Buyer Beware

Of course. Why wouldn't it work the same as washers? There's just more lee-way on how loose/tight you can get with bearing pivots as compared to washers, since a torqued down bearing will still roll while a washer will become essentially friction-sealed shut.
Why wouldn't it work the same at washers? Because it is unnecessary.
 
In three separate posts you’ve accused the seller of knowingly selling you a defective knife when there’s no evidence that he/she had any reason to know the knife was defective. That this mysterious seller intentionally ripped you off is the whole point of your OP. Since the evidence you give suggests precisely the opposite, I think it’s a ridiculous post. Not the first here, and won’t be the last.


Agreed
 
In three separate posts you’ve accused the seller of knowingly selling you a defective knife when there’s no evidence that he/she had any reason to know the knife was defective. That this mysterious seller intentionally ripped you off is the whole point of your OP. Since the evidence you give suggests precisely the opposite, I think it’s a ridiculous post. Not the first here, and won’t be the last.

^^^ This. The knife was fine when you got it, but the seller somehow saw into the future that it was going to develop issues. Right................. One buyer I never want to deal with.
 
Can you even adjust the pivot on a knife with bearings? I'm asking sincerely, as I didn't think you could.

You actually can. I had a ZT 0450CF not too long ago, and all ZTs run on KVT ball bearings. You can adjust them just like you could with a blade run on washers. This is because (unlike washers) the ball bearings are recessed into the handle scales so they are flush, essentially working as washers with less contact surface area and less overall static and kinetic friction as a result of the rotating balls.
 
Not to be a dick but if he was trying to scam you he probably wouldn't have given you the custom scales with it, if he knew he was going to get pinched with a defective knife he would have tried to make every cent back.

He could have easily sent it to spyderco himself also.

No such thing as an honest scammer.
 
To the OP, I don't believe it was a scam. If he knew he had a defective knife, he wouldn't have spent the extra money making it his own, and he certainly wouldn't have sold you it with all the pricey upgrades.
 
To the OP, I don't believe it was a scam. If he knew he had a defective knife, he wouldn't have spent the extra money making it his own, and he certainly wouldn't have sold you it with all the pricey upgrades.
That is kind of what I thought also.
 
T tjweeks
Before you damage your reputation any more than you have,why don't you do the right thing and apologize to the fella that sold the knife to you and close this tread. You have made your point.
 
T tjweeks
Before you damage your reputation any more than you have,why don't you do the right thing and apologize to the fella that sold the knife to you and close this tread. You have made your point.

Since you said that, what's his point?

I don't even remember the name of the seller.

Secondly, he doesn't remember who sold him the knife, so who should he apologize to?

Lastly, if T tjweeks said that he had been abducted by aliens, or that he had had a few too many, before he wrote his OP, then this whole thing would makes sense. But, until then, I feel like I'm on a short-bus, to nowhere.
 
First, I’m super happy to know that Spyderco is willing to make the knife right. I love my Southards (and they flip great!) but I have never been completely comfortable with the craptastic washers.

Second, the last time I oiled my user Southard the action went straight to the toilet, barely open worse. My Southard likes to be run nearly dry. If the OP’s crapped out after oiling, it doesn’t surprise me at all.

Third, $149 for a Southard with CF and original scales that’s been tuned by the manufacturer? Sign me up for one!
 
Last edited:
If the knife flipped fine when you got it and then got worse after you continued to flip it, I don’t think the seller sold it to you knowing the washers were bad. I’m speaking from experience, because I had the same issue with my Southard. It flipped fine at first and within a short time began to degrade.

Also, I sent my knife to Spyderco and they claimed it had been disassembled, even thought i bought it new from an authorized dealer and never disassembled it (I knew better not to).

In the end, you got a great knife at a great price. Enjoy.
I have since learned that a pretty common procedure with the Southard knives that have flattened their washers is to squirt a lot of oil into the pivot, screw the pivot down as hard as you can and then work the blade back and forth by hard for about an hour. After that it will work like new until it quits and that is why you might buy a used Southard that you got a good deal on and then a month later it quits flipping. Everybody has been calling me a dumb ass around here because I fell for this exact same thing. If you look around at used knives you will start seeing Southards, Advocates and several other spyderco Southard knives going for a great price. I sent mine back to Spyderco but because the guy I bought it from had put a custom scale on it, they said it had been modded and opened up and they denied the claim even they know damn good and well that this is a real problem. I feel for anyone that buys one of their Paysans because they are showing a lock related problem that spyderco will have to figure out how to blame it on the customers for their screwed up $500 knives. IU will probably catch a bunch of troll mail for this one but sooner or later you will get screwed with one too-who's laughing then?>
 
Gaston-You can kiss my ---and you too Beak 14. It's guys like you that ruin any kind of posting. You always have to try and make someone who very well might know a lot more about knives than you wish they had never shared. Thanks Buddy's
 
Gaston-You can kiss my ---and you too Beak 14. It's guys like you that ruin any kind of posting. You always have to try and make someone who very well might know a lot more about knives than you wish they had never shared. Thanks Buddy's

Dude, what? Why are you calling out Gaston? All he did was say "Agreed" to a post that was accurate.


