This makes sense. Especially if you can handle the volume.
Nathan said he would try to do 10 LCs for next week. The fact he said try, rather than I will do 10 leads me to believe 10 is pushing the limit of his production capacity at the moment.
Nothing wrong with that. We're here for the quality, not the quantity. I am sure no one wants to see a reduction of quality for an increase in quantity.
The problem with a list is what happens is a bunch of time and energy is spent on management of it, for no benefit to CPK. They just end up managing it. People need to be contacted, change their minds, do they prepay or not, deposit? Then refunds and waiting to hear back, just a lot of trouble. Then there is also nothing coming out onto the market to help build the brand with.
So I don't think either or is great. Maybe a combination of both works. A short list for people who can't play the post game, and the post game for people who can?
Sure the current sales model has it's drawbacks as well, but that is part of the deal right now. A lot of people are just jumping into the thread trying to get one without much preparation. There is a learning curve to it. I probably spent 2 hours researching previous posts, results of replies, frequency of models and options, as well as streamlining my strategy to win at the first past the post game. I spent time experimenting with refresh frequency and timing my computer to understand the posted time at BF and my PCs time. When to use a keyboard shortcut, when to use the mouse. Where to have things set up on my monitors, and how to occupy my toddler. Hell I even put my wireless mouse on a cord to make sure it didn't lag or cut out.
I shared my strategy with a friend here, and he also won on every try he has made. As people participate in threads they will improve their process, get their knife then withdraw and the next people will get one. Yes there will be some people who don't have time to be here, etc but you can't please all the people all the time. Perhaps a list is best suited for them. Sometimes a person will try for months and not get one, and someone will win relatively quick into the game. That is the nature of it.
The main occurrence I would get upset with is if someone is winning the post and buying them all up just to resell at a profit. I don't think that will be allowed.