grylls ultimate knife plain edge..I recievd this knife for Christmas last year and its my kayak camping fixed blade..I like it..
CD
 
Back
Top