You said this:
I have neither slandered nor said anything angry or wrong about the fellow who sold me that knife.
which was patently false. The thread is titled "Buyer Beware", which could be construed as being about either the seller or Spyderco Southards, but when you say what I've set in bold it leads many to believe you were talking about the seller.

I very rarely buy a used knife-maybe 3 times. I guess I just am not the trustful kind. Anyway about 2 months back I saw a Spyderco Southard with some nice extra's at a good price. I have always really liked the looks of the Southard. I have I black but this was originally a tan with satin blade. The owner had swapped out the stock scale for a carbon fiber and it looks good. I got it pretty quickly and started working it. Open--Close-----. It seemed to be ok. Blade was centered. After too much longer though it started getting less smooth flipping and closing. Then it struck me, this must be one of those Southards with the screwed up washers. I guess the seller figured this was a good time to get rid of it-thus the good price. Anyway, I sent it back to Spyderco thinking maybe they would make it right because it is a known problem. Where I screwed up was leaving the carbon fiber scale on it. Thanks to that it cost me 20 bucks. Spyderco is serious about not modifying your knife. Oh well, at least I will have a kind of new knife. It ism a little disappointing though that this guy sold me what he knew was a problem knife. I don't think I would ever do that.,

No and from the pictures and descriptions you could not tell. I thought I had just run into a great deal. It had a custom Carbon Fiber scale with original scale included. A custom titanium clip and the knife was impeccable. He had taken great care of the knife that's why I thought I had gotten a great deal. I can't say for sure he knew about the problems involved with the Southard washers and bearings but I think he did and was going to get rid of it while the getting was good.

That may be true but he sold a knife worth $400 (with customs) for $129 (so how dumb am I?). From what I have read about the Southard problem, most owners start torqueing down on the pivot screw when it first starts acting up and it is a temp. fix. But after you torque down on them it will work ok for a while and then it starts grabbing. I had only flipped it a half a dozen times when I first got it and it seemed fine. Then I put it away until a couple of weeks ago and took it out to oil it and noticed it would no longer flip all the way. I would flip it hard and it would go a little over half way open and stop. It also would not close well. I guess it is not a big deal because Spyderco has it now and they are only charging $20 to fix it and it IS a beautiful knife. I was just put out because the seller snuck it in on me.


I would say that people lashing out for no reason is a more likely reason to make people not want to post.:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
...I sent mine back to Spyderco but because the guy I bought it from had put a custom scale on it, they said it had been modded and opened up and they denied the claim even they know damn good and well that this is a real problem...

So is Spyderco refusing to fix your knife or is your crank just bent out of shape because they’re charging you $20?

I’d seriously like to know.
 
So is Spyderco refusing to fix your knife or is your crank just bent out of shape because they’re charging you $20?

I’d seriously like to know.
Actually it is that my crank is just bent out of shape. I have kind of had a grudge against Spyderco because of their lack of compassion towards their customers. I have dealt quite a few times with Benchmade and Zero Tolerance and they are always ready to try to keep their fans happy. Do you need a couple of free pocket clips or some other thing you just give them a call. They don't even ask for postage. When you read Spyderco's warranty it seems like they are just telling you all the things they won't do for you. With the prices on many of the Spyderco's you would think they would be a little more giving. I know this is kind of childish on my part but it seems like anytime I have had an up close with Spyderco I end up angry. I think the Southards kind of pissed me off. I have really liked that knife since it first came out but at $270 I just could not swing it. Then the rumors started coming out about the bad washers on the Brad Southard knives and within a week Spyderco dropped it from $270 to $179. They knew by then they were selling a knife with a problem. That's what pissed me off with this debacle about fixing my knife. Twenty dollars really isn't shit but the fact that they knew it was faulty parts and they billed me because the previous owner switched out one of the scales. It was like they were looking at any little thing to charge me for their funky washers. On top of that they charged me return postage. I guess maybe Benchmade has spoiled me because that whole ordeal would not have cost me a penny and they would have included a letter of apology. It will be interesting when the Paisans start flowing back in for repair. If you just spent $520 for a knife that they know (at this time) that has a problem. I wonder if they will be trying to make some extra bucks for anything they can find wrong like a slightly scratched torx screw on the handle. Sorry for all the whining.
 
Weird how my first batch Southard still works fine today.

Sounds like you like some other brands. Best bet is to stick with those and you won't have people poking holes in your story.
 
E5F0B3FC-646A-405C-8784-9FF53875D8A2.jpeg
Weird how my first batch Southard still works fine today.

Sounds like you like some other brands. Best bet is to stick with those and you won't have people poking holes in your story.

Mine too. Got this one when they first came out and it is a keeper. Liked it so much I put a custom scale on it and carry it constantly.
No issues with action at all.
 
Back
Top