Yup..thats what I am saying.
If you shoot someone in New England, while out hiking, for kicking sand in your face..you will end up in the pen. I don't care if its fair or not. You will get arrested on the spot, you will go to jail on the spot, you will...need a lawyer.
I am a big fan of guns, and the right to defend one's self...I am also not living in la la land, where I think I can blast someone for any reason anymore.
Unless you are in your home, or on your OWN property, shooting someone (even being fully justified) you are going to jail..maybe for a week..or maybe for years. Does it matter?
What I am saying, is that sometimes, you can do the right thing, and be wrong.
I would love to really get the mods pissed and ask this. Tell me of all the "plenty of times" its ok to shoot someone...really, tell us about it.
I think that when you back up from the keyboard, and get in your car with your pistola strapped, you go out there in the world, when do you shoot? When your in a store, and a clerk has a tweeker pointing a sawed off at them? When your in the bank, and guys with masks barge in screaming "get down!!", When someone jumps in your car and tells you that they know a secret code to save the world, and your in great danger........??. Come on, this isn't a movie, its a day hiking, and somehow, the OP got in some weirdo's head, and the guy acted out. It happens.
If the OP went back and broke the jerks nose, I wouldn't have said it was wrong...I would defend him. IF he shot him for endangering his girlfriend, I would have defended his actions, while sitting in a restaurant talking about the " guy they arrested for shooting a guy for cutting a rope"...thats just the way it is.
I believe in the right to carry 100%, and I know when its better to be judged by twelve than carried by six, but when to use that right isn't up to us anymore. I don't think its fair, but I know what will happen if I shot someone while out hiking.
EDIT: Devilpig, I write like I talk, so when I say "you" I don't mean "you" entirely...imagine me waving my hands and on a rant, and you have my speach here.