Just about every knife I've bought since 1995 will handle the cutting work I need my knives to do, and I tend not to have duplicates of the same knife (shush -- I don't consider 8 different descendants of the Elishewitz Phantom design to be 'the same knife'). So for me this is less a question of capability than of sentiment. If I absolutely had to get rid of all my other knives, which would be the last one that got put on eBay?
The most likely answer is the vintage Benchmade 886SBT Blue Star that my wife got for me as a birthday present, 15-odd years after it was discontinued. She's also gotten me a blurple PM2, but I'd have a lot less trouble finding another one of those in the future.
Otherwise, probably the first "real" knife I bought for myself, a Benchmade 700S Tsunami. If you want to get super nitpicky, the little Ford penknife that belonged to my late father would probably go after both of those, but I don't really count that one as being in the same class with them.
On the other side of the coin, the one I'd let go first would probably be the Cold Steel Voyager tanto, with the Beretta Airlight probably #2. Nothing terrible about either one, but the Voyager is the definition of disposable and the Airlight has never really grabbed me.
The most likely answer is the vintage Benchmade 886SBT Blue Star that my wife got for me as a birthday present, 15-odd years after it was discontinued. She's also gotten me a blurple PM2, but I'd have a lot less trouble finding another one of those in the future.
Otherwise, probably the first "real" knife I bought for myself, a Benchmade 700S Tsunami. If you want to get super nitpicky, the little Ford penknife that belonged to my late father would probably go after both of those, but I don't really count that one as being in the same class with them.
On the other side of the coin, the one I'd let go first would probably be the Cold Steel Voyager tanto, with the Beretta Airlight probably #2. Nothing terrible about either one, but the Voyager is the definition of disposable and the Airlight has never really grabbed me.
Last edited